itt: post a bands best album

>>70576703
That's not The Final Cut

>>70577077
lol fuck off

File: 1483583090587.gif (580KB, 267x199px) Image search: [Google]

580KB, 267x199px

>>70576801
>>70576751
2nd best to Discipline imo
>>70576703

Good taste ITT

>>70576703
>>70576751
great taste

>>70576801
more than half of that album is snoozefest

>>70576751
Islands' title track > Starless

>>70577102
>dude talking heads lmao
I like discipline but it is not better than Islands or even Red/LTIA for that matter.
I put discipline and lizard on the same tier but above court and wake
>>70577142
maybe for adhd teens like yourself

>>70577154
I don't know about that anon
Starless is King Crimsons magnum opus
I do like Islands title track a lot though

>>70577191
I undestand it's a controversial statement but it's my genuine opinion.
And it's not like I dislike Starless, it truly is one of their best songs.

>>70576703
>nott Meddle

>>70577245
One decent track: the album

>>70577223
I suppose I'll re listen to it, has been a little while since I have.
>>70577245
You're only saying that because of Echoes, and that song alone does not make it the best
try again, or alternatively just concede that Atom Heart Mother is the best Pink Floyd album and their only actual Progressive Rock album

>>70577268
even if that was true, that one track is better than anything on moo moo record.

>>70577284
AHM Suite > Echoes

>>70577284
have you ever even listened to Atom Heart Mother? it sounds like you haven't

>>70577164
>If you don't enjoy listening to the same guitar riff without a single variation for 15 minutes you have adhd
Your baby's first drone album isn't anything special, get over yourself.

>>70577307
get over yourself

>>70577305
i have, and i quite like the AHM suite, but i would never argue that it is better than meddle.

>>70577324
ya got me

>>70577330
Atom Heart Mother has more memorable songs than Meddle. I genuinely could not tell you how a song that isn't Echoes goes.
Atom Heart Mother is the only PF album that can be classified as prog and only prog
it also happens to be the most interesting album in their discog

>>70577164
Discipline sounds almost nothing like Talking Heads other than Remain in Light, and even then the song structures and guitar tones are completely different

>>70577412
different strokes man. i think it's far less interesting than some stuff they did before, and a lot of the stuff they did after.

>>70577422
you can hear a tremendous RIL influence on Discipline, not that that is a bad thing at all but it isn't their best album.
I liked the stuff Fripp was doing after Red before Discipline more than I like Discipline

>>70577456
To each their own I guess, I generally like new wave more than prog metal

What post Red Fripp do you recommend?

>>70577490
The League of Gentlemen

>>70577490
also, some of the demos with fripp wetton and Phil Collins is really good

File: app.jpg (28KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 300x300px

APP is superior to TAAB

>>70576703
Atom Heart Mother is their best song but not their best album

>>70577767
they're both good but TAAB is really goddamn good

File: front.jpg (29KB, 454x454px) Image search: [Google]

29KB, 454x454px

>>70576703

File: animals.jpg (2MB, 3672x3637px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 3672x3637px

Haha, silly OP, you posted the wrong image! Fixed it for you :)

>>70577268
>One of these Days
>Fearless
>Echoes
Not going to argue the other 2 since these 3 alone could make a perfect album.

>>70576703
ITT: post the most controversial album in a band's discography

>>70577164
literally one song *kind of* sounds like talking heads

>>70580731
best*
sorry you misspelled that

File: bf72f2c8666468da3e797bbb62e277cb.jpg (111KB, 499x781px) Image search: [Google]

111KB, 499x781px

>>70580787
Good taste, I'd have to agree. Station To Station comes really fucking close though

>>70580835
That's runner up for me too. Love Station to Station just as much desu

File: embarrassing.jpg (11KB, 200x235px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 200x235px

>atom heart meme

come the fuck on guys, enough of this shitty contrarian meme album. pink floyd doesn't even like it, stop pretending to like it

>>70581541
It's a really good album, but they have at least 4 better albums

>>70580728
>doesn't mention seamus
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E3ymbCkVTvo

>>70581655
has any other band used dog as an instrument?

>>70581541
>the band doesn't like it so no one should
its their best honestly, they'd have different opinions on it had it sold 40 mil copies

>>70581655
I actually like Seamus. I know it's terrible. But something about it.

>>70576703
That's not Piper...

>>70576703
i agree with you.

though for me, atom heart mother = meddle

>>70576703
>1 great track
>3 okay tracks
>1 godawful track
How the hell is this their best album?

>>70582171
If by best you mean their absolute worst you're correct

>>70582195
because that's better than all of their other albums?

You guys, op posts this all the time and you all take the bait every time without fail.

File: front.jpg (239KB, 1300x1300px) Image search: [Google]

239KB, 1300x1300px

>>70580756
I think what you meant to post was Trans-Europe Express.
>>70577806
That's a funny alternate cover to The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway.
>>70582171
Heh, wow, what a mistake! I'll just post what you meant to post in pic related to save you the trouble.

>>70582297
I do post it a lot but I genuinely believe it