Album Rate Thread

I'm omw to work but good luck OP

Do you have a template

File: RATE.png (11KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 828x887px

>>72461732
here ya go anon

File: ratedrreview.png (44KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

44KB, 828x887px

>>72461827

>>72461871
>Monsters in the Parasol - 2
>Lightning Song - 8
delete this right now

>>72461909
I'm fine with changing Lightning Song, but Monsters in the Parashit can stay right where it is; at the bottom of the barrel of all QotSA songs. :^)

File: The Glow Pt.2.jpg (379KB, 747x800px) Image search: [Google]

379KB, 747x800px

>>72461409

>>72461871
>Auto Pilot that low
>Monsters in the Parasol THAT low
STOP

>>72461985
>Auto Pilot that low
okay, ya got me
>Monsters in the Parasol THAT low
yeah, should be lower :^)

fight me

File: abbey.png (185KB, 1220x1220px) Image search: [Google]

185KB, 1220x1220px

>>72463544
oh fuck forgot the file >:(

>>72463571
How can you rate an album 8.8 out of 10? How can your subjective view of an album be boiled down so precisely that it is a percentage?

>>72463592
I just feel like that's my thoughts on the record, it's not a nine for me, but it's not a eight and half, It's not about being precise enough but summarizing what I feel in the record. Kinda stupid I know, but grew up in a school which grades where not 9 or 10, but instead, broken numbers.

File: 1493383942197.jpg (301KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

301KB, 828x887px

Prepared to be called pleb
But I legit think Oasis' first two albums are among the best British albums of the 90s

File: 1493151592643.png (168KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

168KB, 828x887px

>>72463782
Pleb

File: 1493383942197.png (178KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

178KB, 828x887px

It's such a shame about that 9th track. The rest of the album is so consistent yet so varied in sound...

>>72461409
would put Hazey Jane II at a 9, bump One of These Things First up to a 10, Bryter Layter to a 9, Poor Boy to a 10, and maaaayyyybeeee just maybe put Northern Sky to a 9

File: 1493383942197 (1).png (110KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

110KB, 828x887px

Rated down for lack of cohesive theme and y'know cuz nothing's really a 10

I actually rate Bryter Layter and Five Leaves Left about the same (5 leaves left a bit higher) even though I don't like many of the tracks on Bryter Layter because I like the jazzy theme and orchestra on Bryter Layter, and they're both nice to listen to for different things.

On an individual song level, five leaves left is the best Nick Drake album

>>72464648
The Shark Private Fuck is one of their best in my opinion

File: 1493383942197 (2).png (215KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

215KB, 828x887px

heck, I might as well do Pink Moon too since that'll mean I can compare all 3

As you can see, thematically I prefer Bryter Layter, but in terms of individual songs I prefer 5 leaves left. Pink Moon is somewhere in the middle of both.

File: 1490142441589.png (101KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

101KB, 828x887px

>>72461409

>>72465050
Here is your (you) friend

>>72465076
lower Shankly to 8, bump never had no one ever up to a 9, (maybe lower bigmouth to a 9 and Some Girls are bigger than others)

File: cj78n78c3c.png (241KB, 444x606px) Image search: [Google]

241KB, 444x606px

>>72465084
>This is Yesterday
>Not a 10

File: 1493383942197 (3).png (86KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

86KB, 828x887px

>>72464648
>>72465008
really? maybe I'll give it another attempt to enjoy it but it's never clicked

as for Rising Tide...

File: mewithoutYou - Ten Stories Rating.png (241KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

241KB, 828x887px

>>72461409
Figured I'd give my de facto favourite album a rating on each track, wanted to be brutal so as not to exaggerate the quality which I fear many do on here, the album whilst I know it isn't particularly phenomenal even compared to the band's other works still holds a certain value to me and emits feelings that cannot be described on paper and thus I shall always cherish it.

>>72465268
Jesus, need to get 'round to that album someday.

>>72465458
I think it's not commonly regarded as highly as, say, Substrata or maybe Patashnik but I think it's my personal favourite of Biospheres discography along with Substrata.

>>72463782
Slide Away is pretty low desu

File: lambreview.png (152KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

152KB, 828x887px

First three songs are so good. Too bad the rest of the album is somewhat worse.

File: urban hymns rate.png (247KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

247KB, 828x887px

>>72463782
Columbia is amazing

>>72466597
underrated desu

File: 981228.png (231KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

231KB, 828x887px

>>72465641
Accurate rating.

>>72468468
long season should be 11/10 desu

File: A7PHA.png (41KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

41KB, 828x887px

NO BRAKES is awesome, the video is a masterpiece to my eyes

>>72468735
Yeah, but I wanted to be fair to all the other songs.

File: damn.png (228KB, 873x889px) Image search: [Google]

228KB, 873x889px

>>72465362
this is mine lol

>>72463592
I prefer not to have numerical ratings for music, but if I had to use them, I'd definitely want the option to be that specific. Sometimes, you can just feel that something is somewhere between two points and want to express that.

File: TEMPLATE 1.png (205KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

205KB, 828x887px

took forever

File: TEMPLATE 1.png (206KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

206KB, 828x887px

>>72469842
shit forgot scores

>>72469842
>>72469873
Pretty cool anon!

>>72470212
aw thanks

File: 3.png (62KB, 300x433px) Image search: [Google]

62KB, 300x433px

>>72469842
>>72469873
This is really cool anon, it'd suck if this thread went dead and got 404'd in a hour with few responses, for that effort you deserve (you)s, and not in a sarcastic sense.

>>72469537
>LOVE gets a 3
>DNA and HUMBLE get a 2 and a 1

What?

File: 1493383942197.png (196KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

196KB, 828x887px

>>72465294
>Red not as good as Providence

Why? Otherwise great taste

how tf do I do this on paint.net

File: atdi rating.png (190KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

190KB, 828x887px

>>72471558
1. Paste template
2. Paste album art
3. Resize album art into the square
4. Use the paint bucket tool to fill in squares
5. Use the text tool to add text
6. Save the image
7. Upload to 4chins

>>72471306
Dishonest rates. You should be thrown out.

File: AMSPrating.jpg (201KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

201KB, 828x887px

AMSP is a great album, don't think people give it as much credit as it deserves

File: lovelessrate.png (258KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

258KB, 828x887px

>>72471619
ty based anon ily, also accurate chart except invalid litter dept, should be a ten

>>72471878
>first three not all at least nines
cmon son

File: 1493420370101.png (424KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

424KB, 828x887px

>>72471839
>Soon
>Only a 9

>>72471891
Side A is probably the weakest IMHO.
I chose to give Halleluwah, Augmn, Peking O all 10s because they're "shit we've never heard before" on a compositional and production POV and are amazing for 1971, and out of the time frame too. Another 10 for Coffee/Tea because it's so articulated it's beautiful.
Gave Paperhouse a 9 because it's very good and the progression is great too but it's not a real jump given what they've done before, same for Oh Yeah's 8.
Mushroom a 6 because it's short and repetitive - the positives are that guitar undertones are creepy and paranoid as hell and generally well executed, very unconventional too.

That's the reasoning behind it.

File: pure guava.png (209KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

209KB, 828x887px

>>72471642
What the fuck are you on about

File: owuwayn.png (155KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

155KB, 828x887px

>>72461871
>>72461909 here, made one of my own

File: ratedr.png (39KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

39KB, 828x887px

>>72472149
aaaaaaaand wrong picture

File: cityreview.png (170KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

170KB, 828x887px

Reflects more on the opinion of the album I had like 6 years ago when I listened more of this stuff, but still kinda relevant today. Would probably be a 10 without the Room 429 cover.