ITT: times scaruffi was right

which one?

File: scrauffi_an_co.png (18KB, 362x187px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 362x187px

This is pretty accurate.

>>71363887
the residents. too lazy to post the screencap

can someone give me a brisk precis on this guy?

>>71364067
>Person Pitch is his highest AnCo score

Everything Scaruffi was ever wrong about has been redeemed

>>71363887
Scaruffi is always right.

>>71364114

STGSTV has the same score, but yeah, he gets the top-tier albums right.

>>71364067
bump all of these up two and he is right

>>71364289
you don't read much scaruffis, am I right

File: POPOPOOIU.png (69KB, 352x538px) Image search: [Google]

69KB, 352x538px

>>71364217
seconded

>>71364217

I just checked this, the self-titled is only a 7/10 right now, what happened? is this a shop?

>>71364436

I don't remember it ever being an 8.

Never believe Scaruffi ratings posted here.

>>71364436
sad isn't it

>>71364436
>>71364463
read >>71364399

>>71364480

what does that have to do with the fake score?

>>71364551
It isn't fake, not anon but I remember it being 8/10 a few years ago

>>71364436
He changes scores more often than you would think

Daydream Nation used to be a 9, apparently, for example, and VU&N used to be a 9.5

Before he heard Faust I too, Faust IV was a 9

His review would indicate a much higher rating than the attached 7/10, so I bet he just changed his mind later and hasn't bother to update the text

>>71363887
>>71364067
>Faggot Collective better than Radiohead
lmao

File: Screen Shot 2017-03-03 at 1.21.04 PM.png (72KB, 762x292px) Image search: [Google]

72KB, 762x292px

>>71363887

>>71363887
Are Scaruffi drones the worst fanbase on /mu/?

File: 3d5d58edbdec5616dee129c0d58927a3.png (6KB, 273x104px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 273x104px

>>71363887

>>71364715
those scores have definitley been changed too

>>71364731
I LITERALLY just took that screencap

pic related contains every time he was right

>>71364743
doesn't mean they haven't been changed by good ol' scaruffles

>>71364636
>>71364574

bullshit, I checked the internet archive wayback machine and none of this is true.

File: ccccccccccc.png (121KB, 516x578px) Image search: [Google]

121KB, 516x578px

>>71364771
oops sorry forgot to attach pic, here ya go

>>71364793
proof faggot

>>71364874

http://web.archive.org/web/20000229172906/http://www.scaruffi.com/vol4/sonicyou.html

http://web.archive.org/web/20021225212738/http://www.scaruffi.com/vol3/faust.html

http://web.archive.org/web/20021202223609/http://www.scaruffi.com/vol2/velvet.html

suck my dick faggot

>>71364067
>Anco good
how good he be so wrong

File: midget with gun.jpg (73KB, 540x748px) Image search: [Google]

73KB, 540x748px

>>71365079
delet this

>>71364715

Third album should be higher.
Same with Loaded.

>>71365219
Wrong. They're good albums but nothing original.

File: 576846575678.png (4KB, 242x70px) Image search: [Google]

4KB, 242x70px

Everytime plebeians talk shit about KoRn, I immediately remind them

>>71364720
This. The only guy to ever give him the time of day.

>>71364952
Wow, crazy. I am so positive that somewhere I read him responding to an email asking about those scores

His response was along the lines of "if Daydream Nation was ever a 9, I'm sorry, that was a mistake" and "I eventually went back and listened to the whole Faust discography and found their first record much more compelling" or something

I'll try and find the link to that

>>71364636
The Smiths used to be on his most overrated artists lists even though they had 7/6/7/7 album ratings, but when he took them off he bumped The Queen is Dead up by 0.5 (now back at 7) and knocked MiM + Strangeways down by 1 each

http://web.archive.org/web/20030608030139/http://www.scaruffi.com/vol4/smiths.html

>>71365079
I mean, yeah. Bowie did in fact die of cancer on that day.

>>71365219
a 6 from scruffi means good, that's about all they are. Nothing special.

>>71365659

to be precise, 6 means "buy if you're a fan," and 7 means "buy eventually."

This is something plebs who think everything below an 8 is shit will never understand.

>>71363887
Why do you care so much about Scaruffi's opinion? (Or p4k's or fandango's)

I'm mainly pointing out Scaruffi because he is a contrarian as fuq

>>71363887
all too high desu

>>71365659
>>71365688

I know what Scaruffi's rating system is like.
I still think that TVU should be at least a 7,5 and Loaded a 6,5 or 7.

Piero (1955), 6/10

Cure's Pornography used to be 8


https://web.archive.org/web/20000510103246/http://www.scaruffi.com/vol4/cure.html

some his bob dylan scores arnt too bad

File: Screenshot_2017-03-03-15-33-19.png (568KB, 1080x1920px) Image search: [Google]

568KB, 1080x1920px

Switch Bossanova with Surfer Rosa and it would be on-point.

>>71364715
wtf some days back i checked this and VU was in 7

>>71366716
>Switch Bossanova with Surfer Rosa and it would be on-point.
no FUCKING WAY

>>71364155
one of the few bands you could clearly consider him a "fan" of, despite what he says about such notions

File: Screenshot_2017-03-03-15-39-14.png (502KB, 1080x1920px) Image search: [Google]

502KB, 1080x1920px

I'll Communication and Check Your Head deserve higher marks imo, but everything else checks out
>>71366791
No.

File: Screen Shot 2017-03-03 at 12.49.11 PM.png (49KB, 766x224px) Image search: [Google]

49KB, 766x224px

literally the only critic to recognize their first as a masterpiece outside of random people on RYM and metallum

File: Screenshot_2017-03-03-15-50-56-1.png (430KB, 1080x1297px) Image search: [Google]

430KB, 1080x1297px

ITT: times scaruffi was wrong

File: Screen Shot 2017-03-03 at 1.04.24 PM.png (240KB, 728x784px) Image search: [Google]

240KB, 728x784px

>>71367072
this bit always stood out to me

File: steven.png (16KB, 392x246px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 392x246px

>Almost 20 years of career
>Just one album under 6

When /mu/ will admit that porcupine tree is pretty damn good?