Should music be made entirely on computers?

why the fuck does it matter how something is made

>>74100028
t. someone who isn't a musician

>>74100131
professional musician with a degree

it doesn't matter which instrument is used, process only matters if it's novel and artistic a la Cage/Browne etc.

don't be a child

>>74099781
Computers
Mixing Desk
Tape Machine
Gramophone

What difference does it make?

>>74099781

Are friends electric?

>>74099781
Rap has always been sample based and electronic has always been electronic. Not sure why you posted this tbqh

>>74100149
a degree in music theory? or recording. there's a difference between difference between tracking a guitar with stompboxes, an amp, and microphones, as opposed to plugging in into an interface and using plugin effects.
plus there's this
http://djbooth.net/news/entry/2016-01-05-tm88-thinks-i-hate-him

>>74100569
"electronic" doesn't necessarily mean computers. like in that article, tm88 made like 6 songs in 2 hours. sure laptops and computers can be beneficial, making music quicker and easier, you can also end up with a quantitative approach to music. plus a lot (not all but most) rapper-producer pairs or groups used to hang out in the studio and bounce ideas off each other, now it could literally be a random person on soundcloud with some random beat, that could be your "producer". the process *does* affect the end outcome, believe it or not.

>>74100728
>the process *does* affect the end outcome, believe it or not.
This is really only relevant to the user. Computers don't have to negatively impact anything, and they enable a lot of worthwhile territory that isn't otherwise possible. It really doesn't make a difference, use whatever works for you.

>>74100728
It's not like you can't quickly churn out grindcore or noise without a computer. Or Van Morrison's contractual obligation album. He recorded 31 songs in probably an hour.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BgkvlSsZiLQ

I don't really care, there's no real upside to analog production beyond some audiophile snake oil and the fact that it can make weird noises for avant-garde music. I, do, however, hold the opinion that non-analog mastered music being pressed on cassette or vinyl is a total fucking meme.