ITT: Post a personal 10/10 and others try to find flaws

>>72599027
>whiny simplistic music by selfish cowards who kill themselves

File: Disco_Volante_album_cover.jpg (62KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

62KB, 300x300px

>>72599027
Wanting to contribute but can't think of any senpai

File: Dog_man_star.jpg (84KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

84KB, 300x300px

>>72599027
>Proof that you can be whiny and edgy at the same time

>>72599027
sad man sings sad music. nothing jaw dropping about this album, other than the fact that you realize he committed suicide not long after.

>>72599027
gay
>>72599061
black

Mine is >>72599121

>>72599027
Can't find anything wrong except 2:45 AM

File: Four-Walls-Paradise-Circus-cover.jpg (62KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

62KB, 600x600px

>>72599027
dreary and whiny

File: disint.jpg (92KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

92KB, 1000x1000px

The original version, without Last Dance and Homesick

>>72599061
both gaye and black

File: bigchair.jpg (84KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

84KB, 600x600px

>>72599027
prefer S/T
>>72599067
prefer California

File: 2061010.jpg (58KB, 500x558px) Image search: [Google]

58KB, 500x558px

be gentle

File: 1343055337808.jpg (26KB, 205x205px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 205x205px

>>72599114
>>72599295
Well done

>>72599027
No Name No.5
>>72599061
Wholy Holy
>>72599078
Daddy's Speeding is the only one I can think of, that and second track is the only brilliant one

File: a1194294056_10.jpg (399KB, 1200x1188px) Image search: [Google]

399KB, 1200x1188px

>>72599027
Made by an unstable
>>72599061
His father hated him
>>72599322
Microphones peaking all over the place

>>72599276
>when you can't get a version without last dance but still has homesick

>>72599787
Why even live in a world like this

>>72599777
>Microphones peaking all over the place
it's lo-fi tho

>>72599322
Too fucking perfect everything sounds like shit afterwards

>>72599061
"How big of an asshole do you have to be to have your dad shoot you?"

>>72600849
Objectively worst Kanye record

File: 1492840899411.gif (993KB, 250x250px) Image search: [Google]

993KB, 250x250px

>>72599045

dude neurotypical lmao

>>72599067

the piss poor mixing, especially on afterschool special

>>72600964
kek
is this a line from something?

>>72600849
shitty Death Grips cover album

File: a3907213656_5[1].jpg (95KB, 700x700px) Image search: [Google]

95KB, 700x700px

good luck finding a flaw

>>72599175
A bit cheesy innit

>>72599061
A bit gay innit

>>72599322
A bit worse than Mount Eerie in every way imaginable innit?

>>72601937
Every song sounds the same desu, but it's still a classic.

File: funeral.jpg (211KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

211KB, 1000x1000px

>>72599027
Hate Elliot Smith. All I can think when I listen to him is that the guy desperately needs help, not to have his mental sickness celebrated.

>>72601165
I believe it's from the liner notes of the 40th anniversary release of the album.

>>72599045
>Elliott Smith
>simplistic
How do you fuck up this bad?

File: Boris - Flood.jpg (63KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

63KB, 500x500px

Hard mode: No "It's too slow!!"

File: 00. OK Computer.jpg (105KB, 770x770px) Image search: [Google]

105KB, 770x770px

Protip: you can't

>>72603164
The Tourist is a meh end to a great album.

File: elliott.png (21KB, 635x235px) Image search: [Google]

21KB, 635x235px

>>72599027
Gonna have to bring in Christgau on this one.

>>72603164
>two or three 10/10 songs mixed with a shitload of whiny sudo intellectual filter

>>72602705
4 fucking skits is too many

>>72603164
Boring trash.

>>72599345
wot r u on about m8 i like no name >:(

>>72600849
>listens to experimental hip-hop once

>>72601013
You spelled best wrong.

>>72599027
i fell in love with elliott smiths songs, but had to stop listening. it brought me in a new depressional phase.

>>72602314
Pretentious "indie" rock/"chamber pop" hybrid with terrible vocals
>>72603717
Bad lyrics. If you think the lyrics are good you're fooling yourself honestly.

>>72604244
I've wanted to get this for a longtime? Anywhere I can find it in the US?

>>72604082
>>72604244
good tastes

>>72604544
discogs probably has it, can't imagine it'd be cheap though - on vinyl, at least.

>>72604601
Yeah, the vinyl is pretty ridiculous. CD's isn't too bad though. Does the band have a place I can get a digital download? I'd like to support them but I can't find anywhere.

I'm pretty sure the band broke-up though.

>>72599285
Too eclectic for it's own good, kind of "tuneless"

>>72600849
shit lyrics, shit production on half the tracks
>those corny "trap" horns on Blood On The Leaves
yuck

>>72602259
Suffers from prog cheesiness at times

>>72603164
Rather boring at times

>>72604082
The first track is miles better than any other song on there

>>72604657
yeah they disbanded in 2010, and apparently the lead singer (mariko gotou) quit the music industry entirely last year

as for digital download, i have no idea

>>72604691
Looks like I'll just grab a CD from Discogs then. Thanks.

File: 71N24co9ugL._SL1425_.jpg (245KB, 1425x1425px) Image search: [Google]

245KB, 1425x1425px

>>72599027

File: 10_700_700_mrg451.jpg (106KB, 700x700px) Image search: [Google]

106KB, 700x700px

>>72599027
Am I cool?

>>72604789
i was so happy when scott weiland died.

File: 6b4a1443ce6697a11537102f05b00f61.jpg (102KB, 950x950px) Image search: [Google]

102KB, 950x950px

10/10

>>72604839
Thx, it was the same day as my birthday.

File: 51wlXMBmP7L.jpg (43KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 500x500px

>>72600849
I'm In It ruins the entire record.

>>72604805
It was just him dicking around with a loop pedal, Returnal was the true apex of his early works.

File: a0fd5705.jpg (589KB, 1731x1731px) Image search: [Google]

589KB, 1731x1731px

>>72604854
my nigga

File: 1485458419335.png (97KB, 710x729px) Image search: [Google]

97KB, 710x729px

>>72604889
i love returnal too it's also 10/10 for me

pic related

File: Ascension.jpg (23KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 500x500px

>>72599061
This would have been flawless had it stopped at Mercy Mercy Me. The latter half isn't bad, just unneeded if taken as a whole work.

>>72604476
I can't stand that Little Red Robin Hood Hit the Road ends in a fade, or at least the proper song before the bagpipes. I know this sounds like a BS critique given that every song on this album ends on a fade out. However, everything preceding the last song feels properly concluded whereas LRRHHtR ends on a drum frenzy before the bagpipes kick in jarringly. My only complaint on this masterpiece.

>>72605128
It's fair criticism but I personally don't see the ending fade as that much of an issue.

Ascension is one of my favorite albums as well.

>>72599061
>>72599319
>>72604082
>>72604970

These are all 10's.

>>72605128
I actually agree with you on What's Going On. If they would've taken the "mother" reprise and put it after Mercy Mercy Me and end there it could've been pristine.

File: a2ac5a8ba8a5a736ecac49c41d614623_full.jpg (365KB, 1441x1429px) Image search: [Google]

365KB, 1441x1429px

The genre itself doesn't count as a flaw

>>72599027
I love that album but the percussion sounds so goofy

>>72599276
This is my favorite album of all time, and I believe that it would not be as good without Last Dance and Homesick, mostly because they give it better flow

>>72604223
this DESU

>>72602314
Only ten tracks long and Wake Up isn't the closing song.

>>72604789
Sounds a bit dated now, like you can tell it was recorded in 1992.

Very comfy album though.

>>72602917
Again, comfy but dated. I do love Alone + Easy Target though.

>>72603164
Fitter Happier

>>72605811
It isn't the Mishima soundtrack.

>>72604256
That's blindly dismissive, not a valid criticism. >>72605869
Eh, In the Backseat works well as a closer. I do wish their other albums were of the same caliber as Funeral. Closest thing IMO is their debut EP.

File: Iceage_Plowing_Into_the_Field_of_Love_Album_Cover.jpg (37KB, 360x360px) Image search: [Google]

37KB, 360x360px

good luck lads

>>72602917

What do you think of There is Nothing Left to Lose? Favorite Foo album for me.

>>72604879
PUT MY FIST IN HER LIKE A CIVIL RIGHTS SIGN

File: MI0003511421.jpg (60KB, 500x498px) Image search: [Google]

60KB, 500x498px

>>72603164
Thom's whiny sounding vocals are hit or miss.

>>72607592
Lyrics are meh. Rattled by the Rush is kind of a boring song. Pavement's earlier shit is better IMO.

>>72607760
I can't really think of a good criticism for this one.

File: Flood_album_cover.jpg (28KB, 302x300px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 302x300px

>>72607760
You win

>>72607518
Not that guy but what do like about it because I really like their first two albums but that one doesn't click with me

>>72605976
there is not a single one, friend. my pick goes to english settlement

>>72601884
personally i feel their lyrics can be really weak and repetative and their stories go no where

>>72608159

I mean I'm not sure, with a lot of things in music it's hard to say exactly why I like it, I just do. I guess one of my favorite aspects is that it's a little more experimental and broad in terms of scope than some of their other earlier albums (Not that they weren't, it just feels like TINLTL is a roller coaster, and in a good way). Part of it is also nostalgia, I guess, Learn to Fly was the first Foo Fighters song I fell in love with and so I really did start with that album, so it has a special place in my heart.

>>72599276
Huh I liked last dance