Will it even be topped?

By the Pumpkins? Nah. By other artists? Oh, it's been done a ton of times.

>>70354901
Name 10 records. Oh btw the Downward Spiral sucked.

File: The_Smashing_Pumpkins_-_MCIS_-_reissue_cover.jpg (68KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

68KB, 500x500px

>>70354887
It has been.

File: 3542621.jpg (372KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

372KB, 600x600px

>>70354988
Billy's influences>Billy

>>70355207
Not that anon but Loveless predates Siamese Dream. Name 10 post-1993 rock albums that are better than Siamese Dream.

>>70355207
walls of fuzz and loveless are not the same thing

>>70355248
He's talked about his my bloody valentine inspiration extensively. Although it was mainly from you made me realize.

>>70355295
I think there's thematic similarities in the lyrics too. Loomer and Soma at the top of my head.

my mom says tyheres a lot of black people in africa

It's a bit of a pointless question asking for something that 'tops' it, when Siamese Meme fails to top the efforts of dozens of bands prior.

Still top 5 albums of the past 25 years.

To this day no other album has featured guitar tones as magestic as the ones on SD.

>>70355797
t. child

>>70355049
this

/thread

>>70355891
t. Pleb

>>70354887
I think Pisces Iscariot is better desu.

>>70354988
>Converge - Jane Doe
>Mayhem - De Mysteriis Dom Sathanas
>Electric Wizard - Dopethrone
>Radiohead - Kid A
>Sigur Ros - Agaetis Byrjun
>Wu Tang Clan - 36 Chambers
>Bjork - Homogenic
>Death - Symbolic
>Board of Canada - Music has the right and Geogaddi
>Modest Mouse - LCW
>Flaming Lips - the Soft Bulletin
>Outkast - Everything
>Swans - Soundtracks and the Revival Trilogy
>Nick Cave - Let Love In
>Joanna Newsom - Everything
>OPN - everything


I could go on. Siamese Dream is a mediocre album. The definitive 5/10

>>70355231
Unwound - Leaves Turn Inside You
Fugazi - The Argument
Hum - You'd Prefer an Astronaut
Blonde Redhead - La Mia Via Violenta
Cat Power - What Would the Community Think
PJ Harvey - Stories from the City, Stories from the Sea
Rodan - Rusty
The Mars Volta - Frances the Mute
Radiohead - Kid A
Sunny Day Real Estate - Diary

Off the top of my head and excluding post-rock

>>70356976
Wow your taste is terrible.

>>70356976
> Mayhem but no Emperor
Ugh.

>>70357073
What bad albums did I name?

>>70357098
Almost all of them

>>70356976
>>70357039
literally the only thing you both mentioned that comes close is YPAA. Nice job.

>>70357123
key thanks you contrarian piece of shit

>>70357138
Shit taste 2bh

>>70357143
Contrarian is calling Siamese dream 5/10

You're a faggot and a pussy

>modest mouse

Lmfao

>>70357138
That's a fantastic argument and all, but it just tells me you haven't listened to all of them.

>>70355231
1. Spiderland
2. Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk
3. Bath
4. Turn on the Bright Lights
5. Different Class
6. Hello Everyone. Nice to Meet You. We Are Midori.
7. Jesu
8. A I A: Alien Observer
9. Vision Creation Newsun
10. The Ape of Naples.

Siamese Dream is just an 8/10 in my opinion.

>all these morons listing shitty indie rock albums

>>70357186
You're right but literally the only one I haven't is Sigur Ros and I'm not really into them from that I've heard.

>>70356825
Confusing opinion but patrician album choice so I'll allow it
Starla in particular is fantastic

File: 0e9.jpg (24KB, 499x499px) Image search: [Google]

24KB, 499x499px

>>70357172
Calling an album with whiny vocals, shitty lyrics, overbearing melodrama and angst, good guitar tone and alright songwriting 5/10 is "contrarian" you say? I think the term "appropriate" would be more fitting desu.

>You're a faggot and a pussy

I feel bad for you that you feel the need to call me names on 4chan to feel more alpha.

>>70357216
Literally not even one of the albums I mentioned is Indie Rock.

File: 61GRRY159HL.jpg (75KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

75KB, 500x500px

>>70355231

>>70357227
I can't see any reason Siamese Dream is better than Leaves Turn Inside You (or Rusty for that matter), but I'd like to hear them.

>>70357260
math rock is wankery garbage and you sound like a fanboy.

File: Hours.jpg (180KB, 1200x1199px) Image search: [Google]

180KB, 1200x1199px

In terms of alt rock albums? It has

In terms of Billy albums? Probably not

>>70357311
Uh huh, didn't think there'd be much of a case given that you haven't listened to either. The only fanboy here is the guy adamant Smashing Pumpkins made the best album of the last 25 years with no exception.

>>70357364
But they did. It's not my fault your bias is showing.

>>70357417
>math rock
Is a terrible description of both and reeks of a quick Google search

>>70357467
Or someone who knows it when he hears it ;^)

>>70356028
>someone who names a Pumpkins album among the top 5 of the past 25 years calling anyone else a pleb
poetry

yea Lemonade by Beyonce exists

>>70355231
1. Definitely Maybe
2. (What's The Story?) Morning Glory
3. Rated R
4. Songs For The Deaf
5. Degradation Trip Volumes 1 & 2
6. Superunknown
7. AEnima
8. Lateralus

that's all I got