>>72479259
it was 10yrs too late
>>72479259
The production on this album is WAAYY too fucking clean and shiny for it to ever be considered 10/10 in my opinion. Every single sound feels uncomfortably calculated. I prefer my rock music a lot more noisy/messy than Brand New.
>>72479259
emo is whiny af
>>72479259
it's a shit on Brand New thread
>>72479259
This is one of my favorite albums but I prefer a lot of the production of Daisy to TDAG, TDAG has some strange noise sections (like the minute and 30 seconds of guitar feedback at the end of Limosuine) that feel misplaced because of it.
Literally haven't listened to anything else in this thread so LMAO
>>72479259
come now, those vocals are pop-punk tier.
ruins the whole album
Album cover font is the only flaw
>>72479259
Second half of the album trails off for me, solid 8 or 9 though for sure.
>>72479383
>This is one of my favorite albums but I prefer a lot of the production of Daisy to TDAG
I'm in the minority that likes everything about Daisy just a little more, that album is incredible
>>72479387
I'm sorry you hate an entire decade of rock music because of association.
>>72479451
Jesse's accent comes in so much more on Daisy and it's insanely nice
Try and find a flaw that doesn't make you sound retarded
>>72479485
awful opinion
>>72479526
Jaki is the only competent musician. I suppose that's a flaw for Can's entire discog, but Tago Mago is flawless otherwise.
>>72479383
Second half it's not as strong as the first one.
>>72479540
Boring; most overrated EP of all time.
>>72479259
whiny bitch album
>>72479298
inspired Sonic Youth and they're garbage
>>72479526
you have to be retarded to like it
>>72479540
it's just fucking crescendos and some homeless dude spouting /pol/-tier conspriracies
>>72479578
actually a perfect 10
>>72479578
I'm glad this album was posted
So many obvious "flaws" and it's still a 10/10
>>72479362
Hey look one of the three other Braid fans on this board. I fucking love that album
>>72479684
hi brian
>>72479683
Pretentious song titles
>>72479540
here's superior EP from a /mu/core band.
The Sonic Youth EP is great too
>>72479259
Luca is weak
>>72479584
>shitposting: the post
>>72479817
almost entirely made up of filler songs
>>72479540
only 28 minutes long
>>72479383
the drums sound like shit but it's still a great album
>>72479259
handcuffs is easily their weakest album closer by a huge amount, which is a shame because this album really deserves a massive closing track like Noro.
This one is absolute perfection from the first minute till the last. You may not enjoy it, but you can't find flaws. I challenge you.
I love almost every song on this one.
>>72479259
>>72479259
Besides maybe Thank You's vocals, there's literally nothing bad about this album
>>72479985
Darkened Rings suck and Realize My Fate is boring
Cool to see the album posted on /mu/ though. They fell of /mu/s radar with this but I saw them live 2 months ago and they were dope
>>72480000
nice quads
>>72480000
quarts confirm
This album is literally flawless.
>>72480041
youre that thug dick rider that shows up in all the threads
>>72480070
Thug has transcended.
>>72479902
not even the best in their discography but still a great EP
>>72479683
read >>72479684
>>72479895
easily a 10/10
>Drunk as fuck, high as shit, bitch suck my dick
>You ain't never seen a long dick, I said a long dick, I said a long dick
>Bitch, you gonna learn today, you gonna learn today
>Pull it out and spray all on ya lingerie
>Call it a cum grenade, rub it on your tummy
>Shouldn't of never gave your black ass some money
>Now I'm stomping all on your couches, standing all on your tables
>Ripping open your bitch blouses, got my toungue all up in her navel
>The baddest mothafucka 'round, hold my drink bitch
>I said bitch I'm Danny Brown, let me get on my pimp shit
can't debate poetry guys
>>72479985
it was a nice progression from Here and Nowhere Else but the fact it didn't have that same warm fuzzy sound that it's predecessor had was sorely missed imo.
>>72480155
>>72479873
i-i cant!
>>72480125
garbage album
>>72479725
>not getting post-irony
>>72480173
did you forget to adjust your standards? it is a rap album, you know
>>72480260
it's awful even by rap standards
>>72480041
Unironic 10/10
>>72480426
At one point it sounds like the male singer is saying "cocks cocks cocks cocks cooooooocks".
Everything else is an 11/10 though, good taste anon.
>>72480426
How should I listen to this for max enjoyment?
>>72479557
no flaws
>>72480579
If you smoke weed, get baked and have some sugary munchies.
Otherwise, on a pleasant, sunny day while drinking lemonade.
>>72479873
All filler except for angel of death and raining blood. Show no mercy is better.
>>72480640
Great album but not as innovative as /mu/ thinks. Could've been even more forward thinking.
This album has no flaws
>>72480679
>>72480775
too loud
>>72480426
music for fucking thick rimmed glasses wearing, Threads wearing, Little Big Planet playing, entry level manga reading who think this music is "japanese", neckbearded, high pitched plebs
>>72479970
the whole thing sounds the same
>>72479557
Never Meant maybe would've been better if they didn't end it on a fadeout
you won't be able to find a flaw because no one has listened to it
>>72482388
t. Gay person
>>72482388
best post I've ever seen on /mu/
>>72479259
Handcuffs is one of the worst closing tracks of all time
>>72482388
This is actually valid criticism to me.
You guys are pretty gay
>>72479977
Being the best american Post-Punk album is like being the best student in a special ed class
>>72482388
na-ah
I dare you, fuckers.
>>72479578
this faggot sounds like spongebob
>>72480066
Big Fig Wasp is pretty forgettable.
>>72479526
>kraut
>>72482388
all me btw
>>72479259
>>72480426
Nothing, it's perfect for what it is.
>>72479383
Too noisy to feel any emotion at some points (Hunter).
>>72479895
It's so aimless and there's no focus. It's like it's missing a visual piece to score on.
>>72480000
Too clean production, the best parts of sample-based music is when you hear the flaws that artists leave in from a time that's past.
Most overlooked album of 2014
>>72483147
No Shows was pretty good but that was it for great hooks, not a very memorable listen
>>72483046
Ma nigga
>>72483147
The fuzzy guitar songs like No Shows, Juarez, Zero Zero, and so on are great it's a shame that they're only half the album and the other half are average pop rock songs.
you cannot find a flaw. it's literally impossible.
>>72483333
quads speak truth
>>72483333
Fuck your quads this album is bullshit their good albums are
>HCTI
>ST
>MPP
>CH
>>72483359
Sung Tongs is one of their worst
>>72480160
<3 bought this LP and my girlfriend loves Ocean Man
Hard mode: No mentions of politics
>inb4 we wuz kangs
>>72483359
>no feels
>no strawberry jam
STGSTV is the best one
>>72479259
>>72483384
This is kind of a weird choice for a personal 10 as one of the most lauded albums in recent memory, but I agree.
>>72479395
Actually Vikernes is a flaw by himself... No offence
>>72483374
Nope it's their third best behind MPP and CHz
>>72483417
>CHz
come on. it's good but nowhere near their best
>>72483406
Feels is actually okay always forget about it
PW > SJ I hate them both though
>>72483430
It's more than stupid noise and bad singing like most of their albums.
>>72483462
>he doesn't think Strawberry Jam and STGSTV have fantastic vocal deliveries
>>72479259
>>72482344
10/10 album my man
i wish brian mcmahan did more stuff
>>72482421
The only flawless album ITT.
>>72479526
Aumgn should be 6 mins at most
>>72482388
What's the point of posts like these? Why quote a bunch of posts and say stupid shit? I wish all shitposters died
>inb4 voice
I honestly love her voice and don't understand the complaints about it
>>72482388
Ikr I can't believe people keep posting such gay albums baka
>>72480640
Most overrated piece of meme shit I have ever heard. Horrible spoken word vocals, guitar parts are generic and make Curt Cobain sound like Paul Gilbert.
>>72482868
Style over substance. Scooby doo chase music..."but its fun"...total shit.
>>72479298
>>72479383
>>72479526
>>72480640
>>72482344
>>72482359
>>72482421
>>72482659
>>72482889
Nice taste.
Also, the premise of this thread is retarded. How can we have enough insights into everyone's reasons for having personal 10s to actually find flaws in the reasoning? Oh yeah, I'm on /mu/, better not get too serious senpai.
>>72482344
What is this called?
>>72483937
Not that anon but https://rateyourmusic.com/release/album/the-for-carnation/the-for-carnation/
It's Brian's project after Slint. Highly recommend giving it a listen.
>>72483971
Thanks! My best friend listens to Slint, but I never really heard much of them
>>72483407
Nice choice, I found no flaws in it
Stumbleine - Ghosting
>>72479259
slightly too weird, doesn't indulge enough in the emotion of tracks like 'Jesus Christ' and 'Sowing Season' to hold my interest in the rest of the tracks
>>72479383
overly dark. not depressing as it's intended and as most people think it to be, just apocalyptic. borders on pretentiousness
>>72479557
gets a bit whiny sometimes
>>72479895
it's close to a 10, but a bit too conceptual for my tastes
>>72480125
I 'don't get' danny brown. He just seems goofy for the sake of being goofy, and his songs also strike me as really bland. I feel like I'm missing something
>>72480758
has nothing on TDS (sorry :'D)
>>72482359
a bit too washed-out and up its own arse
>>72483046
don't get me started. overrated as fuck. the most boring BoC album to date, it offends me that much. Geogaddi is far, far better. I don't know what they were thinking with this album
>>72483199
it's clipping too much. I get that it's supposed to be like that but it's just not my thing. I like his other stuff though.
>>72483384
ooooh. this one misses the mark by just a bit. Still a fantastic album though. I think it's because it tries slightly too hard.
>>72480880
It only sounds good when you listen to all teh songs consecutively, shuffled or by themselves they aren't that great.
>>72484244
>LMAO so quirky XD
is there literally a more reddit band
>>72479526
Aumgn and Peking O' are too much of the album
>>72480640
For Dinner isn't perfect, it's just kind of there. Every other song is.
>>72480000
Some songs get repetitive.
>>72479383
the more laid back/ambient sections feel a tad uninspired
>>72480672
this is really fucking annoying when you're not in the right mood for it
>>72480758
my personal favorite NIN release desu guy
>>72483147
i hope gerard decides to experiment more on his solo stuff as opposed to almost no experimentation in MCR (not counting danger days)
>>72479540
The interview is annyoing, and it doesn't help the music at all.
>>72479873
>>72486793
0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0
>>72479895
Monheim is the best way to finish the album and they fucked it up.
>>72480640
That instrumental is an obvious one.
>>72481175
It's boring, too repetitive.
>>72482421
Some of the songs go for too long and aren't as interesting as the first two tracks.
>>72483609
10/10 album cover at least
The only "flaw" I'm aware of are the vocals. They sound perfect to me though.
>>72479895
Pompous, overblown, cheaply emotional wank.
>>72479526
Two great tracks and muchos filler. Taco mako.
>>72483333
The beginning of April and The Phantom is unnecessary.
>>72480880
Nervous Young Inhuman isn't all that good. It can't compare to the other songs
>>72480406
Blakes got a new face is absolutely horrid
>>72486215
This is a great choice. Dunno about a ten but it's got nothing bad about it.
It was the only record my stoner group at uni could agree on and got thoroughly rinsed out in consequence.
>>72483837
beach music is better
also yeah it's /mu/
>>72479540
plain awful
godsperg
>>72479383
came here to post this, can't find any flaws except the shart-level audio quality due to tim losing the masters.
>>72483407
Hidden track
But no, this album is phenomenal. Especially Even Fantastica and how it kind of mockingly describes how some people imagine what an afterlife would look like. That got me good because I have thought about it that way before.
>>72479259
Some of the lines are way too melodramatic
With more consistent lyrics though that album would be an actual 10/10. One of my favorites
>>72479298
Holy shit good taste
Worst thing I can say about it is I wish it was longer/had more tracks on it
Although I guess Is This Real kind of covers that already
>>72479451
>>72479521
Daisy fuckin rules
Still think the lyrics are that album's weak point though
>>72479985
They should have gone full noise rock after Here And Nowhere Else
this album sounds like it could have been made by any generic emo revival band
>>72480426
Even Roberto admits the longer ambient passages are a little much
>>72480826
Amazing highs but when it's weak it's reeeeally fucking weak
>>72482359
Most of the time they just sound like they're drowning in effects and not in a good way
>>72486075
Maybe the only album on here I can't say anything bad about
>>72484192
inb4 "that's the point" but the production. this is one of my favorite albums too but a remaster to be able to hear everything better would be so nice
>>72483609
Only Skin should have been the closer with Cosmia sandwiched between Monkey & Bear and Sawdust & Diamonds.
>>72483346
The album art is absolutely horrid. Bedsides that its great.
Come to think of it most of Built to Spill's discog has terrible album art like holy shit most of it is objectively ugly.
>>72487706
an absence of humour that functions like a black hole, sucking in and crushing to meaninglessness everything that comes into its orbit
>>72486827
>>72487706
Thom Yorke's voice
>>72487725
Lads, it's Muse.
>>72487678
This could also be posted in an 11/10 openers thread.
>>72479259
>personal
lol you like anything /mu/ likes, you stupid fucking sheep
>>72487886
The music itself is kind of underwhelming and overproduced. The lyrical content is absolutely astounding but unfortunately it kind of stops there.
Production-wise, it should've been just a tad grittier.
>>72487257
The vocals are pretty bad. Its not whinny in a good way like Brave Little Abacus, its just annoying. Also the production is to damn clean, its not nearly as noisey or loud as it should have been and because of that it sounds like the cringe worthy diary of a bullied 14 year old.
That being said I generally enjoyed the instrumentation even if it was, like i said, to clean.
>>72487891
Preach my obligatory nigger.
>>72480406
Asinine album cover and underdeveloped sound.
>>72479895
65% filler.
>>72479741
Watered down and weak.
>>72479557
Maybe a bit too whiny.
>>72479383
Some tracks go on for way too long. Earthmover is totally justified in its length but Hunter and Big Gloom are just timewasters.
Come at me
>>72488020
I forgot my image.
>>72483407
One more thing, I don't think they should have included the end of Losing Carolina; For Drusky where they almost explain what the song is about. It's already hinted at in the title that it was about Donald Drusky, the guy who sued God.
The lyrics of the album, while surrounding the themes of life, death and God, are intentionally left open for interpretation so that part kind of went against the flow of the album
>>72480758
Listening to this over a decade later and Reznor really nailed the protest album with this one. It's anti George-W, but not so much that it's dated. Even Capital-G is still relevant. Other protest abums like Gorillaz current Anti-Trump album is so mediocre; It's already dated and stale.
>>72483490
Flawless. Defined multiple genres and still one of the best albums ever created.
>>72486381
Get the hell out of here, this EP is a 6/10 at best. Bunch of mumbling with noise over top of it with songs that are either cut too short or go way too long.
>>72487705 The singer needs to try a new delivery it gets old (first two tracks are 10/10 tho)
>>72488047 Kirsten Supine does absolutely nothing for me
>>72479259
Luca makes me shit myself everytime
>>72488036
>screams "HEAD SOUTH" in your ear
>>72483384
i have never seen anyone actually listen to this album in person a month past its release. it's just pure wank and boring jazzy beats
>>72487719
>muh two minutes of frog noises
Still perfect though, good taste anon.
>tfw the brass section in Cassandra Gemini
>>72487032
>Reign in Blood
> 0-0-0-0-0
What the fuck are you going on about, King and Henneman's guitar work on this album is amazing.
>>72487996
17 minute opening track
>>72479259
Immature
>>72479540
Most overrated EP ever ( >>72479581 )
>>72479578
Shitty vocals and the music isn't good
>>72479817
Repetitive, simple, boring with all with the same exact song forms
>>72479895
Overrated, takes too long
>>72480160
Literally none
>>72487458
I thought Dan lost them, also I somehow doubt the album would feel the same if it wasn't potato
>>72480160
But for real, waving my dick
>>72488729
"King look, I have this awesome riff for a breakdown on Angel of Death, what do you have for the intro?"
"A bunch of empty chords"
Still an excellent album, but that's a flaw.
>>72483046
I personally feel that Hunter is one of the best tracks on the album, I find that the way it swells and climaxes conveys a lot of emotion to me
>>72487886
Sue
>personal 10/10
>>72488996
that's one of my favourite tracks
>>72488828
PLEB
L
E
B
Factual 10/10
>>72479526
Can't
>>72488930
Boring, wankery filled middle. Too long.
>>72489883
Lyrics are lsd-fuelled nonsense. They do a good job of capturing an essence of "youth" but some real substance would have been nice.
>>72480041
Birdman on Knocked Off
>>72480066
Mr Beat irritates me
>>72480125
dopehead sounds way too similar to danny
>>72482758
we major is ASS
>>72483384
mortal man is boring, trying too hard and the 2pac part makes people think its better than it is
>>72486827
untitled is pointless and kind of hurts the great ending that is MPS
>>72487706
the verses in Bones are shitty (not just the lyrics, everything during the verses)
>>72490829
>untitled is pointless
"""Untitled""" literally isn't listed on the tracklist
Cancel your Spotify subscription
>>72491311
shitty butt rock
>>72491323
shitty nu-male music
>>72491323
Biggest flaw in this one is that they'll never make anything that good again
Everything is perfect and I don't care that it's pleb music
>>72491323
i can't enjoy this anymore. I just can't.
This album makes me cum
>this
>>72492043
oh fucking god the opening few songs (basically one song) are incredible. and am I in heaven going from psych folk to full throttle psych rock. great album.
>>72492377
I don't care how attached you may be to this, but it has a couple good songs, some filler.
>>72480406
I think I'm having a seizure from it, hwlp me
>>72483619
not very flawed
>>72483046
this was a disappointment, everyone was wanting something better than geogaddi when it came out and it failed to deliver
>>72479557
Love them, but it has dead weight
>>72483147
I know you may be attached to this album, but I would listen to it like once then discard
>>72479895
wank ridden
>>72487257
horrible vocals. their following albums were better
>>72487405
generic bleeps
>>72489059
Agree, it's a ten. And their self titled is a 9.5
>>72491323
straight up annoying at times
>>72492043
Just a load of garage jamming. It's defo good, but no 10 haha
>>72488036
modest mouse is usually unbearable, but this was a good listen
>>72479383
only fault I have is the drum machine instead of an actual drummer
>>72479683
sad boy singer
>>72483837
the only song i dont like is the seinfeld bass one.
>>72480406
Contra is actually like a million times better than this shit
Fite me niggas
>>72493403
A few forgettable tracks, although that's probably because of how good the standout ones are.
>>72487257
>>72479557
The A side has some songs that feel a little disjointed. The B side however, is perfect
>>72488255
I feel like the grating video-game synths in Peacebone are only there for the sake of being "weird." It's a forced element that nearly ruins the track.
And Safer does absolutely nothing for me. It should have been cut altogether.
>>72493124
Anon, MHTRTC came out before Geogaddi...
>>72494608
Safer is a bonus track Btw
>>72494643
Oh. Well, good then.
>>72493445
How can you fuck it up when it's the same song over and over and over and over
>>72479581
>>72488930
Shut the fuck up
>>72488944
you're probably right
>>72488200
kirtsen supine is my favourite track on the album
>>72483374
you're fucked
>>72493285
i don't see anything generic about it, replica is more polished though
>>72479557
fucks with my feels to hard
this and Danny Brown - XXX
>>72495882
XXX has some spotty production all over
>>72496046
literally the track with the worst production, that being 30 - is the best on the whole album
>>72496071
uh no 30 has great production
>>72483384
>Rhapsody on complexion is pure garbage
>hook on you aint gotta lie is not so good either
>>72483384
its just kendrick rapping over shit jazz
>>72496211
and it's as pretentious as it sounds
>>72484128
>you dont get danny brown
Dude's sad as fuck, creative as fuck and came from nothing, everything he puts out is fucking great for real. Verbal herbal poison, words I contortion, fucked a pregnant bitch she saved money on her abortion
Just TRY to find 1 flaw.
>>72496327
If it wasn't for Madlib this album would be a 6/10 at best. This album reminds me a lot of Live.Love.A$AP. where the MC isn't doing anything amazing. They aren't getting in the way of the production either so it works, but there could be lyrical improvement.
>>72496435
I'm not the guy that posted that album but a lot of the stuff Freddie is rapping about is personal to him and shit that has happened over the past few years and in the past, listen to his earlier shit then listen to this.
>>72496435
not saying you're wrong but did you read the lyrics? the album got wayyyy better for me once i did.
>>72479259
GOAT
>>72496462
The album is in my top 100. I get that personal note on songs and have paid attention to the lyrics. There is just a certain point where the lyrics are unrelatable to me.
Not even joking, me and my friends driving around singing along to this and having fun listening to this albums have been some of the most fun I've had in my life.
>No politics
>>72496344
It's king diamond, that's a pretty big flaw right there.
>>72487032
boring? Maybe because it's so influential. Can you imagine being around back then to hear Playa Hataz for the first time? Walk Up 2 Your House is definitely not boring
>>72496535
>a certain point where the lyrics are unrelatable to me.
>a gangster rap album
how surprising
>>72487706
it was nice when i was 14
>>72487725
i might actually say this. So much young heavenly energy. Space Dementia is the low point for me
>>72496673
everything after the first track is just OK
Anyone else think this is a 10/10? Don't see it discussed here
>inb4 dad rock
>>72479683
a lot of forgettable tracks desu
>>72480426
gets boring
>>72480640
spoken word
>>72487705
can get repetitive
>>72491428
have a cigar is not as strong as the rest
>>72496620
I agree about the influence, I can't deny that even if I wanted to. But the songs go for too long and most of them don't give the "hypnotic" vibe (though, of course, some of them are great).
Just try, plebs
>>72496471
tfw your album is a 10/10
>*plop*s your path
>>72496726
Mine too (>>72487032) :^).
>>72483384
BOOBOO
>>72483384
honestly too long
i feel like it should have been a double album
i do have ADHD though
>>72496735
Live version is 10x better
>>72496837
is it a flaw when the band can perform the album very well?
>>72490829
Untitled is the intermediate track in between the record sides
>>72497376
Title track. That is all.
>>72497376
Meat is Murder is a shitty fucking song
Personal 10/10?
>>72492043
this is a 10, sorry. my first and favourite KGATLW album
>>72479259
dude the only songs worth liking and listening to on this album are the first 5
>>72496569
submission is hedious
>>72484128
i'm listening to your piece of shit right now and it's so fucking annoying holy shit
>>72497492
Too childish
>>72487725
Tbf Muse were brilliant when they wrote songs while tripping balls on mushrooms. The last couple of albums have been shit, they can't party like the used to because kids and the bass player is an alcoholic. Now they are just a less popular, crazier Coldplay.
>>72479259
it wasn't deja
>>72496607
everytime I see it I think it's the cover for the chainsmokers album
>>72493323
Personally anything 2000 and onward is terrible, their newer stuff is some of the worst music ive ever listened to
>>72496607
it wasn't the glow pt. 2
>>72497781
exactly what is childish about this album? Is it because a core of /mu/ were young when it came out? Does this mean everything we liked when we were young is childish? Demon Days isnt childish. I could see if you took ween or pavement for example and said that was childish because those bands are a bunch of goofballs.
>>72491323
nu-male normie garbage
Anyone over 14 who unironically enjoys this is on the autism spectrum
its from mu
>>72480672
Rafael?
>>72497995
NOTM is better imo but they're both 10s.
>>72497995
>>72497962
So what are its flaws, then?
>>72497962
Jeez man chill I think the album could actually be more childish. It takes itself too seriously at times.
>>72496673
I love this album, but Come Togehter really ruins the mood. I like the song, but after a PERFECT song, it follows up kinda meh.
>>72479383
>>72479540
>>72479683
>>72479895
>>72480000
>>72487452
>>72487706
>>72491428
>>72496673
I'll hang out with you.
>>72479578
Perfect, but I still prefer their first one.
No flaws just endless beauty
>>72487706
Bones and My Iron Lung
Before Tom went full hobo
>>72488318
That part is good.
>>72483619
>>72491311
>>72494817
All perfect; no filler.
>>72498560
10/10 and could never match up to any TMV album
>>72496327
has a Mac Miller Feature
The track with Ab-Soul also kinda blows
>>72496207
Quas' flows just sound too awkward sometimes.
>>72491323
A little over the top obnoxious at some points.
all three of those are still in my top 100 though.
>>72498278
last living souls
>>72498866
K then.
You guys all have great taste :)
>>72498147
For sure NOTM is top tier.