LOL

>>70546427
I have Sasha Fierce as a 4 and s/t as a 6 but other than that he's spot-on for once

did anyone expect him to like her?

>>70546427
I think that's the exact same rating I had for Dangerously in Love, the difference is I never listened beyond that

File: 1484788391797.jpg (65KB, 522x454px) Image search: [Google]

65KB, 522x454px

Don't worry, you can be sure that his opinions have nothing to do with the actual music and are formed purely based on the fact that her albums were made with the help of a long list of collaborators and are consumed by the mass populace.

Beyonce is at least a six but he's right about everything else

>Scaruffi rates an artist that /mu/ dislikes poorly
>SCARUFFI = GOD SCARUFFI = GOD THE FACT THAT

>Scaruffi rates an artist that /mu/ likes poorly
>yeah critics dont matter, all that concerns you is your opinion, etc

Scaruffi is to /mu/ as IGN is to /v/.

don't really care about what he thinks about her in particular
her last 3 albums are good

File: timthumb.jpg (32KB, 200x200px) Image search: [Google]

32KB, 200x200px

>She's a mediocre singer and an awful songwriter, and no amount of production work can fully hide that.
Is Scaruffi racist????

>>70546427
REKT

We're not as desperate for the validation of critics as you seem to be

>>70546427
too high

too high
never cared for beyonces work of art

>>70546427
that makes me feel good

>>70546538
>/v/ uses IGN
Really?

pretty accurate but her body of work is a 7 or 8 desu

>>70546427
Lemonade should be lower

>>70549545
why

>>70547617

>mediocre singer

that's just not true

>>70549592
I guess "boring" singer would've been a better descriptor. Technically proficient, but incredably bland and lowest common denominator pleasing. The best Big Mac in McDonalds.

>>70550296
Totally agree with this

>>70546427
Dangerously in Love is solid R&B though.

I don't understand the appeal behind following a critic that hasn't given anything higher than a 6 in the last 12 years, I really don't get it.

He's I guess more of a meme than he is somebody people take seriously, but the guy just seems bitter and boring, also he's legitimately a pedophile.

File: 1484866589555.png (48KB, 2000x2000px) Image search: [Google]

48KB, 2000x2000px

>tfw scaruffi gives one of your favorite albums a 9/10

>>70550482
>hasn't given anything higher than a 6 in the last 12 years
false

>he's legitimately a pedophile
"legitimately"

>>70549592
It makes it hard to take him seriously when he says something so ignorant. As for songwriting, he doesn't know what she contributed. That last sentence retroactively makes him sound butthurt.

>>70550482

>hasn't given anything higher than a 6 in the last 12 years

not true

>he's legitimately a pedophile.

also not true, he has literally criticized pedophilia

>caring what an old white, probably racist, white guy thinks of Beyoncé

lol

File: IMG_4080.png (2MB, 1334x750px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1334x750px

Are you implying this is better?

https://youtu.be/mkUxFB6jbDc