Why does he like Buttmetal so much?

you mean like korn and limp bizkit? he rated them at best 7 or 7.5, I don't think that constitutes as "liking so much"

>>71483498
Because the genre is all about
>muh technicality
So obviously he's going to "appreciate" it

>>71483498
don't stress your head over it kiddo

patricians thinking only

>>71483604
When you're a contrarian critic like Scaruffi and you give everything a 4 or 5, getting a 7 is like winning the fucking lottery.

But LUCKILY people on here don't actually like him....
.....I hope.

File: 1385919520438.jpg (67KB, 500x600px) Image search: [Google]

67KB, 500x600px

>>71483643
>But LUCKILY people on here don't actually like him
You poor kid, where do you think you are?

>>71483643
Scaruffi rated my favorite album 5 but I still like him. People who hate him are just buttmad. Overall his taste is still better than 90% of people in here

>>71483604
He also likes Fear Factory, Tool, Dream Theater, Guns n Roses, RATM, Pantera, White Zombie and worst Sepultura album

>>71483725
>Overall his taste is still better than 90% of people in here
Liking his persona? Somewhat understandable...

"his taste is one of the best"? A big fucking stretch.

>>71483730
DT is the only bad one.

he has decent taste, isn't slow deep and hard his favorite metal album of all time?

>>71483725
Nah his taste is trash

>>71484286

name a better critic

he's at least a billion times better than Fantano or Conde Nast-fork

>>71483498
The

>>71484322
That doesn't mean much

>likes grunge and buttmetal
>dislikes Radiohead and all britpop bands except Doves

>>71483498
he could shit on everything I like, but the fact that he has the balls and brains to call Radiohead the most overrated act in recent history gives him more credibility than any other music reviewer out there

>>71483825
>only bad one
Get out.

>>71485646
Not that guy, but they are. All of the other bands at least have some sort of defining sound, DT is just a poor emulation of every progressive band in existence.

Scaruffi bases most of his ratings off of the perceived "authenticity" of an artist. Buttmetal is an extremely authentic genre, it is only made and consumed by people who truly love the genre, regardless of critical reception.

>>71483730
And this is taste of the guy who shits on The Beatles and Bowie? He's an edgy teenager.

If you look at Scaruffi's top albums and honestly think to yourself "yep, his taste is shit", you are one tasteless mongoloid and should probably kill yourself.
I may disagree with him on a lot of accounts, but his favourite albums are all great.

>>71483498
cuz he likes it up the butt :)

>>71485908
Spoken like a true poseur

>>71483604
>>71483643
Don't forget he rated Slipknot s/t and Iowa 7 and 6.5 out of 10

>>71486726
Slipknot s/t is easily a 7.

>>71483498
because it's the literal conclusion to music.

>>71486752
lol

>>71488431
its rating is debatable but it is their best

>>71488463
Vol. 3 is actually bettter

>Scaruffi likes nu-male metal

not surprising

Armond White of /mu/

>>71486712
Spoken like a true shit for brains pleb

>>71488571
t. butthurt poseur

>le Trout Meme Replica is best album of all time XD

>>71488589
It may be not, but it is incredibly influential and innovative even by today's standards. And seeing how Scaruffi values innovativeness above all, it's well deserving of a first spot.

he rated Mindless Self Indulgence a 7/10 ffs

>>71488621
>it's real
lmao

File: 1487374616243.jpg (170KB, 480x478px) Image search: [Google]

170KB, 480x478px

>>71488621
>it's actually real

Why do people take him seriously again?

>>71488617
>innovation
Ftfy kek

I stopped taking him seriously after he rated fucking Trout Mask Replica a 9.5/10

>>71488781
fattano is a butthurt ex-mutant, of fucking course he would rate TMR 9.5 or 10

his taste is as "important" as any other random idiot from here but for some unknown reason people still give him attention

>>71488661
>>71488650
but their album Frankenstein Girls Will Seem Strangely Sexy is actually not bad

>>71489078
we talking about scaruffer