Now that the dust has settled, can we all agree that this is

That isn't St. Anger

>>72347873
this

File: 8e1f63f81dde5d818d2186b7d6cb925128d8dab6941a044514eecc9c9e3a5ba0.gif (158KB, 329x353px) Image search: [Google]

158KB, 329x353px

>>72347873
>>72347897
Guys, this is a SERIOUS thread for SERIOUS discussion

>>72347579
Literally every Metallica album post-AJFA is better than Death Magnetic

>>72347579
Sure but it's still hot garbage

>>72347939
Not memeing, St. Anger is very underrated.
Realistically:
Black Album>Load>St Anger>New One>ReLoad>DM

>>72347939
St. Anger has fantastic tracks, it's just the snare sound that's memed to death. It's a genuine fantastic album and the only one after AJFA I can even listen to.

>>72347941
>>72347946
>>72347969
There's not even one bad song on DM. If it were released in 1985 by some obscure thrash band, you guys would love it.

I really like Death Magnetic, and still listen to a few songs off of it. Suicide & Redemption is the best instrumental track they've done.

>>72348124
This. It's even better than Call of Kthulu

>>72348039

That drum sound, tho. I know they were aiming for that lo-fi garage band sound, but that was taking the piss.

>>72348039
>>72347969
>>72347941
>Frantic
>Fuel
kys

Death Magnetic is better than St. Anger, anyone who says otherwise is trolling

>>72348043
No memorable ones, neither. And no, if it were released in 1985 by some obscure thrash band, I would have put it in the trash, next to the countless generic thrash albums made by obscure thrash bands.

DM was a halfassed project to return to their aggressive days, guitars are decent but not even close to their work in AJFA or Dave Mustaine stuff on the early albums, the melodic take comes off as generic, rather than interesting experiments like they did on The Black Album or Load. It doesn't help that the production is goddamn awful.

I mean, if you're a metalhead, I can see why you think DM is the best thing since AJFA, but in general, DM is the weakest work the band ever put.

>>72348396
>Post Grunge
>experimental
kekek

>>72348430
it says experiments, not experimental m8