Rate an artist's Albums

File: mu album rating scale.jpg (73KB, 843x928px) Image search: [Google]

73KB, 843x928px

Template

>>74019636
Dude Oasis rule !!!!!

File: 1492083185995.jpg (52KB, 870x570px) Image search: [Google]

52KB, 870x570px

Pablo Honey
>7
The Bends
>7.5
Ok Computer
>8
Kid A
>God Tier
Amnesiac
>9
Hail to the Thief
>God Tier
In Rainbows
>9
The King of Limbs
>8
A Moon Shaped Pool
>9

>>74019636
Gay/10

>>74019849
>MHTRTC
8
>Geogaddi
God Tier
>Campfire Headphase
7
>Tomorrows Harvest
God Tier

>>74021091
>Debut better than Vespertine, Post, Biophilia, AND Vulnicura

fucking kys

>>74019683
the worst list

>>74019683
>calls one bland british alt rock band "gay"
>posts embarrassingly overinflated rantings of another bland british alt rock band's discography

File: suede_disco_r8.png (1MB, 1440x1118px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1440x1118px

>>74019636

JNew
>MEM
8
>Ys
God
>Ys Street Band
9
>HOoM
10
>Divers
7

>>74021222
Objectively true, trips confirm

>>74021931
Switch reactions for Bloodsports and Night Thoughts and I agree.

File: bors.png (3MB, 1848x2496px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1848x2496px

hot off the press

File: animal collective.jpg (442KB, 1200x1400px) Image search: [Google]

442KB, 1200x1400px

This is tough because I rounded up for a lot of these.

>>74023041
why do you hate black people, anon?

File: sqp.jpg (295KB, 1500x930px) Image search: [Google]

295KB, 1500x930px

Yes Ufabulum is good, fuck your meme opinion

>>74023041
Haha, you're so white it's comical

>>74023324
if you were trying to be funny, you failed.

and if this is actually how you feel then you're retarded.

>>74023041
You're def the prep white kid I beat up in high school

>>74024006
Is this bait?

File: IMG_9001.jpg (95KB, 490x479px) Image search: [Google]

95KB, 490x479px

>>74023468

>>74021804
Imo Heritage was still good, maybe a 7, but after that, shit tier

>>74021767
>(bridge)
>5
what the absolute fuck, anon? christ, i want to smack you

>>74023041
>literal nu-male

File: sorrydigitalshades.png (2MB, 2012x1632px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 2012x1632px

>>74024438
I forgot Digital Shades Vol. 1

>>74019654
XD

>>74023041
kek

>>74024613
i agree with this 80%

>>74025535
London?

>>74021222
Hoop Life is the best music ever constructed by man

>>74025848
Legitimate fucking yikes anon. Women as Lovers that fucking low? Dear God that fucking low? Forget that fucking high? La Foret is their best, the Air Force is at least a 7, Always is literally just Dear God but with weaker songs, and you left out Unclouded Sky and Twin Peaks

File: Screen Shot 2017-06-18 at 2.38.31 PM.png (2MB, 1366x768px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1366x768px

>>74021767
patrish

>>74025848
Alright I'll fix it for you

>Knife Play
10
>A Promise
God Tier
>Fabulous Muscles
9
>La Foret
God Tier
>The Air Force
7
>Women as Lovers
9
>Dear God, I Hate Myself
8
>Always
6
>Angel Guts: Red Classroom
6
>Unclouded Sky
7
>Plays the Music of Twin Peaks
8
>Forget
7

>>74025981
>>74026084
no love for Nina?

>>74026116
Fuck, Nina completely slipped my mind, don't even know how I managed that because I actually like it quite a bit, probably an 8

>>74024613
EXMIL 10
TMS 9
NLDW 8
GP 7
NOTM 10
JD 7
BP 6

>>74019683
>Hail to the thief
>God tier
wew there lil boy

>>74024613
XM 9
TMS 10
NLDW 8
GP 6
NOTM 10
JD 8
BP 9

File: Queen.jpg (529KB, 2595x1119px) Image search: [Google]

529KB, 2595x1119px

>>74019636

>>74019683
AMSP has 2 good songs, 6/10, maybe 7/10. TKOL is a 5/10, let's be real. I agree for the most part otherwise.

File: Gentle Giant.jpg (377KB, 1547x1013px) Image search: [Google]

377KB, 1547x1013px

>>74019636
.

File: Coldplay.png (2MB, 2120x1604px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 2120x1604px

>>74025535
I respectfully disagree

>>74023149
because black people make rap only and rap isn't good genre?

>>74027478
>because black people make rap only
What is Jazz and Blues?

>>74027478
I will be expecting for your death anon

>>74021653
Makes sense given Debut is her best album

>>74023013
>Spirit not God Tier
haha okay

>>74026531
>Being this wrong

>>74024006
oai 7
itaots gt

>>74027589
why do you hate white people anon?

>>74019636
Montie, put your trip back on

>>74027838
>white people
>people
haha boi u gon lie ta em all

>>74027797
I don't understand the point of god-tier, even giving out a 10 seems generous to me a lot of the time but going beyond that makes no sense.

>>74027868
english pls

File: hqdefault.jpg (8KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

8KB, 480x360px

>>74019683
>The King of Limbs
>Anything above 5 out of 10

>>74023041
Vampire Weekend is shit and so is Solange KYS.

File: image.jpg (29KB, 416x343px) Image search: [Google]

29KB, 416x343px

>>74026817
>II higher than ST
>Opera higher than Races
>Jazz anything higher than 5
>Flash, Hot Space and Magic not Shit tier
>Innuendo lower than 8

File: katebushratings.png (1MB, 1552x939px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1552x939px

>>74019798
Anon, you accidentally switched the ratings for True Stories and Naked.

Oh and somehow you did the same with Speaking in Tongues and Remain in Light. you should be more careful!

>>74026817
>The Works at 9
My nigga

File: ninchart.jpg (362KB, 1600x1000px) Image search: [Google]

362KB, 1600x1000px

Still haven't formed an opinion on NTAE
Included remix albums cuz why not

>>74023041
The most infuriating thing about this rating is that Emergency & I is only an 8.

What the actual fuck anon?

>>74024534
Thank you oh my god, I thought Junk was so underrated

>>74028905
literally same

>>74027838
>being this ignorant
>being this lame

>>74027908
Fuck off man, you're such a white-ass vibe killer

File: Silver Mt. Zion.png (1MB, 1242x1037px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1242x1037px

>>74026854
>that Octopus rating
my man

>>74028269

Absolutely false, kill YOURself, ya fuk

>>74026870
>X & Y
>6
shit taste my man

>>74021767
I agree with most of this except for the 5 doe the jesu/sun Kil moon. That is personally one of my favorites from mark and a 9/10 for me.

>>74026084
I like this one better too

File: mm.png (780KB, 1000x1125px) Image search: [Google]

780KB, 1000x1125px

>>74030995

actually having relistened to MBIKMB i'd bump up the rating
it only clicked for me the other day

>>74023013
not bad

This is hard because I feel like a 10/10 or God Tier implies that an album has no flaws at all, but I'm extremely picky even with things considered flawless by others. For example, I found a lot of It Was Hot, We Stayed In The Water forgettable, but The Pull is so damn good it makes me want to give the whole thing a 10/10. The Glow Pt. 2 is a masterpiece, but I'm impatient as shit and it's a slog for me to get through, the middle stretch of the album feels like filler to me at least. Same with the intro to Mount Eerie. The first 10 minutes or so are terrible to me, but the rest of it is perfect. (Also the ear rapage that starts Solar System.) So to call them flawless would be insincere but I feel like it'd be wrong to give the albums too low a score.

>>74023279
This is good

>>74024613
This is pretty close to correct

>>74023041
>calling one of the greatest albums of the 21st century shit-tier
We get it. You don't like rap.

>>74031841
>a thousand suns isn't their best
What the

File: ohgodtier.png (41KB, 1200x1200px) Image search: [Google]

41KB, 1200x1200px

>>74031841
here's my custom rank if you wanna use it

>>74028150
look, the pleb filters worked.

>>74019636
This is fairly accurate, although over the years I've come to think Morning Glory doesn't sound as good as it used to.

>>74021931
lol, Coming Up is nowhere near god tier, it's decent but it's a full step down or more from the previous two
Head Music is like a 5, maybe 6 on a good day
A New Morning is flat, but the first 4 songs are good, especially Lost in TV, nowhere near a 1, maybe a 3 I'll allow.

>>74022004
On no planet is Nonsuch < Go 2 or Wasp Star, nor is O&L for that matter

>>74019849
>>74019886
>Twoism
8
>Hi Scores
8
>Music Has the Right to Children
God Tier
>In a Beautiful Place Out in the Country
6
>Geogaddi
10
>Campfire Headphase
7
>Trans Canada Highway
7
>Tomorrow's Harvest
9

>>74024613
this, i didn`t like botomless put tho

>>74032131
>Pink Floyd went to shit after Syd left

>>74032218

thats the exact opposite of what I said

>>74024006
Thisx1000

>>74024006
unironically agree except itaots is lower and oai is higher

>>74023041
Are you a homosex?

>>74032109
you literally cannot like TMS and not like Bottomless Pit

>>74032324

hi there, I like TMS and dislike bottomless pit

>>7402327
yep 100%

>>74032375
You'd probably feel the same way if TMS & BP switched songs but kept the last tracks

>>74032324
I like BP more than TMS.

>>74024613
>tms not god tier
actually fucking kill yourself

>>74023041
>being this much of a brainlet faggot
holy shit, i hate you with every fiber of my body you fucking degenerate faggot

>>74032006
yeah because u have to be PATRICCIAN to lisen 2 radiohead amirite?

>>74024613
XM: 9/10
TMS: 9/10
NLDW: 8/10
GP: 10/10
NOTM: 10/10
JD: 7/10
BP: 8/10

File: autechre.jpg (432KB, 2082x1130px) Image search: [Google]

432KB, 2082x1130px

>>74028087
I agree but ICBYD got some of his best songs (Start as You Mean to Go On, Mookid, Alberto Balsalm) I would rate it higher then a 4

>>74032812
Seventh Son 6

Fear of the dark 9

please change this, is reverse

and 8 to brave new world? why? also you forgot the dance of death, is shitty too like all the modern shit that they do

>>74022748
>Rating New Album the same as Heavy Rocks and Akuma No Uta
what the fukk

Alright here's Phil, sorry for not making a pic

>DWMU
7
>ITH,WSITW
8
>The Glow pt. 2
10
>Mount Eerie
God Tier
>NF;SOTFN
9
>Lost Wisdom
6
>Dawn
8 (God tier for comfiness)
>Wind's Poem
6
>Clear Moon
7
>Ocean Roar
10
>Sauna
9
>ACLAM
7

>>74031108
10 or God Tier doesn't have to be literally flawless, it just has to be an truly great work of art. Looking at The Glow pt, 2, some songs are better than others (though I think they're literally all good), but that doesn't dull it's overall impact. The closing instrumental on Ocean Roar goes on for wayyyy too fucking long, but that doesn't make me love the album less. Mount eerie is flawless though, including the first ten minutes, it really builds up the emotion when Phil finally sings

>>74022748
>Absolutego that low
>New Album that high
>Flood, Heavy Rocks, Akuma no Uta, and Pink not god-tier

File: 1469635503022.png (7KB, 420x420px) Image search: [Google]

7KB, 420x420px

>>74023149
>>74023262
>>74023468
>>74024517
>>74031646
>>74032313
>>74032891


rapfag filter always works.

>>74032035
>Heathen higher than The Next Day

>>74032979
>Images and Words 9/10
Seriously how can Dream Theater fans stand their cheesy ballads? They're fucking awful, not that their prog songs are that good, but at least tolerable

>>74019636
Embarassing start

>>74023041
>I listen to everything except rap and metal

Soul Discharge (1989)
10/10
Pop Tatari
9/10
Wow 2
6/10
Super Roots 5
9/10
Chocolate Synthesizer
8/10
Super ar
6/10
Super Roots 7
7.5/10
Vision Creation Newsun
8/10
Seadrum/House Of Sun
8/10
77 Boadrum
7/10

>>74028905
Nope, True Stories is by far their worst album. Naked is actually good, it just doesn't sound like Talking Heads. And Speaking in Tongues is more consistent than Remain in Light

>>74026870
agree with parachutes rush and viva
x&y 7
mylo 4.5
the last two i can't even remember 1 or 0

>>74034205
>Heathen is better than The Next Day

>>74034027
oh fuck you're right i forgot dance of shart. i really enjoyed bnw, desu, though this might be nostalgia goggles since this is the first album they made after they got dickinson back and ditched that useless singer they had for the previous 2 records.
i should've put fear of the dark at 7, though i really don't think seventh son is that great of an album

>>74034438
Speaking in Tongues is a consistent 6, RiL is veers between 7 and God Tier. Fuck Speaking in Tongues

>>74023041
white trash
worst list ive ever seen beta

>>74021804
This.

i don't understand how their music has plummeted into cheesy cancer so suddenly, it's like mikael had a seizure after watershed

but still
>orchid 8
literally one of their worst albums
>morningrise 10
actually kill yourself
>my,yh god tier
what the fuck have you been smoking? even heritage sounds better and has better lyrics than this steaming pile of cancer

>>74032131
>meddle god tier
>the wall meh tier
i'm going to celebrate when your useless life ends

>>74034914
you are seriously lonely and starved

File: Objective rating.png (2MB, 1510x1272px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1510x1272px

This

>>74032131

>meddle that high

Fearless, San Tropez and Séamus are all bollox.

>hates animals

Are you for real? it's one of their best. In fact, I'm going to listen to it now.

File: gorillaz.jpg (270KB, 904x1040px) Image search: [Google]

270KB, 904x1040px

discuss

>>74030625
>"Born into Trouble" and "13 Moons" that low

>>74033098
no foxtrot?

>>74021825
t. Montie

>>74023468
Preppy white kids listen exclusively to hip-hop.

>>74019636
something about montie

>>74035468
Gorillaz: 6/10
Demon Days: 7/10
Plastic Beach: 8/10
Humanz: 2/10
Haven't listened to the other ones

>>74035712
"The Fall" is skippable, but "D-Sides" is way better then simply a b-side collection.
Although I'm a Gorillaz fanboy desu

>>74035752
Will you please get off my board

>>74019683
C'mon, you can't call Oasis gay and think Radiohead's THAT good XD faggot

>>74023041
I'm pretty sure you posted this because you secretly enjoy being bashed on by other people

>>74035827
no 10 day?

File: 1499377242660.jpg (11KB, 320x320px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 320x320px

>>74035789
Abbreviated "to be honest" on the end of the post is autoreplaced with desu

>>74035468
S/t 8, Plastic Beach 8, Demon Dayz god tier, Humanz 5, The Fall 5, D Sides 6.

File: smashing-pumpkins-90s.jpg (53KB, 456x304px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 456x304px

Because I love them

Gish 6/10
Siamese Dream 10/10
Mellon Collie & the Infinite Sadness 7/10
Adore 7.5/10
Machina I & II errrBilly/10
Zeitgeist FUCKING HELL BILLY/10
Oceania Billyplz/10
Monuments to an Elegy RIPbilly/10

File: 1444687384658.png (173KB, 285x316px) Image search: [Google]

173KB, 285x316px

>>74035806
not him but
>taking seriously the opinions of underage strangers on a meme site famous for being racist and helped the election of trump

>>74032131
Where is Wish you were here ???

>>74036037
Second row, second from the right

>>74034981
Switch think tank and magic whip and i agree.
Because i know thats what you always wanted my son.

>>74035468
Gorillaz 8/10
Demon Days 9/10
Plastic Beach 8/10
Humanz 2/10

File: the.jpg (750KB, 2344x2400px) Image search: [Google]

750KB, 2344x2400px

>>74019636

>>74033955
Christ and I thought animal collective fans were cringey

File: circa survive.png (2MB, 1532x1212px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1532x1212px

>>74036297
Octahedron wasn't that bad

>>74035468
7, 9, 7, 8, 5, 1

i have yet to see someone in this thread with actual good taste in music. it's just a bunch of contrarian hipster faggots, obvious bait and absolute degenerate retards

>>74036525
Are you always this much of a bitch?

>>74036297
>Goliath that low
>the last one that high
WEW LAWD

>>74032057
Go 2 has the rhythm so it's automatically better than nonsuch, which to me is a very bland forgettable album. Wasp star is pretty good, should've given it a 7. But O&R is awful apart from the first three songs and the last song, I have no reason why it's loved so much.

>>74021767
PAINFULLY bad taste.

>>74023041
Anon either hates hip hop or black people

File: e9d.jpg (18KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 600x600px

>>74036292

>>74035796
Montie?

>>74023041
pitchfork taste is so inconsistent

>>74023041
>all those replies
>cant like hip-hop else youre a racist

>>74036958
Pretty sure people were memeing, i was atleast

>>74026870
This guy gets it

>>74021091
>>
love it

>>74032035
>Aladdin Sane that high
that album is so overrated

>>74033955
>Yes, this anon is a fag

>>74033098
do Peter Gabriel

>>74032872
this is how I know you're a filthy casual

>>74036319
how the fuck do you think cherry bomb is a 4 and goblin is a fucking 8

>>74033964
the album didnt stick that much to me, so eh

im still kinda getting into autechre and here are my rates so far

>Incunabula 9
>Amber 7
>Tri Repetae 9
>Exai 8

i need to give exai a couple more listen though the next couple days, most of their stuff is great so far though

>>74036699
genuinely asking, what would your rating be?

>>74037132
I'd say lower A Quick One down a point or two, unless we're talking about the reissue with the bonus tracks. Also, I always felt like Face Dances was at least noticeably better than It's Hard. So I'd probably drop It's Hard down a point.

MG - 8

AQ1- 6

WSO - GT

T - 10

WN - 8

Quad - GT

WBN - 7

WAY - 8

FD - 4

IH - 3

EW - 6

>>74037015
they were not, there are people in this board who think rap is actual good music.
you know, it's summer.

File: 1.jpg (59KB, 633x960px) Image search: [Google]

59KB, 633x960px

>>74023149
>>74023262
>>74023468
>>74034741
>>74036753

everything wrong with nu-/mu/
reddit has got to go.

>>74035639
Completely fucking forgot Foxtrot, it's a 9/10 though.

File: s3YxkNe.png (864KB, 630x737px) Image search: [Google]

864KB, 630x737px

ITAOTS
>9
Money Store
>7
MBDTF
>5
Trout Mask Replica
>4
American Football
>6
Loveless
>8
Remain in Light
>9
TVU&N
>6
Spiderland
>10
Pet Sounds
>7
Madvilliany
>5
ITCOCK
>6
Kid A
>10
LYSF
>8
MPP
>5
PV
>3
Pink Moon
>10
Ys
>7
STFB
>9
Illinoise
>7
Untrue
>8
GKMC
>7
Hospice
>8
SILY
>5
Deathconsciousness
>9

>>74038609
hell yeah it is

File: IMG_0198.jpg (151KB, 546x700px) Image search: [Google]

151KB, 546x700px

>>74023041

File: Deftones.jpg (199KB, 996x701px) Image search: [Google]

199KB, 996x701px

Never seen one of these before.

>>74027369
>pablo being the lowest
kys

File: 1475832362715.gif (988KB, 351x387px) Image search: [Google]

988KB, 351x387px

>>74038900
>ITCOCK
>6

>>74033955
phm is god tier.

>>74038900
I want you to know that you have terrible taste

File: 1487615588743.jpg (23KB, 251x251px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 251x251px

>>74032131
>meddle god tier
>WYWH god tier
>Animals as low
>The Wall is not god tier

How does it feel to have objectively bad taste?

>>74021222
Do one for Viper

>>74028952
never thought i'd see lambs here
agree with everything besides what sound, that gets at least an 8 from me, scratch bass being the worst pick

>>74023013
Based on the rest of the thread these are all 10s

>>74028979
not bad. in my opinion, pretty hate machine is god tier

>>74038126
Gross racist fuck confirmed

File: savage3.gif (767KB, 369x156px) Image search: [Google]

767KB, 369x156px

>>74038900
>itcock
>6

>Hospice
>8

shit taste

File: The I.L.Y's.png (593KB, 1340x664px) Image search: [Google]

593KB, 1340x664px

>>74019636

>>74036319
How the fuck is goblin any higher than 6/10?

File: sigur ros.jpg (183KB, 2773x660px) Image search: [Google]

183KB, 2773x660px

>>74036297
Deloused is at least on par with Frances imo

File: mu rate braids.jpg (767KB, 4000x1686px) Image search: [Google]

767KB, 4000x1686px

Their output only seems to be going downhill as Raphaelle becomes more and more full of herself at the moment.

Someone save them.

>>74044547
>the EP full of shitty EDM throwaway tracks gets a 9
>Torches gets a "God Tier"
>and so does Supermodel
Anon...I think you're being a bit generous with your ratings...
Torches is nice but nowhere near god-tier and Supermodel is good at best.

>>74034205
this.

>>74032035
>Pin Ups so low
>That hate for Tonight
Fuck. You.

>>74032131
My negro, tho, fuck you a little for Animals

>>74032131
>after 40 listens he still doesnt like animals
lol

File: JuneOf44.png (527KB, 1452x585px) Image search: [Google]

527KB, 1452x585px

>>74019636

>>74036297
Switch Goliath and the last one and you got mine

>>74028896
Who in their right mind would put Jazz at 5 and Innuenedo at 8? It colours your other valid positions as crazy

>>74030768
Maybe a seven, but certainly much lower than anything pre-Mylo

>>74034591
I thought Mylo wasn't too shabby, but the other two who cares? (But they're still better than most stuff on the Hot 40 today)

>>74028949
>>74030625
>>74037038
Glad we're on the same page!

File: thebeatles.png (2MB, 1562x1938px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1562x1938px

>>74047598
>>74022004
here mine

>>74047772
>the power to beleive
>5
too high lol. that nu-metal track fuckign killed me

>>74036292
Why the fuck did you mix UK and USA albums?

>>74031841
looks like Chester felt that way about the album too

>>74019683
good taste, except Kid A is overrated and The Bends is underrated

>>74035896
>that first one

Are you kidding me?

>>74033955
lol

File: macca deux.jpg (160KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

160KB, 600x600px

>Coming Up
8/10

>Temporary Secretary
God Tier/10

>On My Way
7/10

>Waterfalls
10/10

>Nobody Knows
9/10

>Front Parlour
10/10

>Summer's Day Song
10/10

>Frozen Jap
God Tier/10

>Bogey Music
7/10

>Darkroom
8/10

>One of These Days
8/10

>>74048882
The Bends would better if High and Dry was replaced by Banana Co, and Talk Show Host was after Street Spirit. Itd be an easy 9

>>74024613
XM 6
TMS 7
NLDW 9
GP GT
NOTM 10
JD 8
BP 6

>>74027717
>AONO
>6

m8

>>74041806
>SNW
>10

The fuck are you on?

File: floyd.png (301KB, 1166x239px) Image search: [Google]

301KB, 1166x239px

>>74032131

File: 1486796371781.jpg (248KB, 1024x663px) Image search: [Google]

248KB, 1024x663px

>>74034990
All those songs are top notch mate, Meddle is great, and Echoes is one of, if not, Floyd's best songs

>>74048652
kek, good one

>>74037234
What would you give TRON?

>>74038050
Rap is good music, what's your point?

>>74048022
ETTW is better than TAM and INTFT6 should be at least an 8

>>74034864
>i don't understand how their music has plummeted into cheesy cancer so suddenly, it's like mikael had a seizure after watershed
He's actively dedicating his career to mess up with his fanbase

>>74048176
>In Rainbows shit tier
>Kid A not at least 8

don't ever come here again kid

>>74051368
Sorry anon, I like music.

>>74051382
If you liked music you wouldn't be on /mu/

>>74051409
Well, /mu/ isn't my main board, so you're right.

>>74051439
To even post here at all proves you have no respect for music of any kind

>>74051495
Also true.

>>74025535
>Parachutes and Ghost Stories God tier
So much this, Yes. I'd put up VLV higher than MX though.

>>74051382
How can you not like Hail to the thief and In Rainbows over The Bends, I just don't get it

>>74051611
Not enough guitar, too much electronic noodling. I didn't get into Radiohead to listen to them fuck about with electronic textures, I got into them because they were a great 90s alt rock band.

>>74042525
no u

>>74025535
mylo xyloto > ghost stories

pretty good otherwise though

File: - - peter gabriel - 73275f0e-2cb3-43cf-919c-9fcb198dabc6.jpg (142KB, 504x723px) Image search: [Google]

142KB, 504x723px

>>74033098

Genesis with and without Peter Gabriel (and Steve Hackett) are two completely different bands.

Peter Gabriel Genesis = God Tier

Phil Collins Genesis = mor pop rock band: does not rate

>>74036319
>>74037754
fucking ditto to this
Tyler himself hates the stupidly edgy shit he did for money, on cherry bomb you get to hear Tyler how he wants to be heard as an artist

>>74047022
Where are tical, fish scale, supreme clientele, etc.?

File: haha444.jpg (10KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 300x300px

>>74035764
>revolver god tier

>>74051883
haven't listened to them yet

>>74024613
EXMIL 7
TMS 10
NLDW 8
GP 7
NOTM 9
JD God Tier
BP God Tier

>>74051926
Of the ones I mentioned, tical is my favorite. On one of the tracks method man sounds like he's breathing fire.

>>74034981
This is almost perfect

>>74023175
What about Do You Know Square pusher?

>>74052189
I agree, except for Fashion Week. I think it deserves a 7 at least

>>74048652
Savage

>>74049268
kidding you how, anon-kun?

>>74036319
he really peaked with Wolf.

>>74024727
If we ignore the existence of Alice in Chains I agree.

>>74022748
>Feedbacker not a 10
Come on.
>>74025535
>Viva la Vida not the highest
>X&Y not a 7
>Mylo Xyloto a 10
Lol.
>>74026870
Hello, my nigga.

>>74052537
This lol, although AiC is more metal than grunge

>>74046513
Von 5

AB 10

( ) God Tier

Takk 9 or 10

Med sit ghdnfmcjjjdm 7

Valtari 7

Kveikur 8

>>74021804
I guess u haven't listened to opeth a single time

File: pjfaces.png (453KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

453KB, 1000x1000px

>>74027717
Invaders Must Die was great, what the hell? Everything else is spot on though.

>>74033955
Adorable ;)

>>74028087
You didn't rate the Fallout 1 soundtrack he ghost wrote (which is 10/10 god tier btw)

>>74032131
>your opinion about everything is invalidated over that Animals comment

>>74034981
Leisure 7

Modern Life 8

Park life 10

Great Escape 6

S/t 10

13 God Tier

Think Tank 9

Magic Whip

6

File: sr.png (2MB, 2798x848px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 2798x848px

>>74046513
Mehh, I've seen Sigur Ros live and listened to most of their stuff via my wife. I think I'm being generous here.

>>74052146
worst ITT

>>74036319

Bastard
>8
Goblin
>5
Wolf
>God
Cherry Bomb
>4, it's just a fucking mess
SFFB
>9

>>74032812
Iron Maiden - 9
Killers - 8
Number of the Beast - 9
Piece of Mind - 8
Powerslave - God Tier
Somewhere in Time - God Tier
Seventh Son of a Seventh Son - God Tier
No Prayer for the Dying - 4
Fear of the Dark - 6
X Factor - 3
Virtual XI - 3
Brave New World - 2 (I always found this album to be a bit weird)
Dance of Death - 7
AMOLAD - 6 (I think I was unfair to this album the first time I heard it. It's not too bad; nothing special but fine to listen to)
The Final Frontier - 4
The Book of Souls - 6

You can see what my preferred era of Maiden is.

>>74052887
dude....how?

>>74021091
correct

>>74053204
-An hour (give or take a few minutes) late on stage; never apologised.
-The show was pretty boring - every song sounded the same and they just droned on. I could have just heard two or three songs and that would have been enough.
-The band never acknowledged or interacted with the audience once during the two hour set. If there's one thing I can't stand, it's bands who don't even acknowledge their paying fans. I find it rude.

So their lateness etc. didn't put me in a good mood, but the music I just found really boring. But I got dragged to the show by my wife because she didn't want to go alone.

>>74022190
I agree with this

>>74023041
b8

>>74036319
>wolf
>god tier
lmao

>>74048652
:(

(his dying still doesn't change the fact that OML sucks, but I kinda feel bad for making that, and I'm bummed about his death in general)