What did he mean by this?

He gave Kid A the D

It's as good as 21 pilots

It's weird, it's thematically the same album as The Modern Dance with tons of "bangers" like The Modern Dance yet he gave it a 6.5 and TMD a 10.0

>>72493196
he gave the modern dance a 9, he has never given a 10

anyway, this is another example of Scaruffi punishing artists for being "overrated", it's clearly a 7 or 7.5 (in scaruffi's rating system) but he wants to make it clear that the critics "got it wrong" on radiohead so he does this

>>72493196
>it's thematically the same album as The Modern Dance
not even remotely close lol
anyway following your logic one could make the case this is just a carbon copy of another band then

>>72493262
nah kid a is genuinely trash

File: beach boys accurate ratings.png (53KB, 652x482px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 652x482px

I TRIED SO HARD

AND GOT SO FAR

File: Untitled.png (24KB, 429x211px) Image search: [Google]

24KB, 429x211px

reminder that piero scaruffi likes nu metal

>>72493000
seems about right

>>72494324
vol 3 was genuinely good.

>>72493369
>not getting Kid A

how much of a pleb are you

>>72494408
i get kid a its still mediocre for both electronic and rock standards

File: alanis morisette scruffy.jpg (39KB, 766x249px) Image search: [Google]

39KB, 766x249px

Alanis Morisette is rated higher than your favorite album.

>>72494408
not the same anon, but it kind of works the other way round actually.

only plebs think Kid A is something worth 'getting', or genuinely feel some sort of superiority when they do 'get it'.

sad

>>72494442
>>72494470
>I only listen to true innovative music, Beefgeart, Korn, the list goes on

>>72494496
you know scaruffi reviewed more stuff than that right
stuff that people talk about on /mu/ occasionally but you fags dismiss or ignore

>>72494442
because its not trying to suit any of those standards?

>>72494470
I dont feel superior. its an incredibly well crafted album that merges genres like ambient, IDM, and jazz into art rock and makes them accessible, memorable and cathartic. if you cant get into it its your loss anon, you are missing out.

>>72494455
I am secure enough to acknowledge that Jagged Little Pill is better than my favorite album it's a 90s-core classic

>>72494581
why do you radiohead fans always go for that argument? "the album isn't going for that/those standards" ofc it is i'm the one doing that comparison. im the listener. i've listened to tons of albums and seeing the things i've listened to so far radiohead is mediocre. period. why the fuck would you insist its "memorable" or whatever, its the most "meh" band out there, one can obviously see that by seeing the bands that were influenced by them like muse

>>72494455
it actually isn't

so I go to 4chan again because a friend tells me it's not all like /b/ so I start with /mu/

ouch bye forever you guys make my brain hurt

>>72494684
assuming you're the person i've replied to so far, you're really just dumb

>>72493262
Yeah, i meant 9.0

>>72493369
Yes, actually very similar.

The Modern Dance is one of my favorites. Kid A has the same exhausted and insane vocals and lyrics of Pere Ubu's first 4 albums.

In fact, I think you could say OK Computer is just a failed attempt at making The Modern Dance in the style of late Pink Floyd.

>>72494720
>Kid A has the same exhausted and insane vocals
is this bait

>>72494749
Obviously not David Thomas tier
It's either monotone and bored or in panic:
https://youtu.be/mqaD2QAPaLk

I fucking hate Scaruffi drones

>>72494791
>this actually happened
my god thom looks like a fukin idiot
also that's hardly at the same deranged level as david thomas's singing, i don't know what you're saying

>>72494749
>>72494791
>>72494821

You can't tell me that SNL performance doesn't remind you of this:

https://youtu.be/9qnRzCWFgd4

>>72494649
if you dont think its good like me and so many other people is because you dont get it. not as in "you haven't listened to enough music to get it" but simply as that its not for you.

>its the most "meh" band out there, one can obviously see that by seeing the bands that were influenced by them like muse
this is how I can tell you are bitter for not being able to relate to something so many people can enjoy. aphex twin influenced skrillex so by your logic aphex twin should also be "meh" right?

>>72494834
aphex twin is pretty meh too yeah but that's not really the reason why
you fanboys are fukin idiots

>>72494828
i'd say no but i get why you think that's a big reference
i mean thomas looks like he's genuinely crazy
thom looks like he's just doing a classic routine of paranoia that a bunch of bands before him have already done imho

>>72494834
also
>if you dont think its good like me and so many other people is because you dont get it
>people genuinely believe this
yeah i don't like buttrock either must be that i can't get it

>>72494897
I can see your reading comprehension is pretty bad

>>72494880
how am I an idiot? im giving you good arguments on why I think they're good and you can't do anything but throw insults and be condescending.

>aphex twin is pretty meh too yeah
well, thats another pretty bad opinion. i'm sorry you can't enjoy such great things anon. godspeed.

>>72494880
Besides the point that David Thomas is obviously the better frontman, my point >>72493196 still is that Scaruffi loves post-punk exhibiting mental illness and absurdity induced by modern living. He has Kafka's The Trial as the greatest book ever written. Kid A is basically Y and The Modern Dance but incorporating bleep instead of Tribal drums and garage rock. The only reason people dislike it is because it's mainstream.

>>72495006
i genuinely don't think kid a is as much about paranoia and post-industrialism like those post-punk bands but more about just a more accepting phase of man faced with society and whatnot but that's just me

>>72494994
ok bye

>>72493196
How is Kid A in any way similar to The Modern Dance?

I'm really curious