So the dude who's doing this can post updates and so we can wait and talk and other shit
1 v 128
>>71691694
I'm gonna try to refine my pastebin into non retardation, maybe remove some memes as well
>>71691694
Tell me again why don't we start nominating? What is op even doing?
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574474
>>71691736
we already had two nomination threads anon, you're a bit late to the party
>>71691694
ITAOTS will win
>>71691724
>remove memes
So basically everything
>>71691736
The nominating already happened and we got 128.
I was going to do the tournament but another anon said he was going to.
>>71691765
this meme needs to die. it's a good record, but damn, mu sucks mangum's dick too much
>>71691724
I started doing the matchups but gave up because I don't know what some of the jokes are. If you clean up the pastebin and post it I can write a script to randomly generate the matchups.
>>71691786
nigga it basically invented indie folk
>>71691801
like i said, good record. but its not the best ever fucking made
>>71691749
Yes. It makes it more interesting with multiple entries.
>>71691801
>indie anything
>good
lmao
>>71691811
can you name 128 other albums that have a better shot at contention?
>>71691811
Fuck you.
>>71691801
>nigga it basically invented indie folk
Haha oh wow
>>71691821
>saying that on the 10th anniversary of Person Pitch
Wew
>>71691801
>what is Sebadoh?
>>71691832
Fuck you.
>>71691847
>Person Pitch
who
>>71691848
>Sebadoh
>folk
Pls knock out ITAOTS early, /mu/
>>71691859
>>71691832
Fuck you.
>>71691865
>>71691922
Fuck you.
>>71691922
Fuck you.
>>71691926
>using RYM as a source
LOL
>>71691922
Fuck you.
>>71691926
>>71691960
Did they just not use a colored picture for this? In fucking 2007?
>>71691947
>using your own judgment to say that NHM invented indie folk way after it was already invented
LOL
fuck me.
>>71691917
Fuck (you).
>>71691991
wasnt me but as in most similar cases, NMH gets the credit cause they popularized it
>>71691993
>DADDY BETTA MAKE ME CHOKE (YOU BETTA)
>>71691960
>thinking Wikipedia is a good source for genre labels
>>71692026
only did cause the other guy used RYM
RYM is more trustworthy for genre labels than Wikipedia. Just listening to the music, as well, suggests indie folk.
>tfw to depressed to eat burger
>tfw avoiding sweets too because they don't help muscle gains
HOW'S IT GOING OP???
>tfw i started this chain of 'Fuck you's
tell me what the appeal of ITAOTS is. i like that album quite a bit, but mu treats it like the work of god
>>71692057
there is a pretty large distinction between indie rock and indie folk anon
>>71692103
Not OP, but I'm still waiting on the pastebin guy to post his fixed pastebin and then I'm going to randomize the matchings.
>>71692103
This is just a waiting room, they already said it's going to take a while.
>>71692117
there is quite simply just nothing else like it
retardation has been removed
http://pastebin.com/3Rsk7Fr8
memes have been spared, there's still more than 128 albums on here so
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574596
>>71692117
Fuck you.
>>71692139
I know that.
Basically my main point is that NHM did not invent indie folk. Sebadoh does sound very folky to me, but I probably am wrong in defining them as indie folk
>>71692163
yo where's yankee hotel foxtrot
>>71692168
>>71692117
fuck you.
>>71692192
looks like it's in the trash bud
>>71692174
My main point is that they popularized it. They are literally one of the first staples of indie folk.
>>71692202
it got like 10 votes tho
>>71692117
Fuck you.
>>71692163
Which ones would you consider the memes?
>>71692192
fine fine fine, consider it in then
Reminder not to cut off holy mountain if we cut off at 128 since that one was prior to second bread
>>71692202
this >>71692216
>delete memes
delet this
memes are my equivalent of living on life support
>>71692211
yeah, but that's not what you said, is it. I will concede that they popualrized it though.
>>71692222
viper, death of pablo, alien rap, guns n roses, linkin park for starters, after that i'd either ask which others to get rid of or delete some artist's multiple entries
we need to get rid of 11 entries to get exactly 128
(counting foxtrot)
>>71692222
nice quads btw
>>71692227
Same with Atrocity Exhibition.
And OK Computer was one of the first of the second thread so keep it too.
>>71692245
said here: >>71692010
>>71692254
Roses & Park especially. Both of those only got to enough votes because of people replying saying they were awful choices.
>>71692286
i was responding to >>71691801
sorry for any confusion
>>71692254
I swear to god if Viper isn't in this tournament i'll
>>71692222
Not him but Terminal Redux and TDOP I suppose.
Also, remove Linkin Park and Guns n' Roses. Their respective albums only got replies because they are exceptionally shit choices.
Does Swans really need to have three entries?
>>71692254
You should delete the memes, move Holy Mountain, OK Computer and Atrocity up above 128 (because they got in before the others at the bottom), then cut it off at 128
meme deletion seems to be the ideal choice here, so I will remove
Viper
death of pablo
Alien Kids
Linkin Park
guns n roses
and then I can either delete some by my choosing or you can all decide in the next, let's say 5 minutes, which other 6 have to go
keep in mind yankee hotel foxtrot is officially (unofficially) on the list
>>71692310
>Terminal Redux
I voted for that unironically. not sure what you mean
>>71692254
Pls dont delete entries just because the artist has other entries.
>>71692327
>>71692310
oh yeah terminal redux as well
>>71692323
atrocity exhibition goes up to 128 along with those then, is this acceptable?
>>71692350
yah just do it my dude
>>71692327
Remove one Swans and one Radiohead, can't these faggots fanbases stop masturbating over these bands? Two albums max seems like enough, there are others that also have two which is why I'm not going full sperg asking for a limit of one per band
where's thick as a brick? didn't that get in early?
>>71692350
Yes
>no ken snyder
Rev the poll scripts up guys.
>>71692350
Yeah, let's not spend too much time worrying about little details and just get something ready
Here's a start
Strawpoll for meme removal
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574667
Strawpoll for which ones get in
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574678
(multiple answers allowed)
pastebin anon takes this into account at his own discretion.
here we are then, this will be the final listing if no further objections are made
http://pastebin.com/J9driLB2
keep in mind I'm not OP so I'm not gonna make the bracket
>>71692476
Not fair to kick off Atrocity since it got four votes in the first thread but was just added late. Same with a couple other albums there.
>>71692476
Just delete the three memes and that's it.
>>71692493
Matchups:
http://pastebin.com/9Y45Kdf2
>>71692493
Perfect.
>>71692562
these are some spicy matchups my friend
>>71692562
Let's fucking do this!
As soon as OP is ready
>>71692562
How to vote on these
>>71692562
>63 matchups
something is missing anon
>>71692595
Type it.
>>71692562
>Swans vs Radiohead first round
I guess I can stop bitching now
Let's wait for OP then
>>71692562
>swans - to be kind vs. Radiohead - OK COMPUTER
oh man gawd damn
>>71692562
fuuuuuuuuck frances is gonna get outed by a garbage meme right out the gate
>>71692562
wait just one cotton pickin minute
shouldn't there be 64 entries? am I retarded?
>>71692601
I fucked up
Here's a new one:
http://pastebin.com/3qQt33zH
Where the fuck is this album you fuckers
>>71692608
HOW THE FUCK AM I GOING TO CHOOOSE
>>71692562
Yeah, I like this.
>>71692562
I honestly hope Drake wins over Muse in the first round
>>71692631
This is a much better matchup:
>>71692562
Can we just stick the remaining two on the end of that?
>>71692631
>deathcon vs sunbather
wew
>>71692631
>A love supreme vs tvun
Wew
we probably should've included No Now and Mad Illusions
So... how do we do this? OP posts a tournament bracket? Strawpoll? how do we do this?
>>71692635
you lost
>>71692631
Fuck the first one was spicier
>>71692633
I'm sure this one got in in the first thread, thought it was on the list
Shit's a mild mess, but I guess it couldn't be any other way
>>71692631
The first round match ups were better. What was missing from the first matchups?
>Lift Yr. Skinny Fists but no F#A# Infinity
Disgusted.
Though that will help if two favorites are against each other I guess.
>>71692708
>Godpseed You! BLACK eMPORER - F#A#Infinity vs. Arcade Fire - Funeral
nigga can you read
>>71692664
Okay, that works.
http://pastebin.com/UhmES7vf
>>71692695
Fucking hell
>>71692562
Can you just edit your fixes into this one? Matchups are a lot more spicy here.
>>71692708
F#A# is there he just misspelled emperor
>>71692728
>http://pastebin.com/UhmES7vf
SPICY
so what now? what if OP is gone?
>>71692728
IT GOES
>>71692562
>symphonies vs the queen is dead
rip
>tfw I nominated flood and it's against yeezus
>tfw I nominated SHM and it's against the blue album
RIP me
>>71692728
>Wyatt vs. Stooges battle
Hoo boy
>>71692728
>http://pastebin.com/UhmES7vf
ALRIGHT TOECHOMPERS, OFFICIAL PASTEBIN HERE
>>71692720
Holy shit is actually there, damn.
It's against ...Like Clockwork though.
>>71692764
>now Sleep is against MBV
>>71692764
>tfw no Akuma no Uta
RIP me as well, I got the noose here, going to listen to it one last time
Good luck my friends.
>Disintegration vs Kid A first round
Kid A is good but you cucks better not let it kick out the best album ever made already
the velvet underground & nico vs. unknown pleasure
>>71692728
These couldn't be better if planned
>>71692764
>>71692797
flood is absolute trash, akuma no uta should've been on instead
>>71692764
>Yeezus
Is someone actually making the brackets? So I can know if it's worth staying here
new thread for voting? do we vote on individual matchups in each thread? SOMEONE TAKE THE REIGNS
>>71692833
It's easy to make a strawpoll for each pair but it's no fun if someone's not keeping track of it in the ebin brackets
>Since I Left You vs Remain in Light
gee i wonder who's gonna win
>>71692801
Wrong, best album by the cure is Faith. I'm voting Kid A
>>71692851
this
the visual is important
why isn't thick as a brick there???! i swear it got enough votes early enough
>>71692858
>What is Pornography
>mfw I'm unfamiliar with 99% of these albums and basically only know of ItCotCK, Red, and Remain in Light
As long as one of those three makes it, I'm pretty good.
>Charles Mingus - The Black Saint and The Sinner Lady vs. Nirvana - Bleach
>>71692894
Is this faggot for real
>>71692894
literally why are you here
>>71692909
Probably desu.
>tfw i tried to upload the texas-jerusalem crossroad
>tfw image limit hit right before i finished captcha
Don't know about anyone else, but I'm interested to see how that XTC x Pulp battle goes
I couldn't guess either way desu
>>71692931
I'm curious about that one as well. I already have my vote though.
t. contrarian faggots
>>71692909
>>71692920
>>71692925
>>71692930
>tfw no face
So are we ready to go? Can we start the battle?
Alright fuck it im gonna start on a bracket. its gonna look like shit and maybe another anon can spice it up a little when its finished. If someone else gets it done before me please post. Im probably gonna take a long ass time to get this made.
tfw two albums you nominated are up against each other
>>71692960
t. b8
where can you vote
Remain in Light will win
screencap this
>>71692909
Yes.
>>71692920
Because I enjoy music discussion.
>>71692979
>tfw that didn't happen to me because though I posted more than 5 albums only 2 are in competition
>>71692989
It's going to be one of these:
a) Remain in Light
b) Trout Meme Replica
c) In the Court of the Crimson King [very unlikely]
>>71692975
Thanks anon
Somebody has to make a thread and link all the 64 strawpolls too, sounds like a pain
I'd normally do it but not today, gotta study :^(
>>71692975
fuck i already have no idea what im doing someone help
>>71693020
>What is In the Aeroplane Over the Sea
>mfw dsotm wins and this board is labelled pleb forever
>>71692728
>Modest Mouse - Lonesome Crowded West vs. Animal Collective - Spirit They're GOne, Spirit They've Vanished
aw geez that's a good one
hoping my boy Avey will get this one
when's the voting?
I hope The Mollusk wins this shit. I know it sounds humble as all hell, but oh well
>>71693039
I could honestly see Aeroplane getting knocked out because of "anything but Aeroplane" voters
>>71692989
capped
>Marvin Gaye - what's going on vs. Kanye West - My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
>The Beatles - Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Heart's Club Band vs. Death Grips - The Money Store
fuck whoever made this
>>71693020
I know it's unlikely, but I'm hoping it's either 'Were only in it for the money' or 'Since i Left you'
>>71693046
>/mu/ ends up with the same shit as RYM
>>71693039
Fuck, forgot about that.
Yeah, in order of most likely to least likely, I predict:
1.) In the Aeroplane Over the Sea
2.) Trout Mask Replica
3.) Remain in Light
4.) In the Court of the Crimson King
>mfw my nom and favourite album of all time is up against captain beefheart and his shitty band
>>71693056
reddit flooded it before anyone else got to post
>>71693077
If it was any good you wouldn't be worrying
>>71693032
Just add some white space on both sides to make the image wider then replace the numbers with the album names in their correct spots
>Neutral Milk Hotel - In The Aeroplane Over The Sea vs. The Zombies - Odessey & Oracle
oh man this is balanced
>>71693032
Use challonge.com to generate a bracket
>>71693087
knowing /mu/ tho they prefer memes over quality
>>71693058
Money has a good chance since it's against that annoying bleepy Sufjan album, but SILY will likely lose to Brian Eno's Guitar Trip to Africa.
>>71693105
>implying the mars volta is better than beefheart
>>71693077
>tfw I love both TMR and Frances
tis hard
>>71693095
*teleports behind you*
>Nothing personal, Zombies...
>quebec vs mm food
i'm fucked
>>71693062
ART
ROCK
>>71693064
Top 6 most likely:
1. ITAOTS
2. Kid A
3. OKC
4. ITCOTCK
5. Soundtracks for the Blind
6. TMR
7. MBDTF
>>71693095
>mfw if The Zombies win
>>71693095
kek
RIP The Zombies
>>71693134
that could go either way
>>71693139
*top 7
>>71693095
ITS THE TIME AND THE SEASON FOR WINNING
>>71693104
Gonna try this
>Drake - Take Care vs. muse - Origin of symmetry
>>71693134
Which one are you rooting for?
I couldn't call that one. I find the cross-genre match-ups here to be the most interesting.
A meme deserves to win
Pls beat Yankee Hotel, Yeezus
First four polls
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574829
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574833
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574835
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574842
We need a thread to promote the brackets and gather more votes from over the board
>>71693077
>liking neo-prog
baka
>>71693175
>Drake got in
How did that happen?
>>71693175
I feel like this could go either way
>mfw the 2 albums i want to win are up against the mars volta
nobody actually likes the mars volta right
>>71693169
>>71693104
nah fuck this not visually appealing at all
>>71693188
>posting polls before the image is put together
Pls dont
>>71693175
>It's real
>kraftwerk vs kraftwerk
i can vote to eliminate both right
>mfw Trout Meme Replica gets absolutely squashed in the beginning by people who've never listened to Mars Volta solely because they don't want it to win
>>71693212
i-i do
>>71693180
I'm voting for quebec, I think /mu/ likes mm food more desu
>>71693188
>Frances vs TMR
oh fuck this is hard already
>mfw The banana album will win
>>71693233
Fuck off, that was shit asmr too
praying to Kek that frances the mute beats trout mask replica
>>71693279
same t b h
>>71692117
fuck you
how long will the polls stay open?
>>71693279
ditto desu
>>71693228
At this rate it's never going to happen though. I have the next four ready, but if everyone prefers to wait the bracket I'll stop. If that's the case someone take over pls, I'm not going to be around for too long (supposed I had time for the first round links at least)
where do we vote?
>>71693279
both are great though
Someone should just get a bored fag with photoshop on /wsr/ to put the image together if none of you guys will
>>71693288
dubs confirms--Kek backs TMR.
>>71693288
Fuck you.
>>71693304
Keep going man
>>71693267
I've never listened to Meme Volta either and I don't plan to (prog should have died in 1974 when it reached its peak with Red - Fripp knew this, being the genius he is, and that's why he disbanded King Crimson only to reform it with the new wave-y sound), but I still voted for it because fuck TMR.
>>71693279
>>71693286
>>71693294
we must not let this captain man and his magic band beat us
David Bowie - Ziggy Stardust vs. Gas - Pop
wew
>>71693312
Yeah, we should probably just do this
>>71693330
>>71693312
I can do it, I guess. I ain't got much to do, anyway.
LOL I voted for Mars Volta over TMR
>>71693339
Nice one mate
>>71693320
Alright here it goes, thought thinking it again the other anon is somewhat right, this whole thing is kind of a mess
Anyway, next 4 pairs:
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574849
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574854
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574856
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574862
>>71693339
>mfw everyone bitching about TMR
>mfw TMR is winning
>>71693356
You're a nu-male forever if you vote Pinkerton over Rain Dogs
COME ON FRANCES PUSH THROUGH
>>71693356
>A Kind of Blue
>>71693356
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574893
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574899
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574903
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574908
>>71693356
I think we should wait for the image before posting more polls
>>71693422
this. pls wait
>>71693417
Is the site not loading for anyone else?
>>71693417
too fast, wait a little at least
>>71693391
I haven't ever listened to a Weezer or Tom Waits album but I'm voting for Tom Waits just because I fucking hate the name "Weezer" for a band, like holy fucking shit what a godawful name.
I also fucking hate their goddamn fucking album covers.
>>71693417
>Swans - Soundtracks for the Deaf
>weezer gets knocked out in round 1
>>71693391
This.
>>71693391
well guess im anew male then
>>71693417
>Soundtracks for the Deaf
lmao
>Daft Punk gets knocked out by some shitty rapist
fuck
>>71693416
>>71693447
Yeah I dropped the ball already, had to do this quickly otherwise I can't.
Someone who can put in more effort take over please, I need to go in about 20 minutes which is why I was rushing it so much.
>>71693422
>>71693435
I offered to make the image, please we gotta wait this is too much to keep up with
>>71693417
>Swans - Soundtracks for the Deaf
>>71693465
E V I D E N C E
also i voted daft punk, already voted for To Be Kind, i also nominated it lol
>>71693449
I'm surprised but happy that College Dropout is winning
thank god blue album is losing
>>71693474
yeah guys, this is going too fast
>>71693449
How it should be.
>>71693417
>swans - soundtracks for the deaf
>>71693490
Pinketon better, i voted college dropout
>burzum losing to some betta male whomst killed himself
How the fuck is Daft Punk losing to fucking Swans? Swans is boring garbage.
Working on making the matchups an image rn. There's no legitimate seeding right?
shouldn't we remake the polls so the album titles are not fucked up?
is this the definition of brainwashing?
The poll for SFTD vs Discovery
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574934
Ignore the one that has Swans vs Daft
Hehe I voted for discovery to knock out swans cause I know theyll be a powerhouse if they make it passed r1
>>71693525
I believe it's supposed to be Songs for the Deaf - Queens of the Stone Age
>>71693514
>>71693545
>SFTD
kek!
>>71693532
Only two were fucked up, tho
>>71693545
>queens of stone age - soundtracks for the deaf
ayy lmao
>>71693525
>Swans is boring garbage
>implying Daft Punk isn't boring synthpop
>>71693545
>queens of stone age - soundtracks for the deaf
We need an image and a dedicated general thread to get this started
>>71693572
French House. And it's not boring.
oh shit I just realized I wrote soundtracks for the deaf when I made the pastebin
>>71693545
lmao
scriptfags pls go
>>71693570
>>71693574
nigga you know what it is
>>71693572
>house = synthpop
>Daft Punk past Homework = boring
lmao
>voted against swans all 3 times
tight
>>71693576
this is a good idea. this is all going too fast with no organization
>>71693525
No, they're losing against Queens of the Stone Age.
>>71693576
Some dude is working on the image
>>71693610
lol samesies
>>71693610
>only 12 polls posted
>swans in 3 of them already
Voted against them too desu
>>71693616
also, a tin teardrop
>>71693610
You actually voted against Songs for the Deaf in one of them though.
>>71693618
Don't you mean Swans of the Stone Age - Soundtracks for the Deaf
okay guys OP made a mistake, we're only human leave him alone :(
>>71693545
It's Songs for the Deaf my dude.
>>71693679
HIS LIFE DEPENDS ON IT
no pressure op
next 4
>>71693679
>>71693701
What OP tho there are like 4 OPs in this thread
>>71693707
w8 for the image, m8
>>71693679
it's ok my dude
>>71693715
Ok we need a roll call real quick
Strawpoll guy and image guy are differenr guys, right?
>>71693750
pretty sure, yes
image guy is making the image
>>71693715
the strawpoll obvs
>>71693750
I don't even know how many image guys there are. I'm one of them.
>mfw I have to wait the pic for the Pulp vs.
>>71693784
what image are we talking about? adding album covers to the bracket?
i really hope rock record doesnt beat a jazz record
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574981
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574982
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574983
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574986
>>71693803
Yeah, adding them to the OP image. Or they could just be the album names and we could add the covers later if desired.
>>71693803
I'm putting album covers and text on mine.
I'm this guy: >>71693339
>>71693812
you pooper
>>71693826
thanks m8
>>71693812
France is objectivelly better than Italy
>>71693812
oh fug :DDDDDDDDDDD
>>71693812
>winter winning
kvlt as fvck
>>71693812
fegat
Now we're at bump limit can we just wait until the picture's done before the new thread's made?
When pic guy's done he can make a new thread with brackets as main pic.
Wait, I just noticed... aren't we using the wrong matches? In the first one they forgot two and they made another really different, so we keep the old one and we just add the one that isn't there or what?
>>71693880
This
>>71693856
*autumn
Good taste, lads.
what the fuck is even going on
>>71693890
http://pastebin.com/UhmES7vf
>>71693890
The most recent strawpoll is the one we should be using, which is this: >>71692728
>>71693908
>>71693913
Oh, I didn't notice that one. Ok then.
>>71693903
Current status:
>waiting for pic guy before more polls are made
>continuing to vote in the polls while waiting
>>71693924
where are the polls
>>71693913
Wait I was making an image for the previous pastebin, am I fucked?
>>71693944
The strawpolls:
>>71693188
>>71693356
>>71693417
>mfw TMR vs FTM results
>>71693972
Yes
Polls:
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574829
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574833
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574835
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574842
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574849
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574854
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574856
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574862
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574893
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574899
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574903
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574908
>>71693969
thank you
>>71693972
Depending on how your image is set up, you might be able to just shift a column down.
>>71693972
Which one?
>>71694008
The 63 matchup one, but that's what we've been basing the strawpolls off of right?
>>71694023
lol
>>71694023
There's a fixed one with the 64 matchups. It's essentially the 63 one with the missing pair added.
>>71694023
should be this one
http://pastebin.com/UhmES7vf
>>71693944
here my friend >>71693812
>>71694023
Yeah, should be fine. The final pastebin is just the 63 pastebin with the final pair jammed in at the end.
>>71694023
Just add the one that was added in the last strawpoll. You should be fine otherwise.
>>71693998
Wrong poll on that last one, this is the good one:
http://www.strawpoll.me/12574934
Daft Punk loses in both though.
BUMP LIMIT REACHED
new bread or is project kill
I imagine people are either leaving for the night or getting bored by now
>>71694038
>>71694044
>>71694067
>>71694074
Thanks lads, halfway done
Well somebody's gotta make a thread
123not it
>>71694122
We're waiting for picture guy to get the picture with the brackets done, he'll make a new thread with that as main picture when he's done and then we'll just carry on from there.
>>71694122
It's almost time bruh
>>71694137
We're only on page 5
New thread?
NEW THREAD GET IN HERE
>>71694228
>>71694228
>>71694228
>>71694228
>>71694228
>>71694228
>>71694238
You didn't even use the right Daft Punk poll. Fuck off
>>71691801
no it didn't