Times Pitchfork Went Too Far

Having ever gave Kanye a score above 9.0

Frances the mute and the fragile a 2

>>73144527
Giving Boy with the Arab Strap a 0.0 and NYC Ghosts and Flowers a 0.4 or something

>>73144527
Finally Rich is one of the best rap albums of the decade. Not even a controversial opinion among smart people like me.

>>73144540
>three
>fucking
>times
>not even counting a 10

>>73144527
Giving I Get Wet by Andrew W.K. a 2

>>73144540
whats wrong with that

File: rs_600x600-170211120220-600.kanye-west.cm.21117.jpg (61KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

61KB, 600x600px

>>73144540
>>73144651
Mad that Tswift doesn't get reviewed by Pitchfork?

>>73146154
frances the mute is a 2? how is that even psosible

>>73146154
Yeah The King of Limbs definitely didn't deserve over a 6

>>73146154
I'm okay with that best coast score

>>73146154
I would post this pic constantly if that Tool album wasn't on there. Just face it, they suck.

>>73146039
he has never released an album over 9.0 and now look at his ego

>>73146133
Umm, I don't see why I would care about some stupid giraffe.

>>73144527
giving Citizen Zombie a 2.4

>>73144540
implying it wasn't deserved lmao fuck outta here

>>73146335
that album was pretty disappointing. call it a 5.2.

>>73146349
>implying Kanye has made an album you could even compare to Einstein on the Beach or even rap like Midnight Marauders

>>73146154
All those scores are right plen

>>73146322
how has he never released an album over 9.0?
MBDTF is at least a 9.9/10

>>73146300
Pleb

>>73144540
They should have all been 10's

>>73146154
This is happening was good though

>>73144527
>Times Pitchfork Went Too Far

Every time they rate an American rap album over an 8.0

>>73146300
the pleb filter worked

>>73144540
Rating anything other than MBDTF higher than a 9*

Yeezus is overrated as fuck

>>73146154
whats wrong tha carter 3?

File: 1466742544798.jpg (28KB, 272x300px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 272x300px

>>73144540
Pitchfork is underrating Kanye tbf

>>73146154
Carter 3 is great fucking album

>>73146154
What's wrong with This is Happening's score?
The record's at least a 9.5, but still

>>73146154
the person who made this image is probably someone who uses the word "cuck" unironically

>>73144571
So much this.

>>73144527
Giving "Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not" a 7.4, but "AM" an 8

Mars Volta and Tool are atrocious nuprog for numales, if anything the scores were too low.

>>73146300
retard

>>73146300
none of reddithead albums deserve anything over a 6

>>73151128
The Mountain Goats are fucking nu male John Green book garbage.

>>73144571
Fragile reissue got a 8,7. No idea what their Problem is with the Mars volta. They seem to hate them with a passion.

>>73146154
This Is Happening is one of the most boring fucking albums I've listened to in my life, and I actually liked their first two albums.

>>73151092
The only people who have problems with the word "cuck" are probably unironic cucks

>>73146154
I agree with the This is Happening score, though

>>73146315
Lateralus is a fucking masterpiece

>>73151652
I didn't even see a review for Missteps III, which is easily the most interesting electronic album to come out in 10 years.

>>73144527
>The Beach Boys "fake soul"
when¿

>>73144527
>>Calling The Beach Boys "fake soul"
...but they're not soul? Like, no one would ever describe their music as soul.

Unless the writer's saying that the feeling they're trying to produce is fake/shallow, which is actually retarded.

>>73152542
t. cuck

>>73144626
t.white suburban kid

>>73152542
Other way round, only people who use it are cucks.

>>73146284
>>73151347
>>73144571
The mars volta gets those low scores because indie kids hate prog rock.

>>73151341
AM should be added to this >>73146154. Pitchfork giving it a fucking 8 and pointing it out as a shining example of quality mainstream rock being made nowadays while giving albums like ...Like Clockwork a 7 is a joke.

>>73153977
t. cuck

>>73154081
t. cuckold

>>73144540
this

>>73146154
They were right about Andrew W.K. tho; pretty much the one time they literally didn't fall for the meme

Tool and Mars Volta are trenchcoat flameshirt fedora music and have always been hipster anathema

does nobody ITT understand that p4k gives controversial scores to stir up hype around their needless website to make money?

>>73151128
wtf

>>73151376
>ok computer doesn't deserve at least an 8

>>73146154
also Yanqui UXO being a 6

>>73151499
shut your god damn pie hole

>>73146154
Somebody add Niggas On The Moon to this

>>73144540
his best is an 8.5 at max

>>73158461
This.