well it was fun while it lasted

>>72576017
watch ton give it a decent 8

>>72576017
it good album doe

>>72576087
fuck off reddit

>>72576476
Trite

every time I'm with my friend he plays this and honestly I like it a lot more than Salad Days and whatnot

fuck p4k desu

MAC DEMARCO B T F O

>>72576745
lol

theres a few pretty good songs on there 2 was his best

>>72576017
Is 7.9 not a good score?..

>>72576017
7.9 = ~8 = 4/5 stars

how is that bad?

>>72577296
>>72577306
everything that isn't bnm is kind of made to look like it's not really great
especially for an artist who used to get bnms, then it makes them look like they've fallen off

p4k is an enemy to music

>>72576017
JUST
is this the end of Vernor Winfield McBriare Smith IV???

>>72577477
Yes it is Kent.

>On his third album, the antics of Mac DeMarco are muted in favor of his impeccable songwriting, which shines through more than ever with warmth and precision.

How is that a bad review?

>>72577326
You're an idiot if you honestly believe this

>>72577558
it kinda affirms what they liked him for

>>72576017
This is a great score, don't be a spazz anon. Never listened to Mac DeMarco in my life, where do I get started?

>3 singles get BNT
>album gets 7.9

TINY

>>72577824
2 and go backwards

>>72577824
Don't get started, DeMarco is a Shit tier artist who's made one song that's memorable. Ode to viceroy is a decent tune.

How come the new Gas bullshit gets BNM but this doesn't?

>>72577925
the funny thing is that the singles are the least memorable parts of the album. one another, still beating, moonlight on the river etc. are all better songs than my old man, this old dog, on the level by miles.

still though, why do people still trust reviews from this shit website?

>>72579009
>the new Gas bullshit
fuck off fantanofag

>>72579024
See? You have to resort to presuming some sort of aerial bias instead of generating a decent counterargument.

I hope I'm not the only one that thinks this is his best record.

>>72579196
i do as well anon.

its amazing how personal mac gets in this, and he tops it off with some cozy guitar tunes. solid 9/10

Fantano is going to give this a 6 cap this.

>>72576017
Pitchfork has long been shit. However, while obviously 7.9 isn't a "bad" score the fact that they brought it so close to an eight but kept it .1 away is kind of insulting. Almost like they're trying to fuck with him.

Either way it's a solid album and no reason to not give it BNM when they gave that to Salad Days. It's his most diverse and interesting release.

>>72579196
Easily is. 2 was great and Salad Day as well as Another One were both good but similar follow ups.

This album feels like his first step forward into new territory and the songwriting is all still great.

I can't believe they gave three singles best new track but didn't give the album BNM when plenty of the album songs are better than the singles.

>>72579326
huh?
its worse than salad days

> It's his most diverse and interesting release.
what is ying yang and rock n roll nightclub?

>>72576017
So they give him BNM when he releases the same album twice. But when he actually tries to push his sound forward and evolve they only give him a 7.9? Idiots.

>>72579355
Rock n roll Nightclub isn't diverse or interesting, you just think that because he pitch shifts his vocals.

>its worse than salad days

Sorry, I prefer artists to move forward and not re-hash what they've already done.

Ying Yang is irrelevant.

>>72576017
If no red circle no good

>>72579358
this desu

>>72579377
>Sorry, I prefer artists to move forward and not re-hash what they've already done.
pls tell me what he is rehasing on salad days, another one, and some other ones
none of those albums sound alike.

>Ying Yang is irrelevant.
how so?

>>72579399
Salad Days is a complete remake of 2 except with two synth driven tracks. Everyone knows this.

>>72579417
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RheJW2nhkb8
what 2 song sounds like this?

>>72579430
a-all of them anon. Do you have ears?

File: Screen Shot 2017-05-04 at 8.24.02 AM.png (119KB, 638x166px) Image search: [Google]

119KB, 638x166px

>>72579441
>Do you have ears?
pic related

don't reply to me until u have some proof of all of his albums sounding the same

>>72579465
I gave you proof

>>72579465
>prove your subjective opinion to me

Go back to school

File: wXUz3tp.jpg (60KB, 619x619px) Image search: [Google]

60KB, 619x619px

>>72579465
>he's popular therefore you're wrong

>>72579474
what chords is using on salad days and 2

>>72579465
>don't reply to me until u have some proof of all of his albums sounding the same

Nobody said they all sounded the same. I just said Salad Days sounds like 2. Don't reply to me until you fucking comprehend what I posted.

>>72579531
A and G

>>72579552
wrong

>>72579519
youre such a fucking dumbass newfaggot if thats the point you think he was making. Holy shit how new can you be, FUCK

not even that anon but I had to reply because you Booty BOTHERED me so badly

>>72579587
that's literally the argument he was making
you must be very new here

>>72576017
>well it was fun while it lasted

1. That's not a bad score

2. He already has a massive established fanbase so he's good. He ain't going anywhere yet.

>>72579600
Other anon is saying Salad Days is better than This Old Dog. I'm arguing This Old Dog is superior because it's more diverse and not a retread of 2 like Salad Days.

I love all of Macs albums.

Also it has nothing to do with how new you are. You're just dumb.

>>72579519
Way to jump into a conversation without reading previous posts. SMOOTH

>>72579625
People can't comprehend you might disagree with them without completely hating an artist. I agree Salad Days is similar to 2 yet I still love both and actually prefer Salad Days a bit.

Haven't listened to This Old Dog yet but if pitchfork ranked it lower than his other albums I bet that means I'll fucking love it

>>72576017
Fantano is gonna give it an 8

>>72577600
They liked him for Captured Tracks' image and PR money you retard, both of which have shriveled up and died.

>>72580620
you honestly think captured tracks has money to pay p4k

>>72578941
>>72578952
Half-way through Salad Days, this is really good, sounds like the Durutti Column.

>>72578952
>Dreamin
>Passing Out Pieces
>A Heart Like Hers
All memorable and better than Viceroy

Rock and Roll Nightclub - 6/10
2 - 8/10
Salad Days - 7/10
Another One - 6/10
Some Other Ones - 6.5/10
This Old Dog - 5/10

>>72581433
no

>>72579465
>Oh no I like this artist so anything bad people say about it is wrong
Fuck off, the other anon is right all of his songs sound the same

>>72581514
crybaby

>7.9
>bad

>>72581475
I remember them so they're memorable by definition
Btfo

>>72581530
no

>>72579430
You could have at least picked one of the songs from that album that actually has a unique sound like Passing Out Pieces or Chamber of Reflection

>>72581551
why wuld i link the already named synth tracks

Contrarians and elitistfags, if mac is shit, derivative & 'nostalgiacore' then please direct me to whatever artist he sounds like on 2. Because that guitar playing is perhaps some of the most innovative of this century

>>72581617
none
ppl whine all his stuff "sounds the same" but have no better examples

>>72576017
>reviewing music that isn't even out yet

baka

>>72581751
leaked 2 weeks ago newfag

>>72581783
I know that faggot

>>72581869
nah

File: FaceApp_1493789346418.jpg (32KB, 227x227px) Image search: [Google]

32KB, 227x227px

>>72579519
>animenigger proofing himself as braindead again

>>72577574
He needn't believe it for himself for it to be true.

>>72579465
Mac demarco is one of my favorite artists of all time but most of his songs all sound the same

p4k hates albums which don't do new shit, as good as the album is p4k was never gonna give it bnm

>>72580679
They once did, yes. That's why they were getting consistent BNMs up until like 2014. Their image became played out and so the money dried up.

>>72581928
>facebook meme
>unironic animehate
you've been here a week tops, it's obvious

>>72581617
The Return of the Durutti Column

File: DSC_3469-10.jpg (938KB, 1000x1498px) Image search: [Google]

938KB, 1000x1498px

https://wyndwood.bandcamp.com/album/be-yourself

>Acoustic
>Bedroom
>Emo