ITT Albums that would be 10/10 if they removed some tracks

I actually like every song on HTTT. Worse are I Will and Punchup and even those I'd keep.

>>72347193
Which ones though? If you say Scatterbrain you're wrong.

>>72347193
has anyone who's tried thom's alternative track listing enjoyed it more?
>>72347216
this. just remove sdt and it's a 10

>>72347234
2+2=5 needs to be the starting track so it seems flawed simply because he put it at #8

File: imgres.jpg (5KB, 239x211px) Image search: [Google]

5KB, 239x211px

Pink Floyd - Meddle

"Echoes" is easily my favorite song of all time and my favorite off of this album. And the other songs on that album are really solid...except for "San Tropez". It would have been a 10/10 album for me had it not been for that one misplaced, awkward, and forgettable track.

>>72347264
all the tracks in this album are good though

>>72347302
>except for "San Tropez"
I would undestand Seamus but San Tropez is fantastic, mate

>>72347305
"Spider in the snow" kills the vibe after "What do you want me to say"

>>72347264
I guess You Are Invited could be sped up but removing a song would make this record worse

>>72347234
A little more, but I feel that some of the better tracks on there (Backdrifts and Punchup mainly) not being included is sort of frustrating. I usually listen to Thom's tracklist without Myxomatosis and replace it with the previously-mentioned tracks. Backdrifts works much better near the end of the album than the beginning, and Punchup is fine without I Will, and moves well into A Wolf at the Door.

Every album

File: the doors.jpg (24KB, 294x295px) Image search: [Google]

24KB, 294x295px

>I LOOKED AT YOU
>YOU LOOKED AT ME
>I SMILED AT YOU
>YOU SMILED AT ME

>>72347322
I kind of like Seamus. There's something about its quirkiness that's enjoyable to me. It reminds me of something I'd hear in Pink Floyd's earlier, more experimental work.

Best Tracklist
1. 2+2=5
2. Sit Down. Stand Up
3. A Punch Up at a Wedding
4. Myxomatosis
5. The Gloaming
6. Backdrifts
7. Go To Sleep
8. Sail to the Moon
9. Where I End and You Begin
10. There There
11. Scatterbrain
12. Wolf at the Door

>>72347220
Punch Up is god tier

>>72347356
>Implying

>>72347234
It's nice if you switch There There and 2+2=5.

File: doolittle.jpg (889KB, 800x800px) Image search: [Google]

889KB, 800x800px

Silver

File: IMG_2798.jpg (116KB, 450x281px) Image search: [Google]

116KB, 450x281px

I actually made an alternate HTTT tracklist the other day and I think it's quite good:

Hail to the Thief (Buried in Cement)
01 2 + 2 = 5
02 Where I End and You Begin
03 Sail To The Moon
04 A Punch Up At a Wedding
05 Go to Sleep
06 There, There
07 Scatterbrain
08 The Gloaming
09 Myxomatosis
10 Paperbag Writer
11 Gagging Order
12 Where Bluebirds Fly
13 A Wolf at the Door

Playlist on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/user/gloriousprofessor/playlist/1Y4ZxaSbRx00ca1gdP17ya

Let me know what y'all think.

>>72347743
Where Bluebirds Fly fucking sucks t b h

>>72347335
You Are Invited is great

>>72347700
also La La Love

>>72348084
Nah, it's good

>>72348084
>Where Bluebirds Fly sucks
You're a p l e b