Let's be honest, is it actually all THAT good?

>>71156307
I think so. I really love it. It's relatable and you can understand were Rivers is coming from. It's self aware with out being full blown DUDE IRONY LMAO. Also most of the melodies are fantastic.

Yes
/thread

No. Blue is better.

>>71156440
shut up melon

>>71156307
No. Nice album cover but meh album.

>>71156307
Yep

>>71156307
It's fine but I never understood why people claim this is some dark emotional masterpiece. It's just songs about not getting laid. Blue is better.

>>71156307
maladroit is better

It's the best Weezer album but it's not THAT good generally

I literally can't fathom why anyone would think this is better than the debut

>>71157135
this

I love the album for nostalgic reasons but I mean at the end of the day, it's a Weezer album we're talking about here.

>>71156307
it's goodbutnotgreat/10

>>71156307
Nah
>>71156440
This is right, only neckbearded plebs disagree

>>71156307
No. It's not good at all.

The guitar solo on Buddy Holly is the only good thing Weezer have ever put to disc desu

>>71156440
end your life, Pinkerton is obviously better

>>71156440
Only in Dreams is better than all of Pinkerton

>>71156340
>talks about relationships with women and having sex
>relatable

heh, yeah, totally....

Pinkerton > Blue Album.

Shame they only released two albums though. Showed a lot of promise.

>>71156307
Someone praising this album is a red flag that we won't get along. I don't care about how much of a pathetic gross boy you are, take that shit elsewhere and grow up. Some of the arrangements sure are catchy tho, but that's about it.

File: 1478787193179.jpg (36KB, 618x439px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 618x439px

>>71159591
>He thinks Butterfly is a better closer than only in dreams

>>71159646
It's p fucking catchy tho innit

It's not some masterpiece like people make it out to be.
like other anons have said, Blue is better

>>71160111
at times, but it doesn't make up for how uninteresting it is

It's amazing

>>71159591
>what is EWBAITE and white album

>>71156307
No, for once the popular album is actually the best one.

File: 1468050274512.png (431KB, 4000x4000px) Image search: [Google]

431KB, 4000x4000px

>>71159545
only in dreams is their best song

Pretty okay album, it's no fuckin' masterpiece though. I like "El Scorcho", "Why Bother?" and "Pink Triangle" quite a lot, the rest I could take or leave

>>71156307
I really like it, but it's just Cheap Trick for the grunge crowd.

>>71160803
Everything Will be Alright in the End (The 2nd-most-recent Weezer album)
White album is the fourth fucking s/t they've done and the cover has a lot of white so

>>71156307

No, it was a bit underrated at the time of the release, but it's vastly overrated now.
It's a 7/10 album, nothing more.