The 10 most acclaimed albums ever. Thoughts?

music is overrated

>>71888525
take off Nirvana, Banana, Sgt. Pepper's and Radiohead and you've got a pretty solid list

>>71888546
You have to say what you would replace them with

why the fuck is nirvana so high

I never liked The Clash. Aren't they just punk for pussies? Like, Green Day before Green Day?

Pretty unpopular opinion but The Clash is one of the most boring bands I've listened to. Am I too pleb?

>>71888564
they're punk for new wave fans

>>71888565
Nah they're shit.

>>71888564
>>71888565
Same

>>71888564
>>71888565
London Calling is a really good album desu . Best double album for me

>>71888556
Miles Davis - Kind of Blue
Sonic Youth - Daydream Nation
David Bowie - Ziggy Stardust
Bob Dylan - Blood on the Tracks

>>71888546
Keeping the clash while getting rid of VU&N
This must be bait

>>71888564
>>71888565
People only like The Clash because of Stranger Things

nirvana is a shit grunge band, also this album over in utero? kekkles

>>71888564
It's post-punk you mouth breather. They incorporate a wider range of styles than the blues based early punk

>>71888655
A large part of acclaim is influence.

>>71888748
You mean pop?

>>71888525
Never saw this before but I'm quite glad that Exile on Main St. is there, the best of all of them.

What's Going On is, while a decent album, literally babby's first soul music

>>71888627
t. 17 years old

>>71888602
yeah i can agree with you

>>71888655
contrarian faggots are the only ones who say in utero is better than nevermind

File: 1490832975651.jpg (24KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

24KB, 600x600px

>>71888525
>revolver instead of rubber soul

>>71888825
2bad because it's better in every way

>>71888843
>sgt. pepper's instead of rubber sould
ftfy.

>>71888843
I'd take revolver actually. Abbey road is my favorite album however.
>>71888825
But it's true

>>71888525
Aside from Velvet Underground this is the most Reddit list imaginable. All it's missing is Thriller.

>>71889032
It's literally an aggregation of reviews and all time list placements.

>>71888546
>popular thus bad
Kill yourself soon

File: next 20.jpg (88KB, 831x581px) Image search: [Google]

88KB, 831x581px

Here's the next 20.

http://www.acclaimedmusic.net/

>>71889066
more like...i dont like them

>>71889066
All these albums are popular you twit.

>>71888565
Yeah, too pleb.

Wish (you) Were Here is much better than any of that crap.

>>71889177
Not as good as DSOTM according to the critics. >>71889090

>>71888602
I don't think you can bring jazz into this out of nowhere--it's gotta be a different list imo. Because then how are you gonna justify leaving off A Love Supreme or Blue Train or even like Head Hunters?

Also, two Dylan albums and neither one is Highway 61 Revisited.

>>71889213
well it was more of a personal list. i thought about A Love Supreme, and as far as Dylan - Blonde on Blonde and Blood on the Tracks are my favorite albums so there was a little bit of a bias

>>71888565
I don't like the clash, but I still wouldn't describe them as boring.

where is Art Angels

>>71888799
...And?

Oh silly me, I forgot quality and merit were gauged by obscurity.

Grow up.

>>71889310
Agree. What's Going On is a masterpiece. It's like the soundtrack to heaven

>>71888525
>most acclaimed
By whom? What metrics? Because even though Pet Sounds is my favorite of all of these and top five all time for me personally as well, I doubt most mainstream spots would have it above the far more popular records right below it in this list.

Also,
>7/10 of them are rock music
Yeah...I doubt it.

>>71889372
I didn't make the website, I was just trying to generate discussion. If you want to know more about his formula I'm sure it's sourced here
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acclaimed_Music

>>71888525
>Great
>Good
>Good or Great as pop
>Half great half shit
>Temporarily Great
>Most overrated punk album
>Great R&B
>Not even the best Rollling Stones album
>Everything he does is overrated. You don't need any of his albums up there just say his name and move on.
>Kid A was better but still really good
Overall good normie choices

>>71889090
>Overrated
>One good song
>One of the worst Beatles albums
>Not Electric Ladyland but good
>Overrated, has a few good tracks
>I like it but that's way too high.
>He's kinda shit
>Pretty good.
>Good
>Overrated but not pleb
>Should be higher for this list. Not that it's the best.
>Meh
>Bretty Good
>Not their best
>Pretty good
>There it is
>Should be higher
>I'm always half hearted about it
>Should be much higher
>Ok

How is Remain In Light not even in the top 30, let alone the top 10?

>>71889867
There have been a lot of albums man. Even being top100 is a massive honor

>>71888843

If You Won't See Me is GOAT

>>71888525

>ethereal
>their best
>what why lol
>Banunu
>Overratted BS that should be replaced with Rubber Soul or White Album
>Never listened never cared
>ayy
>no interested
>everything he does is overrated
>everything they do is overrated

>>71888565
Their self-titled is different and better if you've only heard London Calling

>>71889032
TVU is reddit whether you want to admit it or not

Why are they all normie trash? :-((

Nirvana's best album was in utero and even then definitely not top 10 of all time albums
pet sounds I agree should be high
sargy pappers, sure why not
the rest can actually fuck off with that
plus you have like 3 genre's of music and the rest being sub genre's
lmao
stop that

>>71888525
all those albums are overrated. People eat their member berries and go rate this medicore bullshit to the top.

Beatles,Marvin Gaye,Nirvana have a handful of songs that are excellent and popular. The fact that anybody thinks that what the Beach Boys were doing was either on par with the Beatles or better makes me sick.

How can you put a man(Brian Wilson) who popularized the way all producers produce music (wall of sound technique etc.) to some decent boy band.

these lists reflect the demographic of music critics, not necessarily whats good music.

>>71890940
Someone with sense, on /mu/?

>>71888525
Revolver - 6
Nevermind - 5
VU&N - 8
SPLHCB - 7
LONDON - 6
Gay - 8
Exile - 5
Blonde - 6
OKC - 8

>>71888525
Says who???

>>71888525
50% British, 50% American
Thoughts?

>>71888602
>>71889213
you guys know shit about jazz, but it's ok, i still love you

File: cat tipper.gif (2MB, 335x258px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 335x258px

>>71891166
>muh jazz