The great debate

no debate here it's all trash

>>73829703
pleb: low

contrarian: lodger

pleb 2: heroes

patrician: scary monsters

>>73829728
Agree

Lodger is objectively the best of these three David Bowie albums because it is the first album since his first where he wasn't trying to do anything other than write decent songs instead of getting all experimental

>>73829741
>>73829741
>>73829711

Well I guess thats us all sorted then

Good thread lads

Low > Heroes (= Scary Monsters) > Lodger

The songs on Heroes, while in many ways more refined, are inferior to those on Low, pound for pound. This is mostly only true of the instrumentals. I think this is obvious, but that people respond to the high-flown tailoring of it and believe this makes them better.

rise and fall of ziggy stardust is his best wtf are you guys talking about

File: Station_to_Station_cover.jpg (69KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

69KB, 300x300px

excuse me.

>>73829703

Can't even rank the Berlin trio. I love them all - I wish it was just a triple album.

It can be any album? Zigg Stardust of fucking course

>>73829703
Impossible to rank. Lodger is the most underrated bowie ever

>>73829703
bump

Hunky Dory >

Low - 8.5/10
"Heroes" - 9/10
Lodger - 6.5/10

>>73829854

Concur... Station to Station is a reminder that he was at his best when living on cocaine, milk and bell peppers, all whilst hiding his piss in the fridge so the wizards couldn't get at it... 10/10.

>>73832549
explain.

>>73829703
Zingy stardust