Best Pink Floyd Member?

>>71875687
I don't know if he was the best, but Richard is the most overlooked member of the band. Wrote some of their best songs as well.

Waters. No contest.

>>71875687
It's objectively Waters. He literally made Pink Floyd "Pink Floyd".

Water

Waters was the best writer
Gilmore wrote the best music
Wright played the best
Mason was the chillest

>>71875806
>Gilmore wrote the best music
That was also Waters.

File: 1459701460007.jpg (29KB, 500x364px) Image search: [Google]

29KB, 500x364px

>>71875687

Syd

they shouldn't have even called themselves pink floyd after he "left"

>>71875806
Gilmore had the best public appeal*

Also fuckin love Mason. Underrated man.
http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x1stgo_pink-floyd-pompei-one-of-these-days_music

>>71875687
Syd

piper and madcap > rest of PF discography

>>71875687
you gotta appreciate the £/effort mason had going
>>71875806
post one waters lyric that's opel tier

Roger Waters

the other two answers:

"Gilmore because I'm a guitar player and Roger Waters is mean."

"Syd Barret because I actually actively dislike Pink Floyd and only rep Piper At The Gates of Dawn as a means to talk about how much I dislike Pink Floyd."

>>71875852
TOOK MY DADDY FROM MEEEEEEEEE

Gilmour

>>71875687
Syd gave the band life

Waters made it Pink Floyd

Ringo Starr

Richard Wright is the patrician answer

>>71875708
This.

The correct answer is Gilmour

Alan Parsons

>>71875766
Fire

>>71876039
>muh if u don't like my fave ur a h8r

>>71875687
Wright = Syd = Waters > Mason >Gilmore

>>71875687
Gilmour and Wright were best musicians
Barret was the best psychedelia guy
Waters the best writer