If you were a music reviewer

File: Natural Snow Buildings - Shadow Kingdom.jpg (168KB, 450x450px) Image search: [Google]

168KB, 450x450px

this is the only record worthy of a 10 for me.

none

>>73663162
Certainly not that one. Nothing Neil Davidge ever produced is worthy of any praise and he is a fraud.

>>73663629
here's your (you)

File: avalon.jpg (416KB, 953x953px) Image search: [Google]

416KB, 953x953px

to be honest this a 10 out of 10 from the first song to the last

File: The_Strokes_-_Ist_Tis_It_US_cover[2].png (220KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

220KB, 300x300px

I don't believe in rating albums, because that would be like rating whether or not the things on my mind relate to the the ideas on the album, which doesn't make a lot of sense.

But I like every song on this, and I can listen to it from beginning to end regardless of where I am or what I'm thinking about. And it's more well known than the other albums that that's true for, so I guess that makes it a 10 for illiterate serfs such as thyself.

If I was a music reviewer I would slit my wrists and drown in the bathtub. It's way more funny to "review" music by playing music.

>>73663162
so much shit filler though. I'd give it a light 7.

File: 536c4099a88f86bda65bfd99d5dd20dd.600x600x1.jpg (74KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

74KB, 600x600px

Potentially best metal record of all time.

File: -1.jpg (101KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

101KB, 500x500px

>>73663766
isn't this the band with the guy who can't sing?

>>73663162
none

>>73663811
if you're gonna say 'none' why bother to even make a post?

>>73663177
this

On the corner
English settlement
Black saint
Ole Coltrane
Spirit they're gone

>>73663766
isn't metallica some 80ies/90ies meme?

>>73663162

Love - Forever Changes

Aphex Twin - SAW 85-92

Shoobi Watkins - Glimpsing The Shoob

Mr. Bungle - Disco Volante

There are loads more I'd give 10/10...doesn't mean they're perfect but means that the whole feels just right.

File: R-26194-1300100128.jpeg.jpg (125KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

125KB, 600x600px

Fight me

File: Isis_Panopticon[1].jpg (12KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 300x300px

>>73663806

LANDMINES

>>73663162
Also I'm just starting to listen to this and holy fuck it sounds GOOD

>>73663951
rip

File: why even bother living.png (102KB, 746x717px) Image search: [Google]

102KB, 746x717px

>>73663806
>>73663843

>>73663823
i gave my opinion

>>73664201
your opinion is irrelevant when you have nothing to say

>>73664284
nothing doesn't exist. if so you would be dead

>>73663756
Which tracks are exactly the fillers in your opinion? Because I think there's none. Just curious, no hate.

>>73664326
since when is this a meta-philosophy thread?

>>73664326
go fuck yourself pseudo-philosophy-retarded

that's my opinion

>>73663766
kill urself my man

Mezzanine is a 9, Blue Lines is a 10.

>>73664373
They both a 10 in their own way.

>What is RYM

>>73664385
RYM is shit, people out there are no music critics, many of them have no knowledge about music at all.

>>73664332
>Makes good album
>Wait... it doesn't sound complete... like it's missing something
>I know! (proceeds to make the worst song on the album)
>Puts it after the albums best run of songs just to magnify how shitty it is
>Puts the only bad song as the closer to the album so it plays twice
>Fuck it, let's make it twice as long!
>Ruined potential 9/10 album, turned it into a 7/10.

Fucking exchange.

>>73664579
so, which song are u talkin about?

>>73664351
your opinion is something?

>>73664579
>>73664668
He's talking about exchange and (exchange) kek. I don't know what's wrong with these 2 track but ok it's your opinion.

Blood Sugar Sex Magik. Tired of vanilla Nevermind getting all the acclaim when there were much better albums from '91

>>73663885
Disco Volante is amazing. Needs to be listened as a whole.

>>73664784
BSSM has way too much filler

>>73664579
I love Exchange but agree that putting Exchange 2: Electric Boogaloo at the end of the album hurts it. Group Four is robbed of being the epic closer it should be.

Is Exchange the only track you have a problem with? Can't really tell.

File: 3960.jpg (33KB, 500x496px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 500x496px

I really love this fucking album

Rock Bottom is probably the only one

File: nowhere.jpg (42KB, 628x623px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 628x623px

>>73664373
While I do enjoy it, I find that much of Blue Lines sounds rather outdated. Agreed with Mezzanine being a 9/10, however.

>>73663174
Why this one specifically? Only heard Snowbringer Cult and Moon and Sun so I'm curious.