RADIOHEAD: WORST TO BEST

thank you my good friend : )

t. lemonhead fan

>#9- The King of Limbs
dropped

>>72241896
haha whoops meant melon head !!!

>>72241907
he really is the ultimate pleb

>AMSP over TB, TKoL, HttF and Amnesiac
LOL FUCK OFF. AMSP IS A FUCKING BORING UNINSPIRED SNOOZEFEST. DUMB LEMON PIECE OF SHIT.

>TKOL
>worst

this is how to spot a pleb, TKOL is heaps underrated

>>72241879
>TKOL worse than PH
more like the The King of Plebs

>>72242001
AND WHAT THE FUCK JUST GOT TO HIM PUTTING AMNESIAC AT THIRD WORST

WHAT THE FUCK

>>72241994
AMSP is great, apologize to thm and his new girlfriend.

>>72241907
>>72242001
>>72242027
Lmaoing at ur life

>>72242027
I listened to the TKOL the other day for the first time in like 2 years. It's not their best work by any means, but I was surprised by how many songs I really enjoyed.

>>72242036
Amnesiac is really really overrated by this board

>Amnesiac at #7

Melon is a tool

>>72242097
It's my 3rd least favorite. But Pablo Honey is their only meh album. Not bad but just equal to or above average.

>"..or on the song Burn The Witch, where the band is really kind of taking a direct shot at the modern state of sociopolitical discourse"
nigga the song was written 17 years ago

>>72242160
at least he mentions their live album as being better. that live studio album performance of bloom is great

>>72241879
What a fucking plebe

>>72241907
>>72242001
>>72242027
I'm more concerned about him hating on Amnesiac

File: wG6NdeT.gif (2MB, 450x253px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 450x253px

>TKOL behind PH
>Amnesiac at #7

>>72242179
[citation needed]

File: lmaofantano.png (2MB, 1366x768px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1366x768px

What did he mean by this?

oh my god I didn't know he was such a pleb when it came to Radiohead
Their most overrated at number 1?
Their two most underrated at 9 and 7?

fuck this pleb

>WHAT? THIS GUY HAS A DIFFERENT OPINION THAN ME? FUCK THAT GUY, P-PLEB!: the thread

>all these amnesiac plebs getting triggered for their shitty b-sides getting called out
WEW

>>72242234
It's been in and out of their live set since 2000 I believe

Ive never hated fantano more hearing him shit on kol and amnesiac

Melon is such a pleb

File: 1491748693107.png (445KB, 609x633px) Image search: [Google]

445KB, 609x633px

>>72242234
>Radiohead developed the song for over a decade, first working on it during the sessions for their fourth album, Kid A (2000)

The King of Limbs is one of their best what the fuck is wrong with this guy

Honestly one of his best videos just for the reactions here.

I wonder if Anthony does these worst to best videos just to trigger everyone.

>KID A
>number 1

Okay, time to boycott this melonhead.

>>72242272
Not a citation. Try again.
>>72242287
Incorrect. it was a HTTT outtake

Everyone's complaining about The King of Limbs and Amnesiac being so low but nobody's mentioning
>In Rainbows is better than Kid A

>calls radiohead 'not very experimental'
>favorite songs are the popular singles
>okay

mu avant-teens found and memed TKOL last year ;)) now they're triggered as fuck ;) based fantano

>>72242313
Stop spreading lies.

>>72242336
Kid A has too much filler despite it being just 10 tracks. It's brilliant but not the most consistent.

>>72242336
That's a correct statement though.
IR is their best

OK Computer is their greatest album fuckbois

>>72242345
You stop spreading lies.

>>72242352
>Kid A has too much filler
like what?

>>72242375
Treefingers (fuck you, it's filler), Morning Bell, In Limbo.

>>72242390
Morning Bell and In Limbo are the best tracks on the album tho

>>72242390
How is this filler?

PROTIP: "I Don't like it!" =/= filler

>>72242354
that's not a good album, just a bunch of good songs

File: InvestigateAntartica.png (51KB, 526x133px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 526x133px

>>72242317
>Not a citation. Try again.
sorry you can't google. the songs been around since kid a.

File: thom.png (257KB, 451x533px) Image search: [Google]

257KB, 451x533px

>>72241879
He was so ugly for so long. Luckily he's aged well.

Correct ranking

Kid A > Amnesiac > The King of Limbs > HTTT > OK Computer > A Moon Shaped Pool > In Rainbows > The Bends > Pablo Honey

>>72242390
Morning Bell and In Limbo are among the best on that album. Treefingers is a sweet little ambient interlude, not filler.

>>72242445
Treefingers is the same droning noise for almost 4 minutes.
Morning Bell was done better on Amnesiac, the album that's B-Sides to Kid A. It doesn't really go anywhere. (also Thom's voice is fucking awful on it but that's just a personal peeve of mine)
In Limbo has the same problem as Morning Bell, it's just redundant and boring. Other than the 'come back' part it's really repetitive.

>>72242451
What?
It's one of their best flowing albums.
Videotape is easily one of if not their best closer.
And the same with 4MW on D2.

You'll eventually see the light, /mu/.
KA is overrated wank.
IR is GOAT

>>72242460
Thom stopped being ugly around the HTTT era

File: Thom Sept 28 2005.png (10KB, 768x334px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 768x334px

>>72242455
>no citations
Try again.

i dont want to watch the video wheres the list

>>72242481
>Treefingers is the same droning noise for almost 4 minutes.
not an argument

>>72242481
>Treefingers is the same droning noise for almost 4 minutes.
=/= filler
>Morning Bell was done better on Amnesiac,
=/= filler
>it's just redundant and boring.
=/= filler

Try again

File: 1479424367358.png (172KB, 414x302px) Image search: [Google]

172KB, 414x302px

>the bends that low
fuck off

>>72242512
>ask me to explain myself
>I do
>lol you're wrong
ok anon

>kid a doesn't have the best flow
Either then that decent opinion although I love TKOL although I see why he hates it

>>72242491
even what you posted shows he's had the lyrics since 05 at least.

>>72242390
In Limbo is the best song on the album though.

>>72242521
just because you don't like a track, doesn't mean it's filer you retard.

File: 2006-03-08_Tour.jpg (43KB, 937x600px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 937x600px

>>72242525
That's not 17 years ago, is it
>>72242521
So you just don't know what filler is

>>72242505
Tkol
Pablo
Amnesiac
The bends
HTTT
AMSP
Kid a
IR
OKC

>>72242481
>He likes the Amnesiac version of Morning Bell more than the Kid A version
AHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAAHAHAHHAHAH

>>72242390
Treefingers is a great ambient track, and an interlude shouldn't be considered "filler" when it helps the flow of an album.

>>72242521
>lol you're wrong
that anon did not say that at all. Nice reading comprehension, buddy. Although, you're probably just straw manning because you have nothing to say.

1. kid a
2. amnesiac
3. httt
4. okc
5. amsp
6. bends
7. ir
8. pablo

>>72242552
>That's not 17 years ago, is it
it's mentioned on the cover to httt which was released in 2003, so at least 14 years ago. i said i believed it's been around since 2000.

>>72242656
>yes hello, I'm your average /mu/tant who can't think for himself

>>72242656
you forgot to put TKOL at 4 other than that perfect

>>72242704
pablo and ir suck
get over yourself

>>72242701
>it's mentioned on the cover to httt
Which is why is aid it was a HTTT outtake at the earliest
>i said i believed it's been around since 2000.
Which is wrong. Do you also believe in Santa Clause and The Tooth fairy?

>>72242656
>httt that high
have you even listened to it amigo

>>72242568
I like it solely more because of the fact that Thom doesn't sound like he's plugging his nose the whole time

>>72242720
>oh no better hate the popular albums or I'll lose muh cred
>if I just copy every critics list and switch up /mu/ favorites I'll get all the (you)s

>>72242473
lol

>>72242751
>>oh no better hate the popular albums or I'll lose muh cred
>kid a is quite literally #1
what did anonymous mean by this
>>72242741
have you? it drags a bit in the middle but aside from that it's absolutely up there

>>72242751
>Pablo honey is the popular album
Now you are just trying too hard

>>72242656
Kid A
OK Computer
The King of Limbs
In Rainbows
Amnesiac
A Moon Shaped Pool
Hail to the Thief
The Bends
Pablo Honey

>>72242794
>>72242797
I meant IR and the bends

>>72242730
>Which is why is aid it was a HTTT outtake at the earliest
you didn't. you just said it was a httt outtake. they've been trying to put true love waits on an album since okc.

>>72242848
>>Which is why i said it was a HTTT outtake
>you didn't. you just said it was a httt outtake
?

>>72242873
>at the earliest
key phrase. like i said. more than half the tracks of AMSP have been around for awhile. several, such as true love waits, were supposed to be on multiple albums.

>>72242730
How's the autism going anon?

If you took out We Suck Young Blood and Backdrifts and replaced both with Paperbag Writer, HTTT would be like #4

>>72242961
>key phrase
Not really. I stated where it came from and a source.

You cannot. Let me know when you do.
>>72242973
What do you mean?

>>72243010
Why would you have Paperbag Writer twice?

Also, no it's awful.

>>72243032
take both tracks out and put it somewhere
any of the b-sides on com lag are better than those tracks

>>72243071
OK so boring/uninteresting/non-band-oriented/breaking flow = better?

>>72243012
you said it, at the earliest came from around httt. if the album cover has btw on it, that means the latest it was worked on was 2003. not the earliest. it can't find a specific source that i trust to post that says it was worked on in 2000. but it was worked on at least from 2003

don't panic everyone. I have the correct rankings right here:

OK Computer > Kid A = In Rainbows > A Moon Shaped Pool > Amnesiac > The Bends > Hail to the Thief > The King of Limbs > Pablo Honey

>>72243098
yeah exactly

>>72243135
>not the earliest.
Yes the earliest because there is NO evidence it predates HTTT
>can't find a specific source
Have fun fucking off then

File: ok.kid.jpg (9KB, 220x229px) Image search: [Google]

9KB, 220x229px

>>72242473
>muh kid a b-sides

>>72243162
>Yes the earliest because there is NO evidence it predates HTTT
it means that it had to have been worked since at least httt. which means it could have been made beforehand. it could not have been started after the httt. so the latest it was made was during httt

>>72243305
>it means that it had to have been worked since at least httt.
Which is why I said it was a HTTT outtake, at the earliest
>which means it could have been made beforehand
No evidence of it, so this notion must be discarded

>>72243349
nice name

>>72243359
Sorry forget to take it off from the other thread

>>72243398
decent taste though

File: answerisno.jpg (10KB, 224x300px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 224x300px

>>72243349
you're a fuckin idiot. the whole point of the start of this argument is that plebtano's criticism is retarded -- he's wrong about burn the witch.

And burn the witch has been in the works since the KID A sessions. Just because you're a fucking autistic faggot doesn't mean it's not.

Go hang yourself. Two THUMBS DOWN

>>72243349
the evidence is several mediocre articles and the wikipedia page saying that it was made before that. it's just not concrete evidence so i'm not gonna swear by it. then again, the album cover isn't concrete evidence.
>No evidence of it, so this notion must be discarded
why should it be? the band toured with nude and true love waits for years before they even thought about putting them on albums. it's reasonable to assume that it could have been worked on during kid a.

File: 1483897626820s.jpg (10KB, 250x250px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 250x250px

Melon boy isn't too far off, but here is the objective list

Best to worst

1) Ok Kid
2) In Radiohead
3) You're fucking dead Kiddo' A
4) JUST (1995)
5) A Meme Shaped Spoon
6) Hail To The Fuhrer
7) Loop Pedal Wank Fest (2011)
8) B Sides: The Album (except Knives Out and Pyramid Song)
9) The Life of Pablo

>>72243489
>And burn the witch has been in the works since the KID A sessions
Prove it.

You won't be able to, because it wasn't true

>wahh I misspoke so you should hang yourself
Wow calm down and just admit you made a mistake
>>72243509
>>72243509
>the evidence is several mediocre articles and the wikipedia page saying that it was made before that.
No citations there either. Read the articles it's "quoting"
>why should it be?
Well why would believe random thigns with no factual basis? Let's just say the song is a Pablo honey outtake. We don't need evidence of it, right! Yeah!
>the band toured with nude and true love waits for years before they even thought about putting them on albums
And that would be evidence that those songs were written for OKC. Very good. You might be learning.

But again, that does not exist for BTW. It seems to have been begun during the HTTT sessions, but completed/refined for IR.
>it's reasonable to assume that it could have been worked on during kid a.
Yes both Big Ideas and True Love Waits were recorded during Kid A

>>72243569
Good list. Thommy Yorke and the Radio boys really make some good music

File: rage1.jpg (5KB, 250x250px) Image search: [Google]

5KB, 250x250px

>>72243593
Jesus christ you're not worth the oxygen you are inhaling.

THE POINT IS PANTANO IS WRONG ABOUT THE SIGNIFICANCE OF BTW.

AND SINCE YOU'RE SUCH A FUCKING MORON HERE'S YOUR KID A PROOF FROM NIGEL. PLEASE NECK YOURSELF IMMEDIATELY.

https://twitter.com/simonwilliam/status/726472148739592192

>>72243593
holy shit you are actually autistic. the point was that you said that the earliest it was made was httt. i told you why the latest it was made was httt. the earliest evidence, that you won't sperg about, is the album cover. if the album cover is from at least june 2003, the song has to be from at least before june 2003. i don't know if it was from kid a. the articles and wikipedia page suggest it enough that if i had to bet i'd say it was. but it was at least made before httt came out. so it is either equal to or older than httt

>>72243740
>if the album cover is from at least june 2003, the song has to be from at least before june 2003. i don't know if it was from kid a.
Well, since Kid A was released in 2000 not 2003...
>the articles and wikipedia page suggest
Right, because that is so accurate.
>but it was at least made before httt came out
I don't think you understand how musicians create music. Do you think it spontaneously comes to life upon the specific release date of the album? or maybe they were written in advance

>>72243795
KILL YOURSELF AUTISTIC MORON.

>>72243693

>>72243807
Link isn't working for me. Try again.

But please calm down first.

>>72242267
t. fantano

File: pepe9thcircleofhell.png (59KB, 525x488px) Image search: [Google]

59KB, 525x488px

>>72243832
THIS IS WHAT AN AUTISTIC WASTE OF MATTER LOOKS LIKE. YOU WILL BE FIRST AGAINST THE WALL.

>>72243863
Hmm, lack of empathy is a sign of autism. Are you projecting?

>>72243795
first off, here's your evidence you sperg
>https://twitter.com/simonwilliam/status/726472148739592192
>Well, since Kid A was released in 2000 not 2003...
that's not what that sentence meant. if the song is at least as old as the album, it could be older. which means saying that the earliest it could have been made was httt is incorrect.
>I don't think you understand how musicians create music. Do you think it spontaneously comes to life upon the specific release date of the album? or maybe they were written in advance
the line you didn't quote was the important one
>so it is either equal to or older than httt
so, again, saying that the earliest it could have been made was httt is incorrect.

File: pepe silvia.jpg (30KB, 500x371px) Image search: [Google]

30KB, 500x371px

>>72243891
>SPENDS WHOLE THREAD AUTISTICALLY DICTATING THE TRUTH
>GETS DISPROVED
>CAN'T OWN UP TO BEING WRONG

N E C K Y O U R S E L F

>>72243569
v good list

>>72243934
stop spergin out everyone on this thread thinks it's gay and annoying

>>72242390
Treefingers and In Limbo are perfect, but I understand how someone would not think so. But, Morning Bell? Complete blasphemy.

File: syphilis.jpg (51KB, 320x240px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 320x240px

>>72243960

K I L L Y O U R S E L F

>>72243934
>>GETS DISPROVED
[citation needed]
>>72243925
>https://twitter.com/simonwilliam/status/726472148739592192
See >>72243832
>it could be older
It could be anything. Doesn't make it true, does it?
>which means saying that the earliest it could have been made was httt is incorrect.
It is correct, since that's the earliest evidence we have of it existing at all
>the line you didn't quote was the important one
You mean the incorrect assumption one? No I ignored it because it was simply untrue

File: pepeitendsnow.gif (28KB, 206x200px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 206x200px

>>72244026
K I L L Y O U R S E L F

>>72243995
(You)

>>72244065
More lack of empathy at someone with a different view as theirs. Interesting. I gotta take you to Vegas

OK Computer (10/10)
Kid A (10/10)
In Rainbows (9/10)
The Bends (9/10)
Hail To The Thief (8.5/10)
The King of Limbs (8.25/10)
Amnesiac (8.25/10)
Pablo Honey (8/10)
A Moon Shaped Pool (6.9/10)

>>72244065
>>72243995
>>72243934
>>72243863
>>72243693
reddit please go back to r/radiohead this is an 18+ forum

File: ScreenShotForTheAutisticRedditBro.png (274KB, 701x515px) Image search: [Google]

274KB, 701x515px

>>72244026
here's your fucking screen shot. search has profile on twitter if you don't trust it. this is what happens when you feed babies out of plastic bottles i swear.

>>72244103
>AMSP
>6.9
Fucking shit taste m8, do the world a favor and kys

>>72244121
>maybe
>[Laughs]
He doesn't remember.

Try again.

>amnesiac 7th

lol ctrl + w

File: 10bux.jpg (82KB, 641x733px) Image search: [Google]

82KB, 641x733px

>>72244114
I'VE BEEN ON 4CHAN LONGER THAN YOU'VE BEEN ALIVE YOU UNDERAGE MONGOLOID BALL FONDLING TWEEN.

>>72244098
K I L L Y O U R S E L F

>>72243147
>kid a = in rainbows

no thanks fuck off dumbass thats not how you rank thingws u fucking idioi

File: ronaldstrangle.jpg (34KB, 467x405px) Image search: [Google]

34KB, 467x405px

>>72244157
K I L L Y O U R S E L F

>>72242336
IR is better than kid gay though

Amnesiac being that low is a crime though even scaruffi considers it their best

>>72244157
damn. can't believe i got b8'd this hard. in case you are serious i want you to post a screen shot of your score.
https://psychcentral.com/quizzes/autism-quiz.htm

also, the fact that he believes it was made near the end of kid a proves that it is older than httt.

File: IMG_2638.jpg (150KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

150KB, 500x500px

HTTT is the best hip hop album of the 2000s

File: 1474143747878.gif (167KB, 480x270px) Image search: [Google]

167KB, 480x270px

>>72241879
Every time melon looks into the camera I immediately look away, does anyone else do this? Only just noticed it.

>>72244252
>proves
Not really, He seems very uncertain, he doesn't quote know. He even laughs.

That's assuming this random guy on twitter isn't just making random shit up btw. This is not a primary source.

>>72244153
Give me any track from A Moon Shaped Pool and I'll tell you what went wrong (especially Desert Island Disk and The Numbers, which are Radiohead's worst songs ever released).

>>72244287
https://psychcentral.com/quizzes/autism-quiz.htm

>>72244300
Present Tense

I'll never take him seriously again lol.
Tkol and Amnesiac at the bottom. HTTT not at the bottom. what a joker

>>72244318
>https://psychcentral.com/quizzes/autism-quiz.htm
I'll do it if you do it too

>>72241879
Kid A = OK Computer > In Rainbows = A Moon Shaped Pool > Amnesiac > Hail To The Thief > The King of Limbs = The Bends > Pablo Honey

only less than enjoyable album is Pablo Honey imo
TKOL (while being near the end) has great songs
>like bloom, lotus flower, codex, little by little, magpie
as well as the bends
>fake plastic trees, just, my iron lung, bullet proof, black star, street spirit
and HTTT has some of my favourite RH songs
>2+2=5, there there, where i end and you begin, myxomatosis, scatterbrain
so i can understand people who have those albums higher up, but when it comes down to it thats my ranking of RH albums

Times like this I wish I was famous. If I was rich and had a large celebrity following I could post the true ranking and people would listen. Instead people listen to melonhead and my correct opinions go unappreciated.

File: Sage~.jpg (318KB, 760x630px) Image search: [Google]

318KB, 760x630px

>>72244365
into the trash it goes.

Amnesiac > Kid A > OKC > IR > HTTT > AMSP > Bends > TKOL > Pablo Honey

>>72242704
how the fuck is that a /mu/core list? you are speaking out of your ass

>>72241879
Pablo Honey - 4/10
The Bends - 6/10
OK Computer - 8/10
Kid A - 8/10
Amnesiac - 7/10
HTTT - 6.5/10
In Rainbows - 7.5/10
The King of Limbs - 6/10
A Moon Shaped Pool - 7.5/10

>>72242234
they literally released the lyrics on their website near the release of Hail to the thief

File: assigned dale.png (2MB, 1280x1717px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1280x1717px

>>72244459
>OK Computer - 8/10
>Kid A - 8/10
confirmed for top tier moron

OK Computer
A Moon Shaped Pool
Kid A
In Rainbows
The Bends
Amnesiac
Hail to the Thief
The King of Limbs
Pablo Honey

Bonus: Best songs
Nude
How to Disappear Completely
Let Down
Daydreaming

Kid A > OKC > The Bends > TKOL > AMSP > In Rainbows > Amnesiac > Pablo Honey > Hail to the Thief

>>72244468
>near the release of Hail to the thief
Which would mean it's a HTTT era track, as I had originally said

Why is this so hard for you to grasp?

hey u guys well the coreckt ranking is

in rainboys
kid a
okc
moon
hail the theif
amnesiac
king of lims
the bends
pablo huney

File: AutismQuickQuiz2017.png (63KB, 686x452px) Image search: [Google]

63KB, 686x452px

>>72244360

Radiohead is a mediocre band

File: Screenshot 2017-04-17 15.16.00.png (205KB, 965x447px) Image search: [Google]

205KB, 965x447px

>>72244527
Looks like you can drop the "What an autist!" defense, huh?

Now you'll have to rely on an actual argument.

>>72244485
are you implying that they deserve higher or lower

>>72242460
he's still not hot though.. like who here would fuck thom based off of his attractiveness . idk i certainly wouldnt unless i was very sexually deprived or something.

>>72244555
gotcha retard

File: Screenshot_9.png (49KB, 861x493px) Image search: [Google]

49KB, 861x493px

>>72244527
>>72244555


?

No Surprises is honestly the prettiest song i ever heard. In the final little bit where he goes AND SUUUUUCH A PRETTY HOUSE I get choked up a little. I could seriously just sit there all day and listen to that song and not get tired of it.

>>72241907

Limb of Kings is bad

>>72244583
get fucked,

so who here can top my score??

>>72244496
>tfw to intelligent to grasp what the anon is trying to convince

File: gg.png (9KB, 510x102px) Image search: [Google]

9KB, 510x102px

>>72244583
Nice

>>72244627
PROTIP: evidence would be a good thing if you want to convince someone of something

File: autismpossible.png (8KB, 165x50px) Image search: [Google]

8KB, 165x50px

>>72244583

File: Screen Shot 2017-04-17 at 4.31.27 PM.png (65KB, 872x403px) Image search: [Google]

65KB, 872x403px

t. an actual sperg

File: IMG_2702.png (663KB, 2048x1536px) Image search: [Google]

663KB, 2048x1536px

HTTT is the best hip hop album of the 2000s

File: 4557591.jpg (69KB, 520x678px) Image search: [Google]

69KB, 520x678px

>>72244650
>>72244670
haha its just a little online quiz right doesnt mean anything right

We're all in agreement that We Suck Young Blood is the WORST Radiohead track, right?

>>72245125
>Treefingers
>half of Amnesiac
>Hail To The Thief b-sides
>most of Pablo Honey

File: Psychcentral Autism Screening Test.png (57KB, 855x580px) Image search: [Google]

57KB, 855x580px

>>72241879
Took the test and I'm pretty sure its insatiably inaccurate, I'm certainly not autistic by any stretch of the imagination, I merely prefer living in my own world and self-imposed isolation. Anyhow seeing how people are ranking these, let's go (worst to best);

9. Pablo Honey - This album is fairly overlooked by the fanbase and for good reason, the songs are a terrible fusion of being overly consumerist whilst simultaneously being flambéd by poor production, and whilst some may appreciate the raw style this album encapsulates, it doesn't do it anywhere near as well as bands like Built to Spill or the Pixies.

8. The King of Limbs - The Live From the Basement recordings are significantly superior than this album and the concept of recording all the individual instruments then welding them together only created an overly minimalist void that I'm sure will be invidious if unmemorable at best. The album still has the occasional atmospheric splendor though, I'm pretty confident that its recent praise is entirely due to contrarianism rather than a better appreciation of the content.

7. Hail to the Thief - Has one of the greatest Radiohead openers though doesn't really get going until There, There, and even then a lot of the album suffers from being far too corny and giving the insufferably "we're going to save the world with rock 'n' roll music!" vibe that prevents me from taking it seriously. That being said Scatterbrain is by far the most underrated Radiohead song.

6. A Moon Shaped Pool - Great album, can feel rather etiolated through what I consider some degree of over-production in an attempt to purposefully restrict itself from having any major 10/10 moments in favour of keeping consistency, that being said Decks Dark and Identikit are both zesty zools for all to relish.

5. The Bends - This is underrated by the fanbase because it is accessible and likely the only album you can show to a casual listener with a straight face.

>>72242390
i get it but In Limbo? really? that track is top 3 on the album

>>72245614
4. OK Computer - No, I'm not being a contrarian, the first half of the album contains the band's best material to date though is thoroughly let down by the harangue of meager ditties (with the exception of Climbing up the Walls), still a great album though.

3. In Rainbows - Arguably their most consistent album in that it actually has good songs all the way through though none that really captivate the listener, I honestly find it quite amusing that people cry tears at songs like Nude and Reckoner, they're good but its not like listening to Two Headed Boy Part Two or The Eternal whilst consuming malt whisky at one's dimly lit desk. Jigsaw Falling Into Place and Bodysnatchers are the main jams here (the latter is underrated because it is more noisy and accessible which is clearly a red flag to the average Radiohead fan).

2. Amnesiac - No, I'm not being contrarian, don't be a faggot if you think that, Amnesiac is one of Radiohead's most consistent efforts and I like the bits where there are loads of flying samples and back-rhythms, like on Packt Tighter than a Tin Can, with the unique drumming effects. Life in the Glasshouse is probably one of Radiohead's best song.

1. Kid A - The lead from Optimistic into In Limbo into Idioteque is a streak that I can get behind, and one that should be celebrated worldwide. The other songs are good too (except National Anthem, that song sucks), the title track which people pretend not to like because it is the title track is also the bees knees.

>>72245614

this is fantastic

>>72245614
>>72245755
irl kek'd

hits the nail on the head with amnesiac
i don't get how anyone could think its better than kid a, peaks at pyramid song and life in a glasshouse lyrics sound like they belong on ok computer

>>72245614
>>72245755
lmfao

>>72242340
What did he mean by this?

>>72247891
? he clearly meant that melons fave songs are the popular ones & not the experimental ones you fucking dumbass faggot.

1. Kid A
2. OK Computer
3. Pablo Honey
4. The Bends

everything else sucks

File: ok pleb.png (389KB, 431x450px) Image search: [Google]

389KB, 431x450px

>>72243569
>"8) B Sides: The Album (except Knives Out and Pyramid Song)"
>implying I Might Be Wrong, Life in a Glasshouse and You and Whose Army? are b-side tier
Your opinions are FUCKING SHIT, mate.

>>72248162
>>implying I Might Be Wrong, Life in a Glasshouse and You and Whose Army? are b-side tier
The aren't, but they are certainly Cutting Room Floor Tier

File: ok kid.png (907KB, 900x900px) Image search: [Google]

907KB, 900x900px

>>72248183
I Might Be Wrong is one of the best songs they've ever made.

I'd switch In Rainbows with Ok Computer

>>72248206
I guess if you like soulless, aimless faux electro

File: thom-yorke-2010_article_story_main.jpg (27KB, 326x217px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 326x217px

>>72248224
>one of the most rocking songs on the album
>is driven by a bluesy guitar riff
>"faux electro"
Lmao, you don't know what you're talking about.

>>72241879
>TKoL worse than Pablo Honey
dropped

>>72248259
>one of the most rocking songs on the soulless, aimless faux electro album
Wow
>is driven by a bluesy guitar riff
Wow what am amazing riff Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
>Lmao, you don't know what you're talking about.
Remember that "I like it the best means it is the best!" is not a valid argument.

>>72248311
Remember that "Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz" and "faux electro" aren't valid arguments.

>>72248345
Why not? They describe the music perfectly.

>>72243569
>In Radiohead
>Hail To The Fuhrer

AMNESIAC FANS B T F O

>>72242512
The first and third things you listed are objectively filler. Second isn't though.

>>72242720
In Rainbows is the best thing they've ever done. Better than OKC

>>72248782

Kys pleb, without the hype Radiohead's In Rainbows (Radiohead, 2007) would simply be a mediocre attempt at making slightly adventurous classic rock music. Abandoning their pretenses of innovation and futurism, Radiohead returned to their rock roots with a guitar-driven album that features precious few electronic/digital effects. This is U2-style arena-rock for the 2000s. The syncopated blues-soul shuffle 15 Step the half-baked hard-rock of Bodysnatchers (reminiscent of pathetic attempts by the Beatles to reinvent themselves in the age of Cream) or Faust Arp, a Beatles-esque elegy that has been heard countless times in the history of pop music, are not only inferior material by any standard: they are plain amateurish. To make matters worse, the album includes a whole set of sub-pop ballads, from the slow Nude (a long unreleased song, originally titled Big Ideas) to the even more moronic All I Need and House of Cards.
Redeeming the album from utter mediocrity are Jigsaw Falling Into Place, by far the best song, the kind of feverish dance-rock that Inxs specialized in, Weird Fishes/Arpeggi, a tender song a` la Coldplay that gradually builds emotioinal momentum, Reckoner, a languid soul lament over a hypnotic polyrhythm and a Moody Blues-esque string section, and finally the piano-driven Videotape, the melodic peak of the album and the one ballad that has something original to say. But it's way too little.
Any critic who hails this album as a masterpiece must be missing 99% of the music released in the same month.

>>72245755
>except National Anthem, that song sucks
p l e b b e r y

>>72248752
>objectively filler
How so? They literally had like 30 finished songs for the album, they didn't need filler.

>>72248381
No they don't. I Might Be Wrong isn't an electro song, you retard.

>>72249693
It doesn't have electronic elements?

Perhaps you are listening to the wrong song

>>72249174
Having 30 songs finished for it doesn't mean anything. Some random chords played for 3 minutes isn't musically interesting in any way and adds nothing to the album.
Pretty much if you can't see anyone saying "________ is my favorite track from the album" it's filler. So this includes (most) interludes or things that aren't intended to be actual full length songs.
Fitter Happier is another example of this. It's pretty much a skit, and skits are filler.

>>72249711
Not him but the drums are clearly electronic. I don't agree that it's electro though.

>amnesiac that low
>overrated

d
r
o
p
p
e
d

>>72249883
>Having 30 songs finished for it doesn't mean anything
For having filler or not, of course it does. Are you daft?
>Some random chords played for 3 minutes isn't musically interesting
Not what filler is
>and adds nothing to the album.
And intermission isn't nothing, is it?
>>72249883
>"________ is my favorite track from the album"
People have said every Radioheda is their favorite. hence they have no filler then, huh?
>it's filler.
That's not what filler is. You can't just make up definitions of words, that's not how it works
>Fitter Happier is another example of this
Of an intermission that works for the album? yes. Not filler though. They had like 20 songs finished for OKC.

>>72248932
fuck off scaruffi drone
also trout mask replica is shit

>>72249983
>For having filler or not, of course it does. Are you daft?
okay, hypothetical situation:
Band writes 30 songs
5 are good songs
they still put the best 12 on the album.
the album has 7 filler tracks.

>Not what filler is
Filler is anything that adds nothing of value to an album. If it's musically uninteresting, it adds nothing of value and the album would be better if it was removed.

>>72243010
FUCK OFF
i'm downright triggerred, backdrifts is one of the best tracks of the album
>that break in the middle of the song
>AH AH AAAAHH YOU FELL INTO OUR TRAAAAAP
best moment of the album

>>72250123
>5 are good songs
Not relevant
>Filler is anything that adds nothing of value to an album.
Still wrong.

Why are you using words you don't understand?

>>72250166
>still wrong
ok tell me what you think filler is and I'll tell you why you're wrong and point you to the correct definition I posted.

>>72250234
>ok tell me what you think filler
What i think is not relevant.

What filler actually is, is material hastily composed/recorded by an artist to "fill" out an album, often because they didn't have enough material.
>tell you why you're wrong and point you to the correct definition I posted.
Be sure to use a citation, otherwise it's not valid

>>72242267
Fuck outta here Fantano