How good is this?

Pretty good.

>>73464895
Good

Good enough to ruin the band for me. None of their other albums have measured up to this or will ever come close.

>>73464936

Suburbs > Funeral > Neon Bible > Reflektor

it holds up

>>73464936
Reflektor is at least 85% as good. Funeral > Reflektor > Neon Bible > The Suburbs

Only 13 years old, but already a classic.

>>73464895
There have been like six great releases in Rock music since 2000. This is one of them.

Neon Bible > Suburbs > that > Reflektor

overrated as hell, don't bother

>>73465124
Neon Bible is better than Reflektor. Everything else is wrong.

>>73465845
lol bandwagon harder dude, Neon Bible is their best

File: Neon_Bible_(Front_Cover).jpg (19KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 300x300px

Neon Bible>Funeral=Suburbs>Reflector

I'll never understand why Neon Bible doesn't get as much praise as Funeral and The Suburbs. I think it's beautiful.

>>73464895
funeral>reflektor>suburbs>neon bible>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>everything now

>>73465945
Have you even heard Creature Comfort? It's nice. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xzwicesJQ7E

>>73464895
Its Arcade fire's third best album after the suburbs and reflektor
>>73465945
How the fuck are you going to base an album just on one song?

>>73465003
This some contrarian shit right here m8

Funeral>Reflelcktor>>Suburbs/Neon Bible

>>73464895
personally, I hated it, and found it extremely boring save a few songs
disappointing since I had heard so many good things about it

>>73466293
In what way?
>inb4 Reflektor is bad
>inb4 The Suburbs is totally brilliant

Funeral > Neon Bible > Reflektor > The Suburbs

Suburbs has some great tracks but can feel a bit lost in the middle, while Reflektor has a solid first half and a god-tier part 2. Funeral and neon bible are just masterworks through and through though

9/10

>>73465903
It starts strong and ends strong but menaders too much in the middle and doesn't push the boundaries as hard as Funeral.

Reflektor could (and should) have been their second groundbreaking Funeral album but Win got too high on his own farts and forgot to actually fucking edit down the damn thing. A 40 min cut of Reflektor could actually be a genuine 10/10.

And of course in response to THAT now the gang's doubling down on the pretention and upling the genericness of the music.

>>73466455
>wow explain
>but you're not allowed to use normal explanations

>>73464895
I fucking grew up listening to this, It's fucking amazing