Rate my song

I feel like this is a reference to that anime about the three little pigs and the big bad wolf(?)

>>71850332
I don;t know what that is

File: 1478774708282.gif (662KB, 798x798px) Image search: [Google]

662KB, 798x798px

>>71850270
I rate it totally garbage mate.

http://vocaroo.com/i/s0VHCOzpWiT3

>>71850964
is that a mandolin?

>>71850964
Wow I just wasted 42 seconds.

Fucking garbage.

>>71850270
It's great

I don't know how i feel about that chord progression. It's kinda not very good.

>>71851128
Wow thanks

>>71851277
I think you are a shit bag. You couldn't write one song so shut up cunt.

>>71851328
Chill man. Can't handle criticism? It can only make you better. I'm still really unsure about it. I'm messing around with it on my guitar and it's starting to sound a little better. At first it threw me off because the progression, from what i can tell, doesn't fit in a common key, so it just sounds kinda off at first. Going from e minor to F# major is a somewhat dissonant to my ears. I think F # minor sounds a bit better personally.

>>71851328
care to play some of it on vocaroo?

>>71851833
Why? So you people can try to belittle me and hurt my feelings more than you already have?

>>71851876
I'm really not trying to belittle you. If you don't want to it's fine. I wanted to hear what tempo and chord shapes you had in mind. barre chords? open chords? Just curious about that kind of stuff.

>>71851876
If you plan on making music plan on getting criticism too. All the greats were called shitty at some point too. Just keep making music! Even if you become as good as your heroes, there will be someone out there who doesn't like your music. What other people say doesn't matter very much. Best wishes to your music making!