Post Your Favorite Album and anons Criticize It

>>70447425
It's my favorite album as well
The use of the crescendo to elicit emotion from the listener can be seen as cheap and Godspeed as a band is sort of pretentious.

>>70447425
peaks early

>>70447425
it's not as good as F#A# Infinity

File: Metallica_-_Master_of_Puppets_cover.jpg (117KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

117KB, 300x300px

Hard mode: criticize the album, not the fan base

>>70447425
MUH CRESCENDOS

File: R-368853-1181835194.jpg (83KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

83KB, 600x600px

>>70448031
weak radio metal compared to their previous albums

>>70447425
the hands on the cover aren't fists 0/10

>>70447425
Godspeed is the reason why third wave post rock is so boring. They influenced a whole generation of post-rock musicians to think that reverby guitars + crescendos = good music. I don't hate this album by any means, but I do hate third wave post rock.

>>70447425
if every song was like the first movement it'd be a pretty good album but instead they focus on le epic buildups too much

File: Strawberry_jam_high_res_cover.jpg (83KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

83KB, 500x500px

>>70447425
made all other albums look like trash

>>70448324
I honestly do not see the appeal in this album

>>70448511
Its perfect wp anon, except for Winter Wonderland that track is a bit annoying.

File: Wild_honey_beach_boys.jpg (191KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

191KB, 300x300px

>>70447425
the crescendo doesn't do a very good job of building tension like it should

>>70448324
albini's conscious attempt to drive away listeners (and his lack of shame at being offensive) are very sophomoric posturing to hide that he actually wants to be liked
it's like "you guys only dislike me because i want you to dislike me"

>>70448031
Not as raw as Ride the Lightning, not as refined as AJFA. Worst of both worlds.

>>70448557
i can see that. good observation.

File: im wide awake.jpg (64KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

64KB, 500x500px

>imb4 emo virigin

>>70448663
Doesn't have a unique, notable aesthetic like the releases before it. Pretty standard folk rock.

>>70448686
I understand that but the it wears the folky tune as an aesthetic and all around is more well put together than the others.

File: Swans_To_Be_Kind.jpg (25KB, 658x658px) Image search: [Google]

25KB, 658x658px

>>70447425
Antennas To Heaven has that weird bit where the drums come in and don't sound good

>>70448511
Winter Wonder Land really doesn't fit and Peacebone is kinda dumb

>>70448663
just doesn't sound interesting at all

>>70448801
Some songs drag on for waaaaaaay too long

>>70448958
Forgot to do others

>>70448031
Sounded too refined
>>70447425
No variety >>70448801
Songs drag out, album cover is ugly

>>70448917
that's not the glowing man

>>70448958
infuential, but feels extremely outdated

>>70448663
>>70448663
the sipping, swallowing, and monologue at the beginning anger me and turned me off from the album for a while.

Not really a legitimate criticism just thought I'd get that off my chest

The minecraft soundtrack

Come at me

>>70447425
Sleep fucks up with the guitar part by making it overlong.

File: explosions in the sky - take care.jpg (426KB, 900x900px) Image search: [Google]

426KB, 900x900px

>>70449254
>minecraft soundtrack
I think enough men come at you as it is

>>70447425
>>70448801
Post rock is honestly just a bad genre.
I kind of like To Be Kind though, though that doesn't change the fact.

>>70449444
trips don't lie

>>70448958
protopunk is way too quaint and dated

File: 1nTbK.jpg (314KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

314KB, 1920x1080px

>>70447425
find a flaw

>>70449571
generic noise rock that is just edgy teens with pedals, utter trite, i cant stand this album

>>70449737
where do i start

File: Tortoise-TNT_(album_cover).jpg (42KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 300x300px

>>70447425

>>70448801
It's not The Seer

>>70449822
studio albums only, you're welcome

File: Spiderland.jpg (66KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

66KB, 300x300px

This is gonna hurt

File: 1405232599292.png (328KB, 427x393px) Image search: [Google]

328KB, 427x393px

>>70449571
awful fucking production

File: tvz_forthesake.jpg (176KB, 1654x1476px) Image search: [Google]

176KB, 1654x1476px

>>70449702
Horn

>>70448324
Great first half followed by comparatively mediocre second half, not enough songs like Big Money

>>70449702
It ends

File: Bob_Dylan_-_Blonde_on_Blonde.jpg (141KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

141KB, 300x300px

>inb4 dad or hipster

>>70448958
Way too many soft cuts

>>70449971
It's pretty dated but I love it, afx has a special place in my heart.

>>70450048
dad go to bed

File: Favourite_Worst_Nightmare.jpg (53KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 300x300px

Love all their shit but this is my fav

File: a2633842828_10.jpg (223KB, 1189x1200px) Image search: [Google]

223KB, 1189x1200px

we lost the sea - departure songs

>>70450365
It's milquetoast hipster garbage at its absolute worst. Completely forgettable, mediocre.

File: 2dc4dedbe1f9441c832c26ec70b5704d.png (3MB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1000x1000px

Hard mode: don't call it edgy

Because I'll know you missed the fucking point so hard that you probably shouldn't even bother to try again

File: weighingsouls.jpg (90KB, 700x700px) Image search: [Google]

90KB, 700x700px

>>70450410
ive never heard of this but from the cover it looks like generic post-post-hardcore bs copying circa survive but rly bad ya know

File: Front.jpg (191KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

191KB, 600x600px

>>70447425
Marked the point where post-rock went from genuinely interesting timbre, arrangements and atmospheric composition to DUDE TEN MINUTE LONG BUILDUPS LMAO

>>70448324
The worst thing I can say about it is that it has less of the blistering energy that SAF has on every track

>>70448511
Inconsistent both stylistically and quality-wise
Probably my favorite Animal Collective album though

>>70448801
Ditches The Seer's atmosphere and crazy arrangements for noisy post-rock jams that all sort of blend together after a while

>>70449603
desu like only their 4th best album, maybe 5th

File: Radiohead.amnesiac.albumart.jpg (81KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

81KB, 300x300px

>>70450444
>Because I'll know you missed the fucking point so hard that you probably shouldn't even bother to try again
Holy defensive
Trent uses screaming and reasonable songwriting to cover up the fact that everything he's doing was done earlier by better and more original acts

File: Megadeth-RustInPeace.jpg (173KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

173KB, 300x300px

>>70448031
Sounds too delicate. One of their weakest album.

>>70448324
Too much experimenting

>>70449737
>gorillaz

>>70450672
>Trent uses screaming and reasonable songwriting to cover up the fact that everything he's doing was done earlier by better and more original acts
as edgy as NINposter is, you're definitely not appreciating the subtleties of TDS. it really is a masterpiece imo, and I'm not usually a big fan of rock

>>70450557
i don't like the scream

File: IMG_3163.jpg (180KB, 1205x1200px) Image search: [Google]

180KB, 1205x1200px

>>70448031
Sounds dated as fuck. Which is unfortunate because a lot of the songs aren't bad. And I personally just don't like James Hetfield.
>>70448663
I'm a fan of First Day Of My Life because it's infectiously happy but I hate the overly sappy love lyrics as a whole. Plus the intro track pisses me off for some reason. The first minute is ASMR af and it drives me up the wall.
>>70448801
Not much wrong with this. Some of the songs drag out though, and not in a good way like in Bring The Sun.
>>70448958
The songs with Nico, with the exception of All Tomorrow's Parties, suck balls. Sorry not sorry. She sounds like a tard.
>>70449702
Can't find one. One of the very few albums I'd consider "perfect".
>>70449737
Damon Albarn is incapable of making an album with consistency. Going from Stylo to Superfast Jellyfish, then Empire Ants to Glitter Freeze... it's a fucking rollercoaster. Still one of the best pop albums of this decade though.
>>70449971
I can see the appeal but it bores the shit out of me. I think it's the dated production and the fact that every song sounds quiet.

Rip it a new one.

>>70450747
I actually like TDS a lot. I just think that in a lot of ways it's not as innovative as people seem to claim sometimes.

>>70450907
>Plus the intro track pisses me off for some reason
this
t. >>70449242

>>70450735
Megadeath is just a bad metallica ripoff

File: Foxtrot72.jpg (147KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

147KB, 300x300px

>>70447425
You literally cannot find a flaw.

>>70450444
One of my favorites. The best concept album in my opinion. If I had to complain about something it's Reznor's somewhat irritating vocals/lyrics and the songs in the middle like I Do Not Want This and Ruiner aren't a particular favorite of mine.
>>70450469
No fucking lyrics to be found. Other than that, very good album with very little to critisize.
>>70450672
Has their best song (Pyramid Song) and their worst song (Pulk/Pull). Also lacks consistency. Overall a good album but is overshadowed by Kid A, and rightfully so.
>>70450735
Dave fucking Mustaine

File: KoRn_-_Korn.jpg (84KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

84KB, 500x500px

Let me have it you fucking faggots I'm dead fucking serious. What's wrong with this fucking album.

File: the-who-the-who-sell-out-20130115231842.jpg (363KB, 640x640px) Image search: [Google]

363KB, 640x640px

>mfw nobody can find a flaw because nobody on /mu/ has listened to this album

File: igetwetigetwetigetwetigetwetigetwetigetwet(igetwet).jpg (79KB, 1200x630px) Image search: [Google]

79KB, 1200x630px

For obvious reasons.

File: front.jpg (182KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

182KB, 500x500px

give it to me straight, doc

>>70448324
Can't say anything honestly bad about this album, ain't gonna diss one of my top 10

>>70449857
this

>>70451106
Amnesiac lacking consistency is valid but
>worst song (Pulk/Pull)
what the fuck

>>70451171
embarrassing post, friend

>>70449904
much respect.

>>70449904
this album sometimes makes me feel like I'm at a renaissance fair. I don't dig that.

File: IMG_1325.jpg (60KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

60KB, 600x600px

Can't Flay the Jai

File: endtroducing-1.jpg (102KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

102KB, 1000x1000px

I honestly havent listened to like half the albums in here

File: pm.jpg (16KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 480x360px

>>70448958
Nico can't sing for shit, and the whole album feels like it was made to be 2deep4u on purpose.

>>70449603
The beginning of Sabbath's decline musically. Overproduced, with bland shit like Embryo and Lord of This World making the cut.

>>70450444
Lazy and uninspired. And the worst part is that Reznor has shown he can do way better, so he either didn't give a fuck or was too shit at music at the time to realize.

>>70451119
Apart from the fact that it's a shitty album, it also was a crucial factor in the start of nu-metal, and for that you should be ashamed.

>>70451505
Inconsistent with some of Modest Mouse's best songs but also Long Distance Drunk and Jesus Christ Was an Only Child
also Trucker's Atlas drags on a bit

>>70448031
>>70450735
Both of these have the same problem of being mediocre follow-ups to strong first albums. You can tell the bands started to struggle with writing new stuff and keeping up the intensity, and the sound reflects it.

>>70449737
Everything that Demon Days did right this one did wrong. No consistency in either tone or quality, shit is all over the place, with most of the songs being barely radio filler tier.

>>70449971
A couple of solid and memorable tracks that are drowning in a sea of forgettable, mediocre electronica.

>>70451139
Has exactly one good track (I Can See For Miles) and a bunch of uninspired, boring Beatles rip-offs.

>>70447425
The First Song is too good. Nothing else really reaches its size.

>>70449571
I tried listening and then didn't

File: rusty.jpg (895KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

895KB, 1000x1000px

>>70447425

>>70452081
>anything on TWSO
>a Beatles rip-off

>>70448031
Only good song is Battery

>>70451675
>actually considering field recordings of people screaming to be your "favorite album"
this is either bait or you need to stop trying so hard to stand out

File: IMG_1959.jpg (254KB, 795x800px) Image search: [Google]

254KB, 795x800px

>>70449571
Bad band, weak album

>>70449603
Weak

>>70449847
8/10

>>70449971
Techno bores me but the album is good

>>70450410
Generic post rock

>>70450735
Not many interesting spots

>>70450907
8/10

>>70451119
Luv

>>70451463
Boring but good

>1 hour
>nobody has found a flaw in my favorite album yet
Good to know I made the right choice.

File: a2972495352_10 copy.jpg (438KB, 1200x1200px) Image search: [Google]

438KB, 1200x1200px

deadsullivan.bandcamp.com

>>70452659
What can I say, I like harsh noise. It's sort of a toss-up between this, As Loud As Possible and Pulse Demon as my top album, and PM wins out due to the mood.

>>70452789
Or it's so forgettable that nobody gives enough of a fuck to criticize it.

>>70453027
Even better, that's how I know my album is pleb-proof.

>>70447992
this.

>>70453049
Now you can rest easy knowing your favorite album is special snowflake certified and hipster approved.

File: pulp.jpg (581KB, 940x940px) Image search: [Google]

581KB, 940x940px

>>70447425
Doesn't end in Monheim.
>>70448031
Kill 'Em All and Ride the Lightning are better.
>>70448511
Filler.
>>70448663
Emo virgin.
>>70448801
Only Nathalie Neal Deserves a 10.
>>70448958
Nico.
>>70449603
Their best. Nothing to say here.
>>70449702
> find a flaw
I can't.
>>70449870
The instrumental.
>>70450048
Dad or hipster.
>>70449971
Boring.
>>70450444
> don't call it edgy
I like it anon, and if you don't allow me to call it edgy, I have nothing to say
>>70450469
No lyrics. And that ends up being annoying if you know the guy is saying something.
>>704506728
Inconsistent.
>>70450735
Only first listens are good, doesn't have the same replay as Peace Sells.
>>70450907
I don't know, some of the tracks just don't impresse me.
>>70451064
Not all tracks are even a 9 (still, damn good).
>>70451119
Oh god... leave it to this guy: >>70451675
>>70451139
I did, quite boring sometimes. Still their best.
>>70452695
I Ain't Superstitious is terrible.

>>70453306
>not all tracks are even a 9
Oh, come on, Time Table is not bad. Even if it were, it'd be more than made up for by Can-Utility.

>>70453573
All tracks are good, but not all of them are great, some are "just good".

File: plsnobully.jpg (1MB, 900x900px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 900x900px

Completely unironically my favorite album.

>>70453714
Is Jesus Christ completely unironically your favorite deity?

>>70453787
No, but I do love the song.

File: 0be0be65_beta-band1.jpg (130KB, 400x400px) Image search: [Google]

130KB, 400x400px

FIght me

>>70449702

Every song sounds the same

File: MyBloodyValentineLoveless.jpg (67KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

67KB, 300x300px

Obligatory. Has meant so much to me for so long.

File: Daft-Punk-Discovery-1000x1000.png (1MB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1000x1000px

1v1 me

>>70451463
Listened to this album falling asleep so many times until "MIDNIGHT MIDNIGHT MIDNIGHT MIDNIGHT"
Why..
>>70451141
Fun album but nothing more.
>>70451119
I regret listening to this in middle school. Music that I cringe looking back on.
>>70450444
Music that I listened to in middle school/HS and don't regret but just can't do it anymore. Great album though.
>>70449971
Never could get into it like Vol. 2. Struck me as generic electronica.
>>70449737
Loved it. Best Gorillaz album in my opinion.

File: Mingus_Ah_Um_-_Charles_Mingus.jpg (110KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

110KB, 300x300px

This, my 2nd is either hot rats or the new standard (by my nikka herbie)

File: Trollfest_Brumlebassen.jpg (102KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

102KB, 500x500px

fite me

File: Tom_Waits_-_Rain_Dogs.png (46KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

46KB, 300x300px

>>70448958
overrated, pretentious and the bad tracks outnumber the good.
>>70450365
inferior to the first, lyrically turner tried way too hard.
>>70451505
could be a 10/10 if not for a couple of terrible tracks.
>>70453306
jarvis cocker.

>>70454382
Tom Waits.

>>70454206
not kaptein kaos

>>70454382

Tom Waits was influenced by Beefheart, who is trash

File: 51dwDUkgLHL.jpg (38KB, 499x500px) Image search: [Google]

38KB, 499x500px

>>70447425
hehehe we are le leftists and love crescendos
>>70448511
"what if we did regular pop songs but were LOL SO RANDOM"
>>70448663
"i'm sad and you should be sad too"
>>70449702
it isn't a double album


i love these albums though, i'm just jokin' around

Bear in mind I consider a few of these albums to be in my top 20 at least.

>>70449702
Pretty similar sounding songs. They're great songs, but still.

>>70449870
Occasionally meanders a little bit.

>>70449971
The only flaw I can think of is that the rhythms can fall into 4-on-the-floor at times but it's innovative enough that it's forgivable

>>70450048
Not one of the best vocal performances of Dylan's career, imho.

>>70450444
One or two cringeworthy lyrics, but one of my favorite albums as well.

>>70451143
Never saw the appeal of this. Pretty generic post-hardcore.

>>70453714
I love this album, but I can't deny that the lyrics aren't sometimes intentionally obtuse.

>>70454032
they just repeated other peoples music over and over lmao

>>70450444
Tront's weak ass fucking voice.

File: 220px-TheMoonAntarctica (1).jpg (9KB, 220x220px) Image search: [Google]

9KB, 220x220px

>>70447425

>>70454029
>S h o e g a z e

File: After_the_Gold_Rush.jpg (36KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 300x300px

try it fuckers

>>70455133
Love this album but if I had to criticise it, it'd be the lack of energy. Tried to be too arty when all you want from Modest Mouse is thrashing guitar recorded in a garage.

>>70455228
eh, I gotta say my favorite modest mouse bits are the long drony parts,

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xBjiYZiv5RE
Is a great example

File: 3821503.jpg (20KB, 300x269px) Image search: [Google]

20KB, 300x269px

>>70447425
lmao faggots try me

>>70455416
too sad
cheer up faggot

File: 91sqAJFwmJL._SL1400_.jpg (895KB, 1400x1400px) Image search: [Google]

895KB, 1400x1400px

Hard mode: no "dude weed lmao"

>>70455454
> no "dude weed lmao"
Then why even try?

>>70455374
Never really liked Cowboy Dan whereas it seems to be one of the very top songs for other fans, in fact half of the album is meh to me.

Different tastes though.

File: front.png (729KB, 590x590px) Image search: [Google]

729KB, 590x590px

>>70453707
Some of the songs go on a bit too long and the attempt to cover so many genres makes it feel a bit gimmicky

Good album though

File: 098.jpg (13KB, 249x249px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 249x249px

>>70452543
Literally just Spiderland but not as good

File: packshot.jpg (119KB, 550x550px) Image search: [Google]

119KB, 550x550px

Best of album. Pavement. I know I suck, and I honestly don't care. Frontwards is my favorite song of all time.

>>70455586
Too stupid of an album for me to take seriously. "The Butthole Surfers" are too stupid of a band overall. I really just can't enjoy an music that is supposed to be "funny" like this. Same reason I don't like Zappa.

>>70455815
enjoy an album*

File: 61Uxg-SWExL._SL1500_.jpg (94KB, 1500x1491px) Image search: [Google]

94KB, 1500x1491px

here we go

File: cover.jpg (397KB, 1500x1500px) Image search: [Google]

397KB, 1500x1500px

>>70447425
mastering sounds muted and flat

>>70449571
the guitar that opens teenage riot is ugly and sounds like cheese.

>>70455416
musically boring, like a paint by numbers.

>>70455993
bloated asf

>>70450735
I was about to post that album as well... Seriously solid.

File: Screenshot_2017-01-19-04-33-22.png (1MB, 720x1280px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 720x1280px

>>70456080
Guess I'll have to go with my second favorite.

>>70447425
not even the best godspeed album lmoa

File: images.jpg (13KB, 240x210px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 240x210px

Be nice it's her birthday

>>70451119
The vocals. The other aspects of the album are amazing but the vocals are so edgy and lifeless.

File: year_zero_art.jpg (42KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 500x500px

Best NIN albumin my eyes

Hard mode:
No
>murr politics
,>bush
>edgy

>>70456119
All the songs are only good for about thirty seconds, the vocals just try to sound like Atheist but don't fit the context whatsoever, uninteresting guitar tone...

>>70456229
Forgot to rate.

>>70455938
Disco xD
>>70455993
>Muh comic books
>>70455454
I remember I hated this record at first because of how "poppy" and perfectly produced it was.

>>70455133
lol planets and stuff
>>70454032
This one is actually perfect
>>70453714
Oh comely sucks. The lyrics are fucking weird sometimes, like fetus and semen stains the mountaintops and shit. Overall creepy lyrics
>>70454029
Only shallow is the only interesting song
>>70451463
Some tracks are boring. There are a number of standout tracks though, solid album.
>>70450672
it's Kid B
>>70450365
Literally sucks except for like 2 songs
>>70449971
Xtal is the best song, it just gets worse after
>>70449737
Every song after Empire Ants except for On Melancholy Hill and To Binge suck ass
>>70449702
Some of the songs are forgettable
>>70448958
Only has like 4 good songs
>>70448511
Winter Wonderland and Unsolved Mysteries suck

>>70448557
I love Wild Honey but why on earth do you like it more than Pet Sounds?

File: Hotel-California-cover.jpg (366KB, 1336x1336px) Image search: [Google]

366KB, 1336x1336px

Hotel California (1976)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jFi2ZM_7FnM&list=PLQ1TJFl_7jjKJwJNc5t8918qggrrzUZa0

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y0d53KUlTN8&index=2&list=PLQ1TJFl_7jjKJwJNc5t8918qggrrzUZa0

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rwYU8jq6Qw0&index=3&list=PLQ1TJFl_7jjKJwJNc5t8918qggrrzUZa0

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZdOptEJk0K8&index=4&list=PLQ1TJFl_7jjKJwJNc5t8918qggrrzUZa0

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dVONBU2UWbo&index=5&list=PLQ1TJFl_7jjKJwJNc5t8918qggrrzUZa0

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1GbMIxrxT0w&index=6&list=PLQ1TJFl_7jjKJwJNc5t8918qggrrzUZa0

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ffBPxEO5vHQ&index=7&list=PLQ1TJFl_7jjKJwJNc5t8918qggrrzUZa0

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yNnH1sN0dw8&index=8&list=PLQ1TJFl_7jjKJwJNc5t8918qggrrzUZa0

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hdx6oyBOVj0&index=9&list=PLQ1TJFl_7jjKJwJNc5t8918qggrrzUZa0

>>70451505
I like you.

>>70449737
Not as good as Demon Days.

File: eagles2.jpg (312KB, 1100x719px) Image search: [Google]

312KB, 1100x719px

>>70456501
Might I add
>inb4 guitars out the ass

I'm well aware of this.

>>70450672
>>70450735
>>70451119
>>70451171
>>70452695
>>70453714
>>70454029
>>70454032
>>70454206
>>70455416
>>70455454
>>70455938
>>70455993
>>70456119
>>70456501

meme Tier

File: 61APrHt5bsL.jpg (65KB, 500x452px) Image search: [Google]

65KB, 500x452px

endless comfy

>>70449971

Most uninteresting of his albums

>>70450444

Not that I dislike the album but Trent has a horrible singing voice

>>70456405

>Oh comely sucks. The lyrics are fucking weird sometimes, like fetus and semen stains the mountaintops and shit. Overall creepy lyrics

Entirely missing the point and the best track on the album. How?

File: helios - erebus.jpg (48KB, 350x350px) Image search: [Google]

48KB, 350x350px

>>70447425
sleep is a pretty shit track up until 9:23
final track is forgettable
and this >>70447992

>>70451171
TLS is in a pretty awkward position chronologically. With it coming out after Heroes instead of before, it just feels like Heroes-lite which makes it rather disappointing despite being just as good, if not better, than most of their other albums.

>>70454032
the last 3 tracks are pretty meh and too long is exactly that

>>70455938
get lucky wasn't cut. Other than that I got nothing

this isn't my end all be all "fav album", but keeping w/ OP's theme it's my favorite by GIAA

NO ONE EVER JUDGES MY FAVORITE ALBUM REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE WHY DO I GET NO (you)'s REEEEEEEEEEEEE

File: 1483546910527.jpg (40KB, 500x456px) Image search: [Google]

40KB, 500x456px

>>70457982

>>70457982
means you posted a flawless one

File: 200px-ABBA_Gold_Greatest_Hits.jpg (5KB, 200x200px) Image search: [Google]

5KB, 200x200px

Unironically this

File: Deloused.jpg (14KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 480x360px

Anyone else?

>>70458002
>>70458027
Thank you for the (you)'s, since I'm Australian this sustains my existence.

>>70458043
Mum, stop posting on 4chan.

File: AFI.jpg (78KB, 600x472px) Image search: [Google]

78KB, 600x472px

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pnrPGtgCThw

>>70458142
>Australian
oh stop it anon, I have an Aussie fetish that can't just be quenched by my Aussie bf

>>70458309
ayyyt bb as long as I get some more (you)'s I can be whateva ya want me to be

File: CurtainsFrusciante.jpg (30KB, 500x503px) Image search: [Google]

30KB, 500x503px

There is literally not one fault in this album

File: Modest_Mouse-The_Lonesome_Crowded_West-Frontal.jpg (83KB, 608x608px) Image search: [Google]

83KB, 608x608px

>>70458081 10/10 that album flows perfectly and ends so powerfully.

>>70456845
cool

File: horses-cover_custom-95bd29494bd12ecab828302378aa305f62fb5ccf-s900-c85.jpg (114KB, 900x900px) Image search: [Google]

114KB, 900x900px

Hard mode: Nothing about her being a "strong woman".

>>70459856
The record isn't entirely consistent at all but that only adds to the charm imo, it's a 10/10 for me.

File: tqid.jpg (92KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

92KB, 600x600px

Truly a masterpiece.

>>70451698
cucks

>>70448436
Gathering Storm is the biggest "epic buildup" on the album, what are you on about?

File: everything everything.jpg (114KB, 750x750px) Image search: [Google]

114KB, 750x750px

it's impossible

>>70461711
The first two movements of 2112 are alright but sitting through the second half is nowhere as fun as the first. Hemispheres does the format so much better than 2112

I do like all the other tracks though

>>70447425
The beginning of the end for Post-Rock.
>>70448031
Songs sound the same, and in a bad way.
>>70448324
Predictable song-writing patterns.
>>70448557
>Pop Music
>>70448801
Drone done bad.
>>70448958
Pop camouflaged as some sort of "Avant-Garde" hallmark.
>>70449223
Weaker than Yerself Esteem, which was already bad.
>>70449571
Indie Pop.
>>70449603
>>70449702
Not memorable.
>>70449737
>Gorillaz
>>70449847
It comes off as too friendly sometimes.
>>70449870
Repetitive formula, should have stayed explore more, as in Don, Aman.
>>70449971
Pop Electronic.
>>70450048
Not enough variation or exploration for a double album.
>>70450444
Too predictable, as well.
>>70450557
>Rap
>>70450672
Pop pretending to be what it's not.
>>70450735
All sounds the same.
>>70450907
Good, but cheesy at times.
>>70451064
Epitome of generic prog.
>>70451119
Gets weaker and weaker as the songs go by,
>>70451463
>Hip Hop
>>70451505
>Pop.
>>70451698
>"It's supposed to be bad!"
>>70452543
Trying to sound hardcore but failing.
>>70452565
>Ska
>>70452695
Generic
>>70453707
>le eclecticism but it's not
>>70453714
Bad songwriting
>>70454029
Too poppy
>>70454032
Electronic music for plebs.
>>70454204
Too samey.
>>70454382
Lots of weak tracks.
>>70455133
>Pop
>>70455454
>Pop
>>70455586
Le quirk
>>70455938
Pleb Electronic.
>>70455993
>Hip Hop
>>70456229
Pop for people who try to pretend they don't like pop.
>>70456268
Awful singing.
>>70458043
>Mom-Pop
>>70458081
Awful production AND singing.
>>70460191
Le proto-punk but it's not
>>70460236
Just overrated pop.
>>70461711
Decline of prog.
>>70461736
For some reason acclaimed pop.

>>70461812
>lol XD I don't listen to pop music thats for blevs xddd

File: sonicyouthgoo.png (504KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

504KB, 1000x1000px

Make me cry

>>70447425
Relies too much on non-music and spoken samples to generate atmosphere (I love the album, by the way)
>>70448031
It's mid-tier thrash even by 1986 standards; the teutonic bands' output of the time sweep it under the floor; production's fucked
>>70448324
Albini
>>70448511
>DUDE DRUGS AND NOISES LMAO
>>70448958
Overrated, the extent to which it pushed boundaries is extremely overplayed by hindsight and its association with Warhol-- it REALLY wasn't THAT groundbreaking. Also Reed doing a gay voice. Cale's the man, though.
>>70449571
Jesus & Mary Chain's Darklands and other noisy alt-rock bands of the era did it a hundred times better, yet people still call this a noise(???) rock masterpiece?
>>70449737
The last third of the album drags on, and the closer is utterly inadequate. Should have ended with Cloud Of Unknowing. Also Reed doing a gay voice
>>70449971
Could have been shorter, and production's a bit flat
>>70450444
U N O R I G I N A L
R I P O F F
S H I T
>>70451119
If Godflesh and Pantera had a retarded gay baby
>>70451139
The skits get annoying and seem to be a distraction for the album's lack of cohesiveness or strong compositions
>>70451463
Babby's first turntablism is "first" for a reason: It's unrefined as fuck
>>70454032
What the fuck were they thinking when they recorded Face To Face AND TOO LONG
>>70452565
2-Tone Lite for Undiscerning American Audiences
>>70453306
The singles overshadow the album, which in turns overshadows their best album, which is His 'n' Hers
>>70454029
There was no need for Touched to exist
>>70454460
Doesn't sound different enough from Emperor Tomato Ketchup, and Refractions In The Plastic Pulse drags on just a bit too much
>>70455165
Previosu and following album are much better, yet that one gets all the praise
>>70455416
The New Blockaders used that cover first in 1983, and that cover is pretty much the sole reason that borefest gets any attention
>>70455454
Still riding on the coattails of Revolver and Spacemen 3

>>70462009
Standard Heavy Metal revival covered up in layers and layers of sticky sugary gimmicks and overproduction: The Kids swallowed it whole
>>70461711
Ayn Rand
>>70460236
Needs more songs like The Boy With The Thorn In His Side; needs less songs like Frankly, Mr. Shankly
>>70460191
Average Stooges worship peddled up because of muuuhh gurl powah
>>70456841
The following three albums deserve all the praise it gets. It's a bit samey at times
>>70456268
Roy Harper's Stormcock gets kidnapped by a cat-eating harp; all the depth replaced with clever wordplay
>>70456229
D.I. Go Pop-Lite for Undiscerning American Audiences
>>70455938
French House ensemble tries really, REALLY hard to sound like a hard rock band's videogame soundtrack AGAIN
>>70456375
Nine Inch Nails is 100% depreciable
>>70462171
Do Make Say Think-Lite for Undiscerning American Audiences

File: ocean-machine-biomech-569fcc4aaffe9.jpg (323KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

323KB, 1000x1000px

>>70448031
Production could have had more edge like AJFA. It's too smooth to sound heavier that what they did in RTL but the songwriting is on point, though the length can become a turn off.

>>70448958
Overrated, pretentious and outdated.

>>70449603
Some songs aren't bad but you can tell they're filler, but overall it doesn't have any criminal flaws.

>>70449971
Has some filler moments, production can feel a bit dated.

>>70450444
Overall a pretty good album, has some edgy/cringy lyrical moments but given the context it can be a passable flaw. Production is on fucking point tho.

>>70450735
Solid songwriting, performance and production wise but Lucretia, Poison Was The Cure and My Creation are flat compared to any of the other tracks.

>>70451675
meme

>>70452695
Production can feel dated but overall it's great. This and So Far, So Good... So What! I consider to be their best work.

>>70454029
Overrated but a good album nonetheless. Some tracks make you wanna sleep tho.

>>70455938
Production is awesome but some moments are brickwalled. Some songs are filler but overall solid, fun tracks.

>>70462009
As close as they've ever come to perfection. Has the quirkiness and danger that the first one had and made it evolve in a great way.

File: IMG_1265.jpg (143KB, 400x400px) Image search: [Google]

143KB, 400x400px

>Hard mode: no "jeff's voice is annoying" or "the guitar playing is basic"

>>70462347
O V E R P R O D U C E D
O V E R T L Y L A Y E R E D
Songs are mediocre at best. Should have ended his career then and there.

>>70462347
Life is one of the worst songs I've ever heard

>>70455941
what album is that?

>>70462119
>>70462237
>>70462347
hahahahahahaa all these buzzwords, Daydream Nation a Jesus and the Mary Chain rip-off? Patti Smith's Horses being even close to the repetitive noise jams of the Stogges? Get out man.

>>70462883
>;_;

File: theblacksaintandthesinnerlady.jpg (431KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

431KB, 1000x1000px

good luck

>>70462933
Rockist pseudojazz

>>70462388

Two Headed Boy is a shit track

>>70463059
>And now let's listen to Roger Waters cry about his daddy for an hour and a half!

>>70463080

There is only one song about his dad you fucking retard

>>70462889
>failing this hard at posturing on an anonymous furry shoujo porn board
Most of your opinions were just uninformed and stupid, it doesn't matter if you try to sound condescending, it makes you look like an utter tool. No one that ever listened to Devin "overproduced cheesy hack" Townsend will ever be in the position to decide about good taste so good luck buddy.

>>70463059
> Hey, I'm Roger Waters. This album is called "My father died in war Pt.1 / War is bad!"
Other name for that album is "Filleer - The Album"

>>70463121
The whole album stems from absent father figure and abusive mommy issues; are you illiterate?

>>70462944
>third stream
>rockist
you are fucking retarded

>>70463148
https://sleepbellumsonno.bandcamp.com/album/judge-us-by-how-we-lived-our-lives-not-by-how-we-made-our-living

File: 758.jpg (48KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

48KB, 300x300px

Extremely difficult choice for me, but probably pic related.

>>70463228
>that album title
even if you aren't shilling your own band, this is cheesy and you should be ashamed of yourself

>>70463253
there are specific threads for "shilling".

This is my favorite album of all time.

>>70463251
A Fine Day to Die and Blood Fire Death are perfect, everything else is a little weak. Anyway, a 9/10 overall.

>>70449671
it's not a proto punk album though

>>70455941
Kinoko Teikoku is my shit. Always love when I see them

>>70448511
They kept #1

>>70463166
That's one of the rockiest "jazz" albums along with Bitches Brew and A Love Supreme. The fact that it's third stream only makes it even worse

File: luaetc.jpg (110KB, 1500x1500px) Image search: [Google]

110KB, 1500x1500px

>>70450644
relies way too much on that pretty girl
>>70459856
well this one's perfect
>>70455133
bad cover.i'm posting the good one

>>70460236
>>70460236
Morrissey has a fucking annoying shitty voice that is even made worse by his politics and the times he tries to be all theatrical and shit in hus singing.
Also instrumentals are ok but nothing great, I'd rather listen to some other jangle or twee band for that.
And the fanbase is the fucking worst.
God i really hate the fucking Smiths

>>70447425
The first 7 minutes are 10/10

>>70453714
I'm sorry you like meme music :(

>>70449242
I listened to the whole album, but seriously this. The intro instantly made me dislike the album and I ended not enjoying the rest except for Road to Joy.

>>70464931
Obvious newfag

>>70451675
What in the holy name of fuck is wrong with you

File: 3b8604297c0a8382812f66778ace7397.1000x1000x1.jpg (65KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

65KB, 1000x1000px

Hard mode: don't mention cop shoot cop

File: QOTSA...likeClockworkfrontpop.jpg (116KB, 570x577px) Image search: [Google]

116KB, 570x577px

Hard mode: don't mention If I Had a Tail

>>70456501
WELL BABY THERE YOU STAND

>>70448324
The mastering on anything other than the vinyl pressing is unlistenable

>>70451698
The second half hits so hard it makes the first half feel weak

File: Unsilent Death.jpg (185KB, 1171x1200px) Image search: [Google]

185KB, 1171x1200px

Hardmode: No "2edgy4u" or anthony memetano posts

>>70465336
camera eye is the weakest of all longer rush tracks

>>70466244
Powder Blue had to be cut down because of legal issues

File: Wormrot-Voices.jpg (219KB, 700x700px) Image search: [Google]

219KB, 700x700px

unironically my favourite grind album

anthony cucktano can suck my knob

File: milesduke_sq-fd60ce1c1ec6276df2ee02e288bb79e6353c8227.jpg (113KB, 948x948px) Image search: [Google]

113KB, 948x948px

>>70449603
Great album, but I much preferred the more bluesy sound of the first two.

>>70450469
Used to love it but honestly it all sounds the same to me now. The drum machine sounds kinda cheap as well. Still good though.

>>70453714
Bland, horrible vocals. Never understood the hype around this album.

>>70454382
Not a fan of the ballads.

>>70456268
The melodies aren't very memorable imo.

>>70460236
Morrissey

>>70449847
Shit cover but it's in my top 5 right now. Overall I just love Tortoise

>>70465901
...cop shoot cop is great though why would someone mention it as criticism

>>70465942
if I had a tail is the best song on the album

>>70466227

>Nuclear Blast

>>70449870
The fucking spoken word sections.

>>70465685
More generic than the ST and number of the beast and has worse production than any before no prayer.
Literally the worst 80's maiden album.

>>70466786
lmao wat

File: beyondcontrol.jpg (770KB, 1600x1600px) Image search: [Google]

770KB, 1600x1600px

I thought it was going to be a crappy Christian album but it turned out to be my favorite album from last year

>>70451675
>Apart from the fact that it's a shitty album, it also was a crucial factor in the start of nu-metal, and for that you should be ashamed.
Nice opinions faggot but I don't see a legitimate criticism anywhere in there

>>70453306
>Oh god... leave it to this guy
see>>70468127

>>70447484
Every aingle detail in yhe way they use crescendos is perfectly mastered though

>>70451119
I find that it's often hard for people to actually criticize this album without looping back around to "well it's nu metal so it's shit". People hate it because they're told to hate it, or they think it's juvenile which might be somewhat legitimate but it isn't like the emotion behind the music isn't genuine, Jonathan Davis got raped and shit. It's actually pretty good, easily the best thing to come out of the scene.

Just because you say I'm not allowed to call it boring doesn't make it not bland and boring
Only good if you like sitting around in darkness self loathing and crying

You might be insecure

>>70447425
The noisy end portion of Static is boring and goes on too long. It should have ended after the crescendo.

>>70448958
>what a clon

>>70453080
an album of good ideas

File: image.jpg (42KB, 220x220px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 220x220px

Judge me

>>70453902
The Monolith
Some of the production sounds way too lo fi and a bit dated.
Great album otherwise.

>>70448801
Do you know that feel when you're listening to TBK and after a while you start thinking "hmm this is actually getting quite boring and repetitive" and then Oxygen comes on and suddenly you're jumping in the air waving your arms around screaming: "I'L STEAL ALL THE OXYGEN" and it makes your day for a week?

>>70458081
The UK version contains a terrible "bonus track", when Cerpin Taxt is the PERFECT closer,

>>70464483
It's too nice.

>>70465901
Electricity is corny as fuck. Sounds like oasis and actually opens with this lyric:
>"Driving fast down a one-way street"
WTF
The only thing keeping this from being 10/10. Cop Shoot Cop is the best track on there.

File: MI0001567975.jpg (44KB, 400x396px) Image search: [Google]

44KB, 400x396px

best album of the 90s to be honest family

>>70462388
Poorly recorded, produced and mastered incoherent ramblings of mental patient somehow ends up portrayed as classic by jaded unqualified music critics and meme-bated ever virgins despite band best efforts not to participate in the creation.

>>70461812
>Pop pretending to be what it's not
That's exactly what makes Amnesiac so good

>>70468769
For Martha should've been cut.

>>70466321
There's a lot of filler and the production + lyrical themes often feel too repetitive.

>>70450735
Half of tracks are pretty good or interesting, half are meh or boring. Also sometimes Mustaine's nasal voice doesn't fit the darkness of the lyrics, which BTW aren't really good except in a couple of songs.

>>70448663
I personally don't enjoy first day of my life, but that's because i like Conor's sad and sometimes bitter lyrics. But maybe that's because of the point of my life in which i am, and will like the track in a bright future.

>>70449254
it's actually quite nice for the game, it gives it a chill vibe

>>70468769
It's good until Shame, which is a great track but drags for too long. Then the next series of sentimental long winded ballads aren't bad, but all put together and one after the other happen to kill the flow of the album and nearly put you to sleep

>>70467062
The song can feel a little samey and aren't memorable apart from the lyrics

>>70460236
Vicar in a Tutu is meh

>>70456375
Songwriting is a little bit meh sometimes (I mean, c'mon, Capital G is as lackluster or even more than the worst tracks from With Teeth). The production is good but nowhere near the level of TDS/TF. The aesthetic of a dystopian future is quite well accomplished but not that well (except on The Greater Good, that track's immersive as fuck)

>>70455454
Trevor's wimpy voice + the constant wash of synths get tiring sometimes. Plus some melodies are pretty corny and the aforementioned aspects do nothing but amplifying the corniness.

>>70461812
call everything pop lmao there ya go also hating an entire genre like why

File: Frances_the_Mute.png (147KB, 318x313px) Image search: [Google]

147KB, 318x313px

Hit me up senpai

>>70454032
Has some very good tracks but some forgettable ones as well, quite a few are dull or repetive. Some samples and the heavy autotune can get annoying. I like the aesthetic and overall sound of Justice's debut a lot more desu
>>70454029
The lyrics are a bit too cryptic and sometimes feel irrelevant to the overall feeling of the songs. Also the fact that the vocals are so buried in the mix doesn't help at all.

File: the smashing pumpkins -SiameseDreamHighRes.jpg (2MB, 1200x1188px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1200x1188px

Hard mode: no criticizing Corgan's voice

>>70471192
It's too perfect

>>70468748
Put the trip back on, faggot

File: 4L_hWzHTywi.jpg (137KB, 900x900px) Image search: [Google]

137KB, 900x900px

>>70447425

>>70454382
Nightmare before Christmas goofy fucking vocals

>>70453306
anyone who doesn't like washer doesn't understand why spiderland is a post rock album and not just a mathy slowcore album

>>70461497
have you even heard world police and friendly fire? also i'm talking about the movement before that dipshit

>>70451443
Only flaw: he hasn't realeased an album yet

>>70456354
What are you talking about? That was Jonathan's best vocal performance of is career. No other Korn album compares when it comes to his vocals. They're so raw and tormented.

>>70454382
Ron Perlman doing a Daffy Duck impression with a skeleton playing a marimba for music.

File: hqdefault.jpg (22KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

22KB, 480x360px

>>70472558
Bait
>>70471192
Reminds me of being a dorky kid with no friends 2/10
>>70467062
Kinda samey tbqh.

I love how post-rock this thread is.

File: wew.jpg (49KB, 400x400px) Image search: [Google]

49KB, 400x400px

>>70468441
hm, I quite like that album. I don't think they did enough with some of the songs. The sound gets stale
>>70472558
epic!
>>70471014
easily worse than DeLoused.
>>70458081
The lyrics are cryptic to the point of being a turn off (to some, not me)

>>70471014
I feel that the ambient portions outstay their welcome

File: R-2907770-1405120134-4681.jpeg.jpg (96KB, 600x583px) Image search: [Google]

96KB, 600x583px

>>70447425

>>70461812
>Epitome of generic prog.
Not sure why I expected any more from this shitpost.

>>70472564
The opener is a pleb filter that tends to scare people away