>A 3.5 album
>>74085172
is better than a 7.3 album
>perhaps the Jimmy Eat World's best record since Bleed American
What did Pitchfork mean by this?
>>74085187
two different people wrote the reviews you fucking mushbrain
>>74085265
>getting asspained over Jimmy Eat World
Take a hike.
Threads like these are why I visit mu
>>74085265
still retarded that they're so inconsistent
>>74085265
Pitchfork writers groupthink the scores, they are not assigned by the writers iirc. Either way tho hipster Pitchfork writers from 2001 are not the same hipster Pitchfork writers from 2017. Expecting them to be consistent over time with different people is a ridiculous standard and allows disallows them the freedom of changing their mind.