Who was in the wrong here?

None. Roger is an egomaniac with great song-writing skills and mediocre bass technique. Gilmour was a beautiful son of a bitch with above average guitar skills but can't write a good song to save his life.

Rick Wright was in the right.

>>70464905
>waters
>mediocre bass technique.

but thats wrong. he has lots of lines that are literally iconic rock bass. hes pretty solid.

>>70464843

>>70464905
>Rick Wright was in the right

File: 1480976263542.jpg (34KB, 620x650px) Image search: [Google]

34KB, 620x650px

>forced syd to take lsd despite it fucking with his schizophrenia, just so he could take control of the band
>bullied richard wright to quit the band and get on hard drugs
>deleted david gilmours good take of dogs just to spite him
>tried numerous times to kill david
>wrote a very homophobic, antisemitic, racist song he tried to pass off as deep sophisticated commentary
>believes the great lawful nation of Israel should be destroyed and Sharia law should reign over Western Europe
>pushed nick mason into one of those tar pits in pompeii
>told syd to never show his face again at his sudden reemergence in 75, also stole his wallet
>used syd's royalty income to pay the debts from the failed the wall tour
>exposed richard to constant radiation giving him terminal cancer
>recorded a momentary lapse of reason, but retroactively left the band and blamed everything on david when it received awful reviews

>>70465598
>poisoned our water supply
>burned our crops
>delivered a plague onto our houses

>>70464905
More like Rick Wright was in the cocaine

Roger is one of the greatest song writers in human history and is an amazing bass player.

Gilmour is one of the greatest guitar players in history who writes terrible, terrible songs.

Roger was wrong to tell them they couldn't keep being Pink Floyd without him. The last few albums were essentially his solo albums preformed by Pink Floyd and he was mad Gilmour was going to make his own solo albums preformed by Pink Floyd. He was a hypocrite baby.

>>70465781
Except the last few Roger Floyd albums were actually good ;)

>>70465897
Fair, Animals, The Wall and The Final Cut are unbeliebly better than AMLOR, Div Bell, and TER. Roger was still unfair.

>>70464843
They both were in the wrong.

>>70464905
This guy gets it.

Gilmour is a great technician but he's terrible when it comes down to actually writing songs, Roger is pretty much the opposite, but he went way out of his way to do political stuff because that's just how he is.

Shame really, doesn't help that the best member went fucking crazy.

[spoiler]Also Nick Mason is ringo starr level of bad[/spoiler]

>>70464905
Gilmour sucked in Floyd but some of his solo songs are pretty great

>>70466818
and by sucked, I mean sucked as a songwriter. He is one of my all time favorite guitar players

>>70464843
Roger was talented but he took dictatorial control over the band and tried to fuck them over when he left them. David's not as talented but he tried his damned hardest to keep the band going and going well and seems a nicer bloke.

>>70466864
In terms of talent, who had it more, Syd or Waters?

>>70466845
this

>>70467075
It's not a fair judgment, Syd never even got started. I like to think Syd could have written amazing stuff better than Animals and Meddle but there's really no way of telling.

>>70467206
It's interesting to imagine what the group would have become if he stayed.

The stuff they made would have been radically different.

>>70466789
so what about the fourth guy? Did he just play piano and sing or something. Who wrote the shit on dark side of the moon?

>>70467929
they all contributed to dark side