One of these threads.

>>74152568
eric

>>74152568
t. nu-male

File: pf.png (2MB, 1984x1616px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1984x1616px

>>74152540
imagine being this contrarian

>>74152568
>le rap is bad

>>74152568
bait

>>74152617
hardest agree

>>74152585
does this term even have any meaning anymore? I thought nu males loved rap

>>74152540
>hating WYWH and Animals
>loving Barrett this fucking much

Barrett era Floyd is shit btw, psychedelic rock is mostly a garbage genre

>>74152819
They claim to love it just to give fake points to blacks.
obviously they don't actually listen to the music considering how TPAB is considered a generation defining and genre defining instant classic when it's mediocre shit.

>>74152568
sell me on Person Pitch, I've tried forcing myself through it like 20 times now and I've not once been able to finish listening to it, and I have not even remotely enjoyed a single song from it.

File: kc.png (1MB, 2289x1017px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2289x1017px

objectively true

>>74152906
pretty much completely agree, Discipline is really something special.

>>74152540
goddamn OP you are edgy as fuck

>>74152906
I can agree with this. Islands and In The Wake Of's scores should be swapped though... Greg Lake was halfway out of the door doing stuff with ELP at that point so was barely putting any effort in, and half the other band members had left.

>The Division Bell is bad

Go listen to High Hopes live, either by Pink Floyd or David Gilmour on his own.

>>74152568
Can you name those albums for me bud?

>>74153359
One song that works well live doesn't make a shitty album not shit

>>74152540
This is some next-level contrarian shitposting, and this is coming from a person who doesn't even like Pink Floyd.

File: PJ4chan.png (439KB, 988x604px) Image search: [Google]

439KB, 988x604px

Here's one for Pearl Jam.

The first three albums are amazing with Vitalogy being one of my favorite albums of all time. No Code is great. Yield is decent but much of it is forgettable. Binaural is good and is best when listened to as a full album. Riot Act is decent. Self Titled is the best thing they've made since the original three albums. Backspacer has two good tracks and the rest is generic as hell. Lightning Bolt was a disaster - besides Mind your Manners, the album is awful.

>>74152540
>Being this contrarian

>>74153359
Its a decent 7, better than everything else post wall

File: singer, roger waters, photos, young, pink floyd, guitar.jpg (20KB, 336x500px) Image search: [Google]

20KB, 336x500px

>>74152540
>Syd Barrett is good
Classic meme. Let's let the real adults write songs now though.

Le upvoted redditor. Supreme patrician taste. *nods respectfully in your direction*

>>74152814
ebin

File: Kanye.png (727KB, 1540x402px) Image search: [Google]

727KB, 1540x402px

>Inb4 Kanye-Stan complains I didn't give everything he ever released a 10/10

>>74152540
>WYWH anywhere below 8
dropped

>>74153916
dont worry this isnt reddit

does anyone have a template?

>>74153916
Pretty accurate, though I'd give MBDTF a 6, Yeezus a 5 and TLOP a 3.

File: opinions.png (556KB, 1775x863px) Image search: [Google]

556KB, 1775x863px

>>74153916

>>74153916
Imagine giving Graduation a higher score than 808s.

File: Gentle Giant.jpg (377KB, 1547x1013px) Image search: [Google]

377KB, 1547x1013px

>>74152617
No way they actually believe that. You putting Meddle and Piper above DSOTM seems all too disturbingly real to me.

File: Queen.jpg (529KB, 2595x1119px) Image search: [Google]

529KB, 2595x1119px

Roast me /mu/!

>>74155032
A night at the opera is their best but it's an 8/10

>>74155120
If you consider that a 8/10, then there must not be anything you consider as 9, 10, or God Tier!

>>74154141
accurate as fuck. good job

>>74152814
fugg :DDDD

>>74152871
same here, somebody pls explain what makes this album not garbage

>>74155144
Certainly not by Queen.

>>74153421
pearl jam is garbage though

>>74153916
>CD an 8 and LR a 9
you right

>>74154141
CD ok
LR -> 7
Grad -> 5
808s -> 6.5
MBDTF -> 7
yeezus -> 6.5
pablo -> 6

>>74152568
r u gay? lol

Template?

>>74155017
I do actually believe that, I maybe would consider making Meddle a 10 and Saucerful a 7. I've seen your GG chart before too, good taste but Acquiring the Taste is at least a 9

>>74155285
Asunder should be a 9, my bad

>>74155240
can someone fucking post a template

>>74155365
No

File: 1500068216605.jpg (73KB, 843x928px) Image search: [Google]

73KB, 843x928px

>>74155365
save it

>>74155392
thank (you)

File: 1494433518342.jpg (120KB, 740x737px) Image search: [Google]

120KB, 740x737px

>>74152540
>saucerful not better than piper

>>74155415
>le middle aged jewish women meme

>>74155269
I put AtT below Free Hand and TPatG bc all of their better songs are on a similar level, but AtT's lesser songs are worse than than the others.

Meddle is ~ 8 for me and DSotM is 10 or God Tier.

File: GGiant.png (2MB, 1547x1013px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1547x1013px

>>74155017
i made my version

Someone pls do Radiohead, I would do one myself but I'm in bed atm. Might do one tomorrow.

File: kc rating.png (1MB, 2146x980px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2146x980px

>>74152906
I sort-of agree, I guess

good to know antz still baits the hell out of this shitty board

>>74155188
nice meme

>>74156088
TPAB is worse than DAMN

>>74156153
this

File: ah FUCK.png (1MB, 2198x415px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2198x415px

>>74156153
+1

File: 1500541535733.jpg (1MB, 2968x2008px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2968x2008px

do i dare post this heartwarming autism

>>74154141
change mbdtf to a 7, 808s to a 9, and cruel summer to a 5

>>74156153
>>74156196
>>74156235
Its literally not, though. Damn is worse musically, conceptually, and just generally.

Damn is only good after about half of the songs are over.

>>74156235
>Sung Tongs and Painting With on the same level

>>74156337
I'd probably give People a 10 but overall correct ratings. The Bible 2 was also really good in a live setting so I'd give it a 9.
Althought I give ANDREW JACKSON JIHAD -5000 points for changing their name

>>74156732
b8

>>74157005
>calls it b8
>still replies to it
You just made it worse

>>74157005

>this chart is not accurate to my shit taste
>must be b8

File: radiohead.png (323KB, 614x720px) Image search: [Google]

323KB, 614x720px

>>74156732
hilarious

>>74157137
>must be b8
b8

>>74152795
Such great b8 u forgot the last 3

>>74156732

accurate

>>74157139

kill yourself

>>74153916
give Pablo a 7 and this is perfect

>>74156732
I legit agree with this

File: blink182.png (581KB, 843x928px) Image search: [Google]

581KB, 843x928px

one for blink-182

tried to be charitable

>>74152871
listen to it louder

File: QGrx05j.jpg (53KB, 460x743px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 460x743px

>>74157449
I have nothing to add to this, except when a classmate of mine showed me The Mark, Tom and Travis Show, I learned about masturbation for the first time.

I had completely forgotten about that until I saw your chart, thank you.

>>74157448
Horrible

>>74158293
glad to help

I don't recommend revisiting the album unless you're jonesing for unpleasant flashbacks, learned that the hard way

>>74158294
elaborate

>>74153385

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pitchfork_(website)#Pitchfork_Album_of_the_Year

>>74152568
>bon iver, 9
>kendrick 1,shit

kys

>>74152749

>meteora not a 9

hmmm