How do Fagtano/Scaruffi/Christgau rate your favorite album?

fagtano - n/a
scaruffi - 8.5/10
christgau - n/a

>>72273485
What album?

>Favorite Album
Boris - Flood
>Melon
N/A
>Scaruffi
6/10
>Christgau
N/A

Fuck.

Scaruffi - 8/10
Other two fags haven't rated it

n/a
n/a
n/a

Fantano - None
Christgau - C+
Scaruffi - 4/10

Album: Diamond Dogs

Scaruffi- 7.5/10
Theneedledrop- 8/10
Christgau- B-

>>72273530
>>72273616
>>72273485
>tfw scaruffi is the only one who cares enough to review somewhat obscure albums and he rated mine badly without an explanation

>>72273430
See >>72273661

Scaruffi: 9/10
Fantano: Classic/10
Christgau: C+

>Favorite album
Down Colorful Hill
>Fantano
N/A
>Scaruffi
9/10
>Christgau
N/A

>>72273682
>He also loves Diamond Dogs

Marry me.

melancholia
fantano - n/a
scaruffi - 6/10
christgau - n/a

>>72273735
I am planing to become a wizard. Sorry, senpai.

>>72273710
>Christgau gave Spiderland a C+
why does anyone on this board give him any respect at all?

>>72273772
Marry me wizard dog.

>>72273710
Spiderland?

They haven't reviewed it.
myke c-town did and he liked it

>>72273789
>>72273812
yes and Christgau is a fucking Dud

fantano - n/a
scaruffi - 7/10
christgau - 4/10

>>72273850
>christgau
>numerical rating
what album? I thought he does a letter score

>>72273430
The Beach Boys - Smile
fagtano - N/A
scaruffi - 7/10
christgay - N/A

>>72273869
The Avalanches - Since I Left You
>using bits and pieces of dumb crap, which is ecological, to make smart crap, which is less so ("Frontier Psychiatrist," "Close to You") **

more specifically, he gave it 2/5 stars

>>72273530
This guy is the only one who talks about this album in every thread
Is it really that good?

>>72273430
fantano: 7/10
Scaruffi: N/A
Christgau: N/A

Wowee Zowee

Fantano - n/a
Christgau - A
Scruff - 5/10

Fantano - Classic/10
Christgau - A-
Piero "Why are there age limits?" Scaruffi - 9/10

File: thepod.jpg (2MB, 1500x1500px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1500x1500px

Fandango: N/A
Scruffy: 7/10
Christgau: *bomb*

>>72275592
Loveless?

blink-182 is Scaruffi approved

cucktano - N/A
scaruffi - 7.5/10
christgay - N/A

File: Cy824FNUUAAtOFR.jpg (58KB, 675x1200px) Image search: [Google]

58KB, 675x1200px

Wall of Voodoo - Call of the West.

>Christgau
B
>Scaruffi
7/10
>Dankony Memetano
N/A

I guess that's not too bad.

>>72273923
This makes me mad