>there are people on this board RIGHT NOW who think Siamese

>>74222010
It is becuase it's not 9 years long and mostly filler

>>74222018
What filler?

>>74222010
I would put both at about the same level.

Mellon Collie is such an expansive experience, but what Siamese Dream lacks in variation compared to MCATIS it makes up for in it's amazing production. The guitar tones on SD are god tier.

it is you cunt

>>74222018
Lmao fucking, this.

>>74222010
Because it is. Mellon Collie is still great and a lot more innovative than SD, but literally every song on SD is god-tier and the album just flows amazingly well.

Also, most underrated SP song coming through:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T2tX99ODVDQ

>>74222010
Which one had Fuck You (An Ode to No One)? That's the best one.

why is billy such a pretentious weirdo now?

>>74222055
We only come out at night is not a real song

Eh, neither album really does anything for me; not a huge Sonic Youth fan

>>74223264
>now
he always was senpai

>there are people on this forum who prefer Smashing Pumpkins over Zwan.

Can't believe you people. No, I don't wanna go for a ride with you,

>There are people ITT right now that believe that soft rock and alt rock Pumpkins is better than hard rock pumpkins

KEK and the Infinite Normies

>>74223277
u take that back

>>74223177
this post is right.

Favorite songs on each?
Siamese Dream: Geek USA, Hummer
Melon Collie: Jellybelly, 1979

>>74222010
yeah there are, im right here fucko

well... they ain't wrong.

>>74225047
Hummer is a perfect song if I ever heard one.

>>74223177
This
>>74225047
Top 3:
Siamese Dream: Mayonaise, Cherub Rock, Soma
Mellon Collie: Thru the Eyes of Ruby, Zero, Jellybelly

>>74223177
This song is great. Never listened to SP past Mellon Collie, still debating if I should.