Yeezus 4/10 Blackstar 4/10

that's correct.

I don't see a problem

?

One of those is correct

>Korn s/t 7.5/10
>Slipknot s/t 7/10
>MSI 7/10

If you really hip hop both these albums wack.

>>73114979
no problem here

he's smiling

don't you see?

>>73114967
Both of those albums are experimental simply >>73114967
for the sake of being experimental

Makes sense for him to slam them even if they do in all honesty deserve 5/10s

>>73114992
>MSI 7/10

Not Wrong

>>73114967
He's being generous in these ratings if i'm being honest.

>>73115019
>Blackstar
>experimental for the sake of being experimental
that's wrong though

>>73114992
>Korn s/t 7.5/10

Pretty accurate

>>73115064
this
I don't see how that garbage is experimental

>>73115064
Shallow attempt at being experimental is more accurate

File: manul.jpg (347KB, 1024x647px) Image search: [Google]

347KB, 1024x647px

>rating music objectively

>>73115093
that's also not true
>>73115123
this

>>73114979
blackstar is not 4/10
anybody who thinks that is an idiot

>random old dude creates a website
>writes a bunch of stupid bullshit with terrible and uninformed writing on various topics
>pretends to be more knowledgeable than he actually is
>decides to write about music
>claims to have varied taste despite it being heavily centered on north america and europe
>write a bunch of biased and contrarian opinions for the sake of being different
>15 year olds on 4chan eat it all up
why do people take him seriously again?

>>73114967
By Scaruffi standards, but also for any other critic or literally any person, that's an "understandable" rating.
Yeezus hopped on the angry industrial hip hop train just because it was cool with half-assed songs and laughable production and the lyrics are an absolute meme.
Blackstar is alright but more of the same and really nothing new, I can see why you'd throw a 4/10 at it after listening to Bowie for 49 years.
Korn's 7.5/10 is deserved since it pioneered a new genre with pretty well made and catchy songs too.

>>73115216
you lost me about halfway through

>>73115161
pleb detected

>>73115161
>anybody who dislikes a pop album I like is an idiot

>>73115257
>>73115242
kys contrarians

>>73115282
>falceflagging to make bowiefags look autistic
you're good at it, keep doing

>>73115161
bowie cuck spotted

>>73114992
I like Black Eyed Peas - The E.N.D rating
>6/10

>>73115161
ur right, it's a 2/10

>>73114992
MSI?

>>73115623
Frankenstein Girls Will Seem Strangely Sexy by Mindless Self Indulgence

listen to this
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yb6amH7hEhA

>>73115019
Lmao how was Blackstar "experimental"?
Lmao he's following the rock musik formula to a tee it's only experimental j you're totally clueless. Yeezus was because he didn't know what he was doing putting it together since he didn't produce shit on it. "Experimental" is the most misused word in music discussion.

Yeezus is rated too high
Black Star is rated too low

>>73115692
opposite way around

>>73115161
Blackstar is literally Bowie's best album. Solid 10/10, only one that comes close is Space Oddity but that's only a 7/10

>>73115688
Lmao

[spoiler]Lmao[/spoiler]

>>73115884
Blackstar is a shitty Doors wannabe album

>>73115216
I know it sucks not have artistic sensibility dude,but go play soccer or something:)

>>73115884
>no Station to Station
pleb

>>73115660
so good

>>73116213
>Thinking bowie was ever experimental
Lls

david bowie raped a child lmao

>>73115216
Lmao where else would it the music he listens to be centered around? Africa? Lmaooooo only so many sounds you can make on a Congo

>>73116599
I take it back then. Maybe he was "experimental" lls

>>73115873
Correct