Rate the albums above Geogaddi. Do they really deserve to be there?

Interpol maybe.

2002 was a dogshit year though.

>>71520226
>interpol
absolutely
>wilco
not really
>sigur ros
maybe
>queens
no
>flaming lips
not in a million fucking years

File: Screenshot at 2017-03-11 12-11-57.png (193KB, 733x865px)

193KB, 733x865px

>RYM

>>71520280
only dsotm is a bad album
whats the problem

>>71520280
>OSX

>>71520280
>People who use rym are pretentious

>>71520226
9/10
6/10
10/10
9/10
7/10
8/10

>>71520280
I see nothing wrong here

>>71520280

Rockism is a disease.

>>71520280
all of these albums are good

>>71520280
replace velvet with the queen is dead and where good.

>>71520226
>Turn On the Bright Lights
Of course.
>Yankee Hotel Foxtrot
Lol no.
>( )
Nah.
>Songs for the Deaf
Maybe, I like it a little more.
>Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots
Ha! No.

Turn on the Bright Lights: 8/10
Yankee Hotel Foxtrot: 9/10
() : 8/10
Songs for the Deaf: ??
Yoshimi: 9/10
Geogaddi: ?? (Only listened to campfire headphase and Tomorrow's Harvest and even though the former was superior, I still thought each was disappointing considering the hype

>>71520280
what's wrong anon, don't you like art rock?

>>71520280
Only Pink Floyd actually annoys me tbqh. The others, nothing I can consider a 5.0 but yeah, whatever, they're good.

>>71520226
BoC are overrated

>IDM
wew RYM

Why do people tend to overrate rock so much? Every album that's above Geogaddi can be covered, Geogaddi can't, it's completely unique and impossible to recreate. I think it has to do with tradition, people value the tradition of rock. As time goes by rock will become less and less overrated.

>>71520323
>bitching about rockism on RYM
Dumb bleepfag

File: top.png (338KB, 944x1422px)

338KB, 944x1422px

>>71520226
Why aren't these better albums higher than all of them?

>>71520512

The most random 5/5 I've ever seen.

>>71520512
Go to bed turny

never listened to interpol. not interested
yankee is not better than geogaddi, but close
haven't heard brackets, but i bet it's good. other sigur ros albums have been great
not gonna bother with queens of the stone age either
yoshemi is ok but not better than geogaddi nor wilco

>>71520512
>when plebby avant-teen tries hard to be original

>>71520273
How does Oczy Mlody compare to the rest of The Flaming Lips' discography

>>71520291
The lack of diversity: two bands with two albums.

File: bolten-inc-porcupine-tree-in-absentia.jpg (284KB, 928x916px) Image search: [Google]

284KB, 928x916px

>>71520226
Best 2002 album is not even there

>>71520648
None of that is ''avant-teen'' /mu/ drone.

>>71520226
5/10
7/10
6/10
6/10
6.5/10
6.5/10

>>71520671
Why the fuck did I just answer that question as if it were serious?

>>71520684
kys

File: 1464455218100.gif (2MB, 208x200px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 208x200px

>>71520226
interpol 9/10
wilco: 9.5/10
sigur ros: didn't finish it but for now it's a solid 8.5/10
didn't listen to it, do you recommend it? what does stoner even mean?
didn't listen to it, do you recommend it? i'm listening their 1999 album and it's fine so far
10/10

>>71520512
Because Starbucks-core is worse than p4k-core and RYM-core combined, Turny.

>>71520226
In Absentia should be higher than it is

Geodaddi is so overrated. So many better electronic artists out there than Boards.

File: 1469429943439.jpg (47KB, 956x651px) Image search: [Google]

47KB, 956x651px

>>71520929

>>71520226
It's a fucking tragedy you forgot it in people is below any of those albums excluding interpol's.

>>71520950
Ulrich Schnauss and Jon Hopkins are both better. Boards is entry-level as fuck.

>>71520226
i feel nauseous looking at that. rym is the worst fucking website.

>>71521019
I don't love Schnauss, but Hopkins is the GOAT.

>>71521019

>using entry-level as an argument

Also no, Geogaddi is far from entry-level. That's a one of a kind record.

>>71521019
stop saying "entry-level" when you are namedropping shit like hopkins, infact i hope you throw your keyboard in the trash

>>71520404
art rock is the most pretentious term ever used, it's an offense to real art music.

>>71521041
>>71521029
OK I was being contrarian to the point of absurd. I love Schnauss and Hopkins. I do think BoC is slightly overrated though, but I'll give another listen to see what I'm not exactly getting.

>>71521058
homie I've been listening to Hopkins since years before the p4k review and most people only know Immunity even though that's one of his worse records.

>>71521091
>most people only know Immunity even though that's one of his worse records.
You're going full contrarian again. People should listen to all his discography though.

Interpol does, but not the others.

>>71520280
The only album here I enjoyed was OK Computer. I listened to a few of the top RYM albums one day because I wanted something to put on. Wish You Were Here is cringe as fuck.

Geogaddi will creep up to second in 5-10 years, screencap this.

>>71520883
>solid 8.5/10
Why do people do this? A "solid" score should be a 6 or a 7

>>71521235
You enjoyed OK Computer but not Kid A?

>>71520677
>>71520923
I remember when most PT albums had a score of almost 4.00