Closer > UP Prove me wrong

Only people who wear Unknown Pleasures shirts and only really like Disorder would disagree.

New Order >>> Joy Division
Prove me wrong

OP isn't wrong mainly 'cause Closer has The Eternal

Joy Division was a singles band anyway

Still is better than both

>>71938335
listening to UP now and it's pretty good. I think Les Bains Douches had a good enough selection that you won't need to hear their studio albums

File: 25.jpg (36KB, 400x300px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 400x300px

An Ideal For Living > Closer >UP

>>71938315

New Order had a fucking shit singer, like bland as fuck.

Ian Curtis had a blandish voice but he was fucking supposed to for the type of music he was making.

Bernard Sumner should've just stayed on guitar and let Peter Hook do vocals.

>>71938233
>>71938315
I literally can't.

>>71938233
Contrarian "look at me im le different" opinion. No songs on closer are better than disorder, she lost control, or shadowplay

>>71938469
>i can't into music that isn't pop

>>71938469
Colony

>>71938508
the only answer i would've accepted was the eternal. UP as a whole is still a better record. see me after class

>>71938469
atrocity exhibition
isolation
colony
heart and soul
decades

>>71938606
passover too

>>71938486
What are you trying to say baby brains? That closer is less pop than UP?

>>71938622
true