Is trap rap just black EDM?

>>73826534
I'd rather listen to Joel at his worst than Lil Peep or Lil Pump

>>73826534
Is EDM just white trap rap?

A lot of the first house musicians were black.

The meaning of trap rap has changed.

This song talked about trap back in the 90's yet kids think it's some kind of hip new term.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sajEFSpoxHI

>>73826592
EDM didn't start until 2010

>>73826534
>black EDM

Fuck off

>>73826628
techno is also edm

EDM is a black music

>>73826640
Nope

>>73826648
>techno is not electronic dance music
you're retarded btw

>>73826648
Oh great, one of those "my favorite dance music isn't EDM" guys. Fuck off.

>>73826659
EDM != all Electronic dance music

Dumb pardners lls

>>73826628
EDM started in the 1970's.

>>73826713
Source: my ass
Kill yourself you fucking autist.

>>73826727
>
>>73826713

>>73826713
>Electronic Dance Music ≠ Electronic dance music
>!=
go back to your containment thread >>73820985

>>73826713
This song is EDM from 1978

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VXa9tXcMhXQ

>>73826784
No it's not

>>73826824
Yes it is you stupid normie cunt.

>>73826854
Only a normie would think EDM existed before Joel and Skrillex

/mu/ knows nothing about electronic music. they don't even attend clubs
bunch of basement dwellers

>>73826931
there's a perpetual general for your shitty club electronic music. non-/bleep/ electronic music barely gets any discussion though i agree

>>73826534
say that in Traplanta bitch.

>>73827372
Thankfully, I don't live in the USA.

>>73826899
>Only a normie would think electronic dance music existed before Joel and Skrillex
is this a bait or /bleep/ visitors are legitimately that autistic

>>73827401
All electronic music != EDM

You all get stupider each reply

>>73827417
>>73826760

>>73827432
Oh, you really do.

>>73827417
You still have yet to explain how your favorite autistic dub techno doesn't fall under the moniker of electronic dance music.

>>73827439
It does.

But not under EDM.

>>73827417
>All electronic music != EDM
nice strawman

>>73827452
EDM = Electronic Dance Music. Please kill yourself.

>>73827452
EDM is just a shitty umbrella term. It's not a specific genre like you seem to think it is. If it's electronic dance music, it's EDM.

>>73827469
>>73827470
Wrong.

>>73827517
ok so define EDM in contrast to electronic dance music. and make sure you're not just saying "EDM is the bad electronic dance music" in different words

>>73827574
"Music played and produced by artists who regularly feature at EDC and Ultra Music Festival. In the early 2010s, the term "electronic dance music" and the initialism "EDM" was being pushedby the United Statesmusic industry andmusic pressin an effort torebrand American rave culture".

>>73827641
so not only could you not come up with something yourself, the quote you chose to use instead of an original thought does absolutely nothing to define the music that supposedly falls into this "very specific genre". you've lost.

>>73827671
This is House:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=txii1cweRws

This is an EDM's Bigroom House abortion:
https://youtu.be/e-U1lj57pv8?list=PLbvfp3U9ClFY30WT2MLdO8QRqkLXpwu2s

>>73827780
>"EDM is the bad electronic dance music" in different words

>>73826534
yeah. it's cultural appropriation

>>73827671
>[citation needed]
>no not citation that prove me wrong
lmao

>>73827997
the quote literally doesn't say anything to prove me wrong and i didn't ask for a citation i asked for a definition

>>73827780
both are edm dumbass

>>73828019
>>73828025
If all electronic music that can be danced to is EDM then Stockhausen, Faust, Can, Tangerine Dream and Jean Michel Jarre are EDM too.

By your definition.

>>73828101
>If all electronic music that can be danced to is EDM then Stockhausen, Faust, Can, Tangerine Dream and Jean Michel Jarre are EDM too.
exactly

>>73828101
yes. you'll notice that i have not been arguing that EDM is a particularly useful term.

>>73828101
see >>73827465

>>73828101
>>73828136

also
it's started with my post
>>73826659
it's interesting how you went from this
>>73826713
to this
>>73827417
and now you're namedropping Stockhausen

you're retarded

>>73828210
EDM is still only post-2010 American Fruity Loops 101 played at EDC/Ultra regardless of my extensive explanation variety you needed.

>>73826584
unironically yes, but only if we include music made AFTER the term "EDM" was coined

>>73828234
see >>73827574
also try to do it without any strawman

>>73828234
>defining a genre by if they attend a certain festival
that's some next-level nonsense. so an electronic dance music artist is only EDM after they play at EDC? but before that, they aren't EDM?

edm by dictionary definition is electronically produced music that you can dance too. "EDM" as a colloquial term refers stuff like big room house. context boys..

>>73828325
Krautrock, progressive electronic, industrial...

>>73828342
yes?

>>73828294
Just like metal is a different rock sub because it's harder/heavier.

Equally as retarded yet also universally accepted.

>>73828369
except "because it's harder/heavier" has to do with the music itself, so no those aren't equivalent scenarios.

>>73826592
>This song talked about trap back in the 90's yet kids think it's some kind of hip new term.
Did you.... like.... knew .... that .... memphis.... rap.... from 90s.... is like trap....

>this thread

ahahahahaha, hip hop and trap already are electronic dance music / EDM pls wtf

>>73828398
So is EDC/Ultra versus.... if you think about it