Times when Scaruffi was right

why ddn't you click on the last two

File: 960.jpg (18KB, 960x540px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 960x540px

>>72886157

It would be a much shorter list to post times when Scaruffi was wrong.

>>72886424
>In Rainbows
>a fucking 5/10
>REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

>>72886424
he is such a fucking contrarian
why the fuck do people take him seriously?

>>72886601
leld and saved

>>72886187
that's when he found out he could scroll

>>72886444
>>72887041
kek
triggered much, radiopleb fans?

>>72886157
Animal Collective

The why we can't marry a 12-year-old one

>>72886556
Objectively wrong

>>72887175
his ratings are actually quite positive for radiohead. very respectable. you have just revealed yourself to be a newfag and a fool

>>72887320
Not really, his right about everything except Exmilitary and Jenny Death, which should be lower.

>>72887438
he's*

>>72886424
>two 7/10
>nothing below 5/10
Scaruffi was pretty kind here.

File: download.jpg (4KB, 149x144px) Image search: [Google]

4KB, 149x144px

>>72886157
Shills, critics and (((rankings)))

>>72886157
This is almost entirely correct. Good job.

>>72886424
>Pablo Honey above The Bends and tied with Kid A
Literally contrarian

>>72888280
>people can't have opinions different than mine
literally retard

>>72889131
Pablo Honey checks all the boxes of albums scaruffi hates yet for some reason he rates it a 7? The only thing going for it is that it's a debut album which scaruffi loves to rate higher just because

>>72888280
The Bends is literally Pablo Honey but with better lyrics and band's image, and as far as I know scaruffi doesn't really care about lyrics and a band's image

>>72889164
>Pablo Honey checks all the boxes of albums scaruffi hates yet for some reason he rates it a 7?

but it clearly says 6.5????

Scrauf is the best his top tens are amazing recs and in general his a very intelligent human. The amount of knowledge he has film(early 1950s to present),politics (history and analysis of various countries all over the world), music (covering classical, rock, jazz and all there time periods with analysis and historic overviews) on top of being a lead head in A.I field and computer sciences.

>>72889218
i swear to god it used to say 7
he changes those all the time i wouldn't be surprised if he changed this one

Why do people get so angry about this old man's musical taste?

>>72886424
This, Radiohead is trash

File: sofia7.jpg (97KB, 600x450px) Image search: [Google]

97KB, 600x450px

>>72889314

Because they subconsciously know he's right.

i think it's funny how everyone acknowledges the beatles except this weird italian dude and all the avant teens rally around him

>>72889499
If you understand his rating system and actually read past the initial rant he definitely gives the Beatles credit for making good music, he just says they arent the best, which is completely true.

>>72889258
Masterfully done, stronzo

Dude's almost always right though. He is quite objective with his reviews

>>72889272
>>72889218

it was originally a 7

and Kid A was originally a 5 lol

>>72890371
That's a generous score for Kid A

>>72886556
He will bump both exmilitary and/or the money store in less than five years.

>>72889499

The beatles peaking at 7/10 on his scale sounds about right.

File: redpill.png (23KB, 464x212px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 464x212px

>>72886157
>>72886424

>giving even a single flying fuck what some asperger riddled old geezer thinks

>>72890576
they were actually interesting at that time, too bad nu-metal became such a meme

>>72890577
>being this mad about someone disliking your favorite band

File: thefinalredpill.png (19KB, 450x217px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 450x217px

>>72890614

>>72890626
I literally give zero fucks what Scaruffi or anyone else thinks of the music I like. I like it, that's all that matters. You must be cuck to the max to dislike something or feel shame for liking something because some internet nobody told you to.

>>72890647
Correct, Untoucables is favourite of mine
3 seems harsh for untitled

>>72890647
These scores are mostly legitimate. While post-follow the Leader Korn are a shadow of their former self, in '94 they were something genuinely interesting and innovative.

>>72890493

no matter what score you think Kid A is, it is objectively better than Pablo Honey.

>>72886182
He actually posted this /mu/tards compilation on his website lel.

>>72892732

link?

File: 9b97ba6056e4dd4cd7a4a6ff28aef3f1.jpg (402KB, 1923x2548px) Image search: [Google]

402KB, 1923x2548px

wht would someone who doesnt like music review music?

>>72892745
http://scaruffi.com/music/top100.png
It's on his frontpage links. I'm pretty sure I saw someone on /mu/ compile it long before Scaruffi posted it though.

>>72889164
Why would he hate an album like it?

File: 1491915265906.gif (3MB, 359x202px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 359x202px

>>72886424
>Pablo Honey: 6.5/10
>Kid A: 6.5/10

>>72890655
You do sound mad lel

>>72890933
But Kid A's songwriting is much less existent than Pablo Honey's. They focused on production too much without doing anything so out there to drive the record. This is indisputable.

>>72886157
>yellow submarine and revolver with same rating

scaruffi was too damn high for this

>>72893741

dead wrong kiddo