top10 albums of all time as per rym.

>>71981755
3, 6, and 7 are the only ones that would deserve to be in top 50 rock albums

>any Beatles belonging in a top 10
d r o p p e d

>>71981755
>all rock albums
>mostly dudes
Sounds gay

>>71981755
OK Computer as #1 needs to stop

>>71981786
More like top 100.

Rym is hardly better than Reddit.

>no marvin gaye

>no beach boys

pleb top 10

maybe the definitive /mu/ top 10, christ /mu/ has shit taste

>>71981755

Reddit/9gag: The Taste.

>>71981840
when you make these posts, do you do it with the intention of getting people to respond to you in anger or just because you think it's funny?

>>71981814
True, well the ones I mentioned I think should be in the top 50 but I don't see the any of the other seven making top 200. Top 500 (rock) should probably include all of them except Revolver though.

>>71981755
anyone who disputes this is a contrarian faggot

>>71981755
britishbritishbritishbritishbritishmericanbritishbritishbritishbritishbritishbritishbritishbritishbritishbritishbritishbritishbritishbritishbritishbritishbritishbritishbritishbritishbritishbritishmericanbritishbritishbritish

i listened to led zeppelin iv for the first time.

i don't understand the appeal.

>no dylan in top 10

>>71981951
it's fun

>led zeppelin IV in the top 10

And out goes all their credibility.

While believable, it is a very nondiverse lineup for a "most influential" collage. You would think at least Miles Davis would have made the cut.

>>71981971
o ok

>>71981875
marvin gaye is top 10

beach boys pet sounds is the greatest album ever

mu will debate this forever

>>71981755
ok computer isn't even top 50
DSOTM is breddy good but defs not #1 or 2
VU&N is gutter trash
WYWH should be higher than DSOTM
Kid A isn't even fucking rock music, it's also complete fucking garbage
6-9 are all breddy good though none are top 10 material
LZIV is probably top 5 material

>>71981786
Shut up Scaruffi

only acceptable one there is loveless

>>71981755
AMSP and Kid A > OK Computer

>>71983338
Hey dad, can I borrow your AC/DC CD for the road trip tomorrow?

>>71981786
t. Poseur

File: kys.jpg (2MB, 3725x2955px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 3725x2955px

>>71983435

>top 10 albums are all rock
when is the music review culture going to get over the rock meme?

File: file.png (270KB, 500x489px) Image search: [Google]

270KB, 500x489px

>>71983584

>>71982239
>beach boys pet sounds is the greatest album ever
lol

File: ok kid.png (421KB, 618x454px) Image search: [Google]

421KB, 618x454px

>>71981888
>except Revolver though.

Name 500 albums better than Revolver.

Go ahead, I'll wait.

>>71982087
Kind of Blue is literally #11. Boohoo it's not in the arbitrary "top 10" how could life ever go on.

>>71984164
desu this would take forever regardless of if there's a coherent list or not

>>71983472
>posting a timestamp on a bunch of ac/dc cds as if it's so unbelievable you thought you needed one
>calling someone else an autist

>>71983472
>I want to show everyone that I have an awful shitaste.

>>71984196
Name 100 albums better than Revolver.

This will hardly take long if you're not a newfag and you've actually listened to a decent amount of music.

I'm calling you on your bullshit. Prove me wrong.

i think Animals is better than either listed pink floyd album and sgt. peppers is better than either of those from the beatles

not sure about LZIV at all, it's not a consistent enough record and if you're going on influence there's a lot i'd put ahead of it

but anyway it's stupid because "greatest albums" and "most consistently high rated albums" will never be the same list

File: ahahahahaha.jpg (33KB, 358x361px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 358x361px

>>71984220
He even included a timestamp because he thought we wouldn't believe him!

>>71984227
Beatles are garbage, faggot.

Go back to plebbit

>>71984205
>>71984220
>>71984232
>I'm unironically triggered because someone has CDs of an artist I don't like

wew

>>71984240
Lol figures. No you fuck off to Reddit you dumb newfag. It's obvious you can't name 100 albums better than Revolver.

Hell you probably haven't even listened to 100 albums.

Let me guess, you just started browsing a year or two ago and all you listen to is /mu/core and p4kcore.

>>71983358
came here to post this

File: ahahahahahahahahahahahahah.jpg (165KB, 1200x800px) Image search: [Google]

165KB, 1200x800px

>>71984272
>he thinks we're the ones triggered
>he posted a bunch of ac/cd cds WITH a timestamp

>>71981951
Your dad told you it's great and the elderly are wise.

File: best modern albums.jpg (1MB, 1830x2896px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1830x2896px

>>71984358
>and the elderly are wise.

Actual Objective Top 10 Albums of All Time List:

>1. Led Zeppelin II - Led Zeppelin
>2. Sticky Fingers - The Rolling Stones
>3. Led Zeppelin IV - Led Zeppelin
>4. Magical Mystery Tour - The Beatles
>5. Wish You Were Here - Pink Floyd
>6. Abbey Road - The Beatles
>7. Dark Side of the Moon - Pink Floyd
>8. Electric Ladyland - The Jimi Hendrix Experience
>9. Definitely Maybe - Oasis
>10. The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars - David Bowie

>>71984384
nice pop/rock list mom

>>71984384
>look mom, I posted it again!

Unironically kill yourself.

>>71983472
i laughed in the way where i exhale through my nose slightly

>>71981755
1. Great
2. Very good
3. Good
4..Okay
5. Okay
6. Very good
7. Trash
8. Very good
9. Okay
10. Good

All of these are overated as fuck, especially for the position they are in on this list. 2/10

>>71984445
Back to /b/.

Actual Objective Top 10 Albums of All Time List:

1. Johann Sebastian Bach - Brandenburg Concertos
2. Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - Requiem
3. Ludwig Van Beethoven - Complete Symphonies
4. Miles Davis - Bitches Brew
5. John Coltrane - A Love Supreme
6. The Velvet Underground & Nico - The Velvet Underground & Nico
7. Dark Side of the Moon - Pink Floyd
8. Stevie Wonder - Innervisions
9. Underground Resistance - Interstellar Fugitives
10. Kanye West - MBDTF

>>71984467
>1. Johann Sebastian Bach - Brandenburg Concertos
sure
>2. Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - Requiem
lolno
>3. Ludwig Van Beethoven - Complete Symphonies
fair enough
>everything else
yeah, no

>>71981786
t. Faggot

>>71984467
>Kanye West - MBDTF
Nice b8 I give it 7/10

>>71984467
>Brandenburg
>not DKDF
Pleb

>>71984467
This is a dumb list but raises an interesting question: there are many classical pieces far greater than anything on that RYM list - do recordings of them count?

>>71981755
>OK Computer #1
>Kid A #5

If you needed any more proof that RYM's fanbase is comprised entirely of children.

>>71984582
If you count classical recordings, then not a single rock album (or even jazz) would make the top 2000.

>>71984611
*except Pet Sounds

>>71984582
Of course.

album -albəm/Submit - noun
>a collection of recordings issued as a single item on CD, record, or another medium.

>>71984623
Mom, stop.

>>71984623
Good point, forgot about that one.

File: can-stock-photo_csp0141748.jpg (18KB, 337x470px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 337x470px

>>71981755
>OK computer at number 1
>number ONE
i.e
>OK Computer is the best album ever made
>ever
>best album ever is soppy car radio britpop shite
>ever

>>71981867
Reddit taste is Frank Sinatra + Queen + Shiity Dubstep

>>71984623
>easy listening pop/rock
lmao

>>71981755
why the hell is there mucore on the list? and wheres itaots?

File: 1467648770793.jpg (11KB, 219x230px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 219x230px

>>71984611

>>71984657
It is true, I am a dog in reality.

>>71984582
Obviously they count, but stuff on RYM is rated by album/single and with classical music one single piece could spread out across different performers and albums, so it's obviously not going to get as many ratings as an album by a rock/jazz/hip hop etc musician. Ergo classical won't end up very high on the main chart.

>>71984644
honestly it's the same shit as /mu/ at this point

OK Computer is objectively the greatest rock album of all time
> stylistically diverse
> experimental and progressive
> mass appeal
> predicted the entire mood of the 21st century

>>71984670
some people like him take these reddit etc categories seriously kek what a sperg

>>71984654
Wait, do you think these albums are only known and popular here?

loooooool

Where the fuck is Pavement and Modest Mouse?

>>71984725
>edgy rock and rapist music

ewww

>>71981786
if you're going for top 50 rock albums you should probably add dsotm/wywh

Could be worse albums in there.

>>71984725
In the trash where they belong

>>71984227
Kind of Blue, Mingus Ah Um, TBS&TSL, 5 Mingus, A Hard Day's Night, Out to Lunch!, Judgment!, Dialogue, Miles Smiles, Sorcerer, Between the Buttons, Sgt Pepper, Smiley Smile, The Doors, Strange Days, Piper, Saucerful, Lumpy Gravy, The USA, An Electric Storm, Monster Movie, Phallus Dei, ITCOTCK, Five Leaves Left, Moondog, In a Silent Way, Bitches Brew, Third Ear Band, Lorca, Surf's Up, Tago Mago, Faust, Cluster 71, Led Zeppelin IV, Tubular Bells, Islands, Pink Moon, Ege Bamyasi, Faust So Far, Hosianna Mantra, Octopus, Cluster II, Future Days, Faust IV, Flying Teapot, Larks' Tongues, Starless and Bible Black, Red, Lanquidity, Musik von Harmonia, Zuckerzeit, Phaedra, Meet the Residents, In Praise of Learning, Third Reich n Roll, Suicide, Low, "Heroes", Not Available, Chairs Missing, MSABAF, The Modern Dance, Dub Housing, Alien Soundtracks, Half Machine Lip Moves, 154, Metal Box, Fear of Music, This Heat, Jane from Occupied Europe, Deceit, Discipline, The Flowers of Romance, Birdsongs of the Mesozoic, Confusion Is Sex, Psychic Powerless, Bad Moon Rising, EVOL, Daydream Nation, Doolittle, Spirit of Eden, Laughing Stock, Loveless, Yerself Is Steam, Eva Luna, Boces, The Stars Are So Big, TRNBWA, Tortoise, Helium, Iaora Tahiti, Exploded Drawing, Millions Now Living, ETK, Filosofem, OK Computer, ITAOTS, TNT, Black Foliage, Vision Creation Newsun
Off the top of my head so I might have missed some

>>71986369
>OK Computer

>beatles have two albums
>pleb sounds isn't there
YES, FUCK YOU RETARDED COCKSUCKERS, BEATLES WIN, FOREVER, I WIN, YOU LOSE, NOW FUCK OFF AND DIE

>>71981755
Why are these kind of threads allowed on /mu/?

should be like this:

1 the bends
2 mezmerize
3. turn on, the bright lights
4. discovery
5. horses
6. birth of the cool
7. humbug
8. vol. 3
9. sung tongs
10. ascension

whoever disagrees is a pretentious hipster faggot

>>71986477
>whoever disagrees is a pretentious hipster faggot

Great music based arguments there, thanks for such an interesting post and addition to the discussion.

>>71986493
t. pretentious hipster faggot

>>71986477
One of these is not like the others

>>71981755
>OKC
paranoid android is the only good song
>DSOTM
Lol...
>TVU&N
WL/WH is better
>WYWH
Lol...
>Kid A
better than OKC but still not amazing
>ITCotKC
Good
>MBV
Good
>Abbey Road
LMAO
>Revolver
it's alright
>Zep IV
LMAOOO

>>71984685
didn't predict my mood u shit

>>71989336
http://rateyourmusic.com/customchart

This chart was created by people voting

>>71981786
This

>>71981755
Don't we have this thread every few days now?

>>71981755
>only rock music
more like ryr

>>71981786
fpbp