the great debate

>>71536967
OK COMPUTER is such shit

garbage

All shit albums

DSOTM for me
I used to be a (born in the wrong generation) great Beatles fan but now I don't see them as anything special.
OK Computer is amazing, but DSOTM is obviously better and more important album.

>>71536967
Sergeant Pepper no doubt. Can't even understand why OK Computer is on there when that is when Radiohead started their downfall.

>>71536967
Over which is the most overproduced garbage album of all time? Probably Pepper's but Dark Side is close behind

3/10
2/10
4/10

OK Computer is objectively the best album of the last 20 years

File: 1476121416402.png (1MB, 1468x672px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1468x672px

Is it bad that I haven't heard any of them?

>>71538567
No, don't waste your time

>>71537022
Radiohead released their best after Ok Computer you contrarian

Dark Side. Contrarians will say Radiohead. Plebs will say Beatles.

Dark Side > Ok Computer > Sgt Peppers

As long as Beatles are last you're right

>>71536967
Ok Computer has some insane high points, but isn't that consistent, DSOTM is consistent but doesn't hit the same highs, and Pepper doesn't even belong there

>>71538694
>doesn't hit the same highs
>What is Us and Them

What a bizarre selection of albums. You seem to have picked the 2nd best Beatles album, the 3rd best Pink Floyd album, and an okay Radiohead album

>>71538745
A song that is nothing compared to Airbag, Subterranean Homesick Alien and Lucky

>>71538694
Dude Dark Side has Great Gig, Us & Them, Any Colour You'd Like...to me that's the album with higher highs

I love OKC btw

>>71536967
All good but massively overrated albums. Overproduced, lacking strong ideas. Except for Pepper, sort of. So that one is best.
>>71538567
I wanna live under whatever rock this guy has

>>71538771
not even the best songs from OKC
>>71538788
>lacking strong ideas
Objectively wrong in all 3 cases

File: lerightgeneration.png (221KB, 843x384px)

221KB, 843x384px

>>71537016
>I used to be a (born in the wrong generation) great Beatles fan
helllo reddit

DSotM > Sgt. Peppers > OK computer

File: OItnWGv.jpg (42KB, 480x270px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 480x270px

>>71536995
>>71537011
>>71537026
>>71537240
>>71538582
>pic related
>>71537022
>Presumably liking pablo honey

>>71538814
It's true though. Just from a songwriting perspective, OK Computer is fairly average and Dark Side is straight up mediocre. Sgt. Pepper is overall pretty good songwriting

For me the best is Sgt Pepper's, it's a great record with a cohesive feeling,second place Dark Side, i think it's good but definitely not the best Floyd album, and I can't get into Ok Computer, you guys praise it a fuckton and I don't get it, preffer in rainbows

>>71536967
1. Sgt Peppers
>Their most solid throughout album by a decent margin, but I don't think the Beatles made very solid albums
2. Dark Side of the Moon
>Wish you were here + Animals would beat Sgt Peppers
3. OK Computer
>Their best album but i'm not a big fan

>>71537240
Correction:
1.5/10
1/10
2/10

Pepper, followed by Dark Side of the Moon, followed by OK Computer.

If you're replying to this shit on /mu/ the only coherent stance is OKC being the best on that list by far.
DOSTM is good in the context of it being released in the 70s

>If somebody had not invented "Beatlemania" in 1963, you would not have wasted five seconds of your time reading this greentext about such a trivial band.

File: a48ced05ac742f13a5826ff0cbf5746a.jpg (85KB, 380x130px) Image search: [Google]

85KB, 380x130px

the great debate

Not even the best Radiohead album
Not even the best Beatle album
Clearly the best Floyd album, dickhead contrarians will say its le epic bike xD

>>71540360
>but I don't think the Beatles made very solid albums
haha. they literally pioneered the album as a complete statement. fucking moron

>>71538756
This guy gets it!

>>71539995
This exactly

Pet Sounds

>>71542827
But it's WYWH

>>71542827
>he thinks it's the best Floyd album
Oh anon this is cute

File: IMG_0108.jpg (122KB, 600x460px) Image search: [Google]

122KB, 600x460px

The album with "A Day in the Life" wins

>>71536967
OK Computer is alright, I don't even remember what the other two sound like and I don't consider any of the three to be remarkable at all.

>>71538585
>>71536995
Burn the Witch is one of their best singles of this millenium.

>>71536967
OK Computer does not belong in that company, friend

>>71536967
OKC>SGTP>DSOTM

>>71538567
me neither, it's nice not being in contact with dadrockers/nu-males

>>71544635
It would be my favourite Floyd album, but looking at it from a more objective standpoint, I'd say WYWH is their best album. There really isn't a low point in the entire album whatsoever. Incredibly consistent over all 5 tracks.

i've never listened ot dark side of the moon desu

File: 3ef923690956f97b9376cb838542577f.jpg (82KB, 380x130px)

82KB, 380x130px

Which one wins 90s aotd?

>>71538788
>lacking strong ideas

fucking kek

Dark Side of the Moon > OK Computer > Sgt. Pepper's

All great

The great debate of what? Which overrated album is the best?

>>71539978
That's an overly broad statement. Ideas behind albums don't have to be particularly obscure or strong in order to hold up. Tracks like 'Time' and 'Brain Damage' have some of the greatest songwriting of all time in my opinion because of how easy it is to empathize with the songwriter (Roger Waters in this case).

>Sgt Pepper
but Revolver is their best

Anyways OK Computer = DSOTM >>> Sgt Pepper

If it was Revolver itd be all equal

yellow submarine is the best beatles album