well /mu/ are they right?

wtf i love p4k now

absolutely

i really hate music, guys

no... its like a 6-7 max

>>73957175
like pitchfork has dick fuck to do with guns n roses and their legacy. i seriously hope no one on here is impressionable enough to have their views affected by this score

>>73957534
wtf i love GnR now

*buys t shirt*

>>73957534
look at all the threads about it

My dad always says that Appetite is the last truly great rock album. What do you think?

>>73957613
the crimson idol, at least

>>73957534
It was always a 10
Literally the perfect album, at least in that genre.

>>73957613
Definitely the last great Rock n Roll album.
There have been great rock albums since.

>>73957175
It would be a 10/10 if Axl Rose wasn't such a shit vocalist

>>73957661
>objectively the best singer in recorded history
>shit
https://www.concerthotels.com/worlds-greatest-vocal-ranges

>>73957175
stop phoneposting

They already had it close to the top of their best of the 1980s list so no surprise really

>>73957703
>objectively the best singer in recorded history
Oh, boy.

File: IMG_0187.jpg (21KB, 200x225px) Image search: [Google]

21KB, 200x225px

>>73957175
Literally only has two good songs

>>73957175
this is my dad's favorite album, so naturally as a 90s kid I'm inclined not to like it... but honestly it's pretty good. definitely not a 10 though

>>73957585
I think it's because giving that album a 10/10 is pretty hilarioue stuff

File: meme.jpg (35KB, 460x297px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 460x297px

>>73957962
well???

Based pitchfork

Finally a good p4k rating

>>73957175
No it sucks

where is that nick cave quote when you need it ?

pitchfork has truly outdone themselves this time.

>>73960181
oh nvm it was about rhcp

WOO AH OH OH OH OH SWEET /MU/ OF MIIINE

>>73960181
"I'm forever near a stereo asking, 'What the fuck is that garbage?' And the answer is always the Red Hot Chili Peppers."

>>73957175
nice. i'm impressed.

wtf i love gnr now

b-b-but muh black people.

It's a 4 at best desu

>>73957534
i agree.

some people will actually believe it is a worthwhile release now. shame people can't think for themselves.

>>73960191
TAKE ME DOWN TO THE PARADISE /MU/ BOARD WHERE THE THREADS ARE GREEN AND THE OPS ARE PRETTY

>>73960253
this but for people taking nigger rap pitchfork ratings seriously.

:|

>>73960255
WELCOME TO THE /MU/ BOARD
WELCOME TO THE /MU/ BOARD
GET DOWN ON YOU'RE SHANANANANA CHARTS CHARTS

>>73960284
I THINK ABOUT /MU/

>>73960191
>>73960255
>>73960284
>>73960331
looooool

>>73960191
>>73960255
>>73960284
>>73960331
Kek. Based /mu/ board posters.

Glam metal is the worst genre of music.

Has there ever been a music publication more liberal with giving out perfect scores?

Pitchfork is a bad joke and anyone who reads it, either seriously or for laughs, should be ashamed.

Use Your Illusion is better

>reads Scaruffi once

File: Scaruffi.jpg (32KB, 200x200px) Image search: [Google]

32KB, 200x200px

Appetite For Destruction (1987) was as harrowing an experience as being catapulted into a dark narrow alley of the worst Los Angeles neighborhood. William "Axl Rose" Bailey's nasty, offensive, anti-heroic vocal acrobatics fended off the double-guitar attack of Saul "Slash" Hudson and Jeff "Izzy Stradlin" Isabell, who indulged in unbridled concertos of screeching and reckless riffs. The noise, the energy, the lyrics transformed each song into a bloody fistfight.
8/10

Based Scaruffi is based

Guns n Roses is the worst shit.

>>73961276
^^^^this