Ramones or Clash?

>>72372453
The Clash

ramones

>>72372453
the clash no question

>>72372453
Ramones imo.

>>72372453
The Clash

Clash>>>Ramones>>>>>>>>>Sex Pistols, even if they're all posers.

Bruh The Clash made "London Calling" m8. Easy win.

File: ChTqdREWUAE_qZv.jpg (32KB, 600x200px) Image search: [Google]

32KB, 600x200px

>>72372453
ramones

Los ramon es

>>72372501
(The album with only 4 great songs)

>Lost In The Supermarket
>Guns of Brixton
>Wrong Em Boyo
>I'm Not Down

>>72372557
reply

>>72372557
>Wrong em Boyo

"no"

>>72372453

Both?

>>72372453
Ramones, by far.

The Clash is fucking garbage.

>>72372557

>forgetting Clampdown

>>72372557
>what is Hateful
>what is Lover's Rock
>what is Brand New Cadillac
>what is Right Profile
>what is Spanish Bombs

File: Dude Guys Stop.jpg (6KB, 250x226px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 250x226px

>>72372576
>>72372579
>>72372605
>>72372639
>ok

Neither. Shit music.

Lmao the ramones. Strictly bitches listen to the clash

@72372720

I think you're just fishing for some (You)s

Both great 70s bands that fuckin sucked in the 80s

The Clash are my favourite band so obviously I'll go with them. I don't understand the appeal of Ramones really. I'd like to get in to them but they almost come off as pop punk to me... really weak vocals which lack the bite of Strummer's and other punk singers of the time, muddy sounding guitars which are not brought alive in the mix (compare I Wanna Be Sedated with White Riot), pretty dull lyrics compared to the challenging lyrics of their contemporaries, and a pop style of songwriting which they never shook off.

Can someone change my mind by giving me a god tier Ramones song to listen to now please? I wanna like em.

paul simonon looks like he's calling on a cellular phone

>>72373311
Well you described the Ramones pretty well, they are pop punk, they're just considered "punk" because they were one of the first. They're songs are clearly largely influenced by bubblegum pop and 60's girl groups. If that doesn't appeal to you there isn't really a song I could show you that would change your mind. I would just recommend the first 4 Ramones albums and if you don't like them you just don't like the band, which is fine

The clash because they actually had real talent and were competent musicals

>>72373394
I see, fair enough. I don't dislike the Ramones or anything, but I guess they're just wedged too awkwardly between the genres for me personally. If I want to listen to some punk, I'll go for something more energy than the somewhat pedestrian Ramones, and if I want to listen to pop I'll probably just listen to something with cleaner production. Ah well, maybe they'll grow on me some day.

>>72373492
I can see that, that may be one reason I don't listen to them much anymore. There's "poppier" sounding stuff and more aggressive sounding stuff so if you're craving one of those sounds there are better more "extreme" options. Plus the Ramones songs are insanely simple and straight forward, not much complexity, so I could see the music having limited replay value due to that, yet that straight forwardness is also the appeal of the band for people who like them

File: 1441929641039.png (174KB, 308x308px) Image search: [Google]

174KB, 308x308px

>>72372589

>>72372453
>implying Sex Pistols isn't the best

ramones. never heard a good song by the clash.

File: 1397775150678.png (872KB, 910x599px) Image search: [Google]

872KB, 910x599px

The Replacements
British punk rock is so shit, the best music to come from britbongistan was Post-punk, shoegaze, and Kate Bush

>>72375583
>implying you have taste

>>72375583
kys

How does Joe Strummer rate as a guitarist?

>>72377730
average, remember he only played rhythm

great songwriter though

>>72372557
fuck outta here

File: strummer-006.jpg (32KB, 460x276px) Image search: [Google]

32KB, 460x276px

>>72377795
nah he could solo, albeit imprecisely
to me being a good songwriter and good guitarist are tied together

>>72377730
More of a strummer than a shredder

>influence
ramones
>ability
clash
>consistency
ramones
>high points
clash
>cultural significance
this one's a tie because they both had impacts in their regions
>punkness
this one's up to you

>>72378159
well it's a good thing he's not called Joe Shredder

>>72372453
X-Ray Spex

>>72378182
punkness should undoubtedly go to ramones

a gang of shithead kids from queens will always without question be more punk than some british faggots

>>72375583
This

SP > C >>>>> R

>>72378306
gay

>>72378182
spot on

Ramones, easily. I do like the Clash, just not nearly as much

>>72372890
>Subterranean Jungle
>Too Tough to Die
>Animal Boy
>Brain Drain
>Ramones sucked in the 80s
alright m8

>>72372639
>The Right Profile
My fucking nigga, that song has my favourite moment of the album, I've never seen anyone else talk about it

The Clash and its not even close for me

File: mod-1-3075-102.jpg (67KB, 855x855px) Image search: [Google]

67KB, 855x855px

The Jam