Who is right?

>>71033879
>take this L
certainly not that faggot.

Eric.
Technical ability has no weight in how good music is

>>71033879
go to bed eric

Josh Shitter...you're fuckin dead kiddo

>>71033879
They're both wrong

File: 1468521763896.jpg (14KB, 262x337px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 262x337px

>take this L

im really surprised that people still give a shit about the amount of skill needed to make certain thing

File: powerslave.jpg (525KB, 1500x1500px) Image search: [Google]

525KB, 1500x1500px

I think Powerslave took quite a bit of skill to make though.

why didn't Josh just call him out on sucking

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GymbC8P5OqI

>>71035061
really makes you think

File: b.png (157KB, 286x295px) Image search: [Google]

157KB, 286x295px

>>71034646
>slows down diana ross track
>LMAO ME MUSICIAN NOW

Eric is right, quality music can be made with little formal skill. But if you make a good product you'd have to be skilled in some way

vaporwave commentary is a gimmick for the mind lol

>>71033915
>Technical ability has no weight in how good music is

[citation needed]

>>71037004
Aren't those two sentences contradictory? Rephrase please

>mozart compose a song but dont write
>create a program that select digital audio file samples values at random and create the audio file
>I am lucky and its that mozart song
>the song is not good because it didnt took skill to create

>>71037253
what album nigga?

>>71037004
what

>>71033879
Lol, your insecurity is showing so much, Eric.

>>71033879
Stop spamming your shit, Eric. You literally spammed me some Sonic shit like a week ago. I know it's you and you're a faggot.

>>71033879
Not you, Josh or Eric.

>>71037032
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xjQajG2P0gg

>>71037043
>>71037343
A lot of people wouldn't consider Merzbow talented, he doesn't really fit under the formal definition of talent. But he's popular and makes some good stuff, so he has to have talent in some sense, just not a traditional one

>>71035915
i mean, its probably more well known and highly regarded than the original song though

>>71038342
are they trolls?

>>71033879
Both are idiots but one knows pretty words. I don't care.

>>71037004
This guy gets it. Formal training doesn't teach one how to fucking destroy someone's soul with emotion. It's something else. One can do said destroying with or without technical prowess. Technical prowess simply adds more tools for a musician, but not every musician needs a toolshed. Some just need a toolbox.

>>71033915
kill yourself

>>71039757
>>71037004
But he made vaporwave

>>71040489
>71040489
So?

File: 1486996531711.png (519KB, 600x580px) Image search: [Google]

519KB, 600x580px

>>71033879
>take this L
eternally BTFO

File: 1485566557362.png (679KB, 768x768px) Image search: [Google]

679KB, 768x768px

>>71033879
Josh sounds like someone who has never attempted to make music.

eric

ITT: people confusing skill with talent

>>71034700
what is this meme