accurate let's get this going

File: HerbieChart.png (929KB, 1362x629px) Image search: [Google]

929KB, 1362x629px

Trust me on this. I'm an expert.

>>70308600

i actually agree throw empyrean isles on patrician too

>>70308619
I'd do his whole discography but then I'd be here all day/night.

HERBIE
HERBIE
HERBIE

>>70308668

true nice choice though

>plebeian
Nevermind
>contrarian
Bleach
>Patrician
In Utero and MTV Unplugged

Try and fight me on this, faggots

>Plebeian
Cheap Trick
>Contrarian
The Raspberries
>Patrician
Big Star

Fuck it I'm doing it.

>>70308698
>>70308710

true

>>70308418
True

>Plebeian
In the Court of the Crimson King
>Contrarian
Islands
>Patrician
Larks' Tongues in Aspic

>>70308698
nirvana's entire catalog is plebeian

>Plebeian
Meat is Murder
>Contrarian
Strangeways Here We Come
S/T
>Patrician
Hatful of Hollow
The Queen is Dead

>>70308793
larks tongue blows intcotck out of the water

>>70308600
>Plebeian
His fusion stuff

>Contrarian
His later disco sounding stuff

>Patrician
His actually jazz stuff

>Plebian
Painting With
Feels
>Contrarian
ODDSAC
Hollindaggin
Danse Manatee
>Patrician
MPP
CHZ
HCTI
STGSTV
SJ
Campfire Songs
Sung Tongs

>>70308795
patrician*

>>70308600
>>70308921
why do you hate his fusion stuff so much

honestly how can you dislike head hunters

>>70308942
>Pleb
Avey
>Contrarian
Deak
>Patrician
Panda, Geo

>>70308945
grunge is the plebbiest thing I can think of and Burt Bobain was a fraudulent hack who pretended to have indie cred cause he had a beat Happening tattoo even though Calvin Johnson hated his guts for being a sellout whore

>>70308942
So wrong

>Plebeian
MPP
Feels
Strawberry Jam
>Contrarian
CHz
Danse Manatee
>Patrician
Here Comes the Indian
Campfire Songs

>>70308984
isn't it past your bedtime? There's school tomorrow

File: HerbieChartFull.png (1MB, 1362x802px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1362x802px

I'm in physical pain with the stuff I had to put in plebian. I hate my life. 4 of those 5 are my top 5 herbie's. I worked hard on this.

>>70308965
This.

>>70308793
Larks is also pleb
THRAK is patrician

>>70308965
And to clarify I didn't put Headhunters in 'pleb' because I don't like it, far from it, I'm basing it on what most of /mu/ would agree with, not my personal taste.

>>70309017
Why do nirvanafags always resort to the "you're le underage" argument? Nirvana is for 13 year old redditors

>>70308698
Bleach >>>>> In Utero, fuck Steve Albini

King Crimson:

>Plebeian

>Contrarian

>Patrician
all of it

I didn't make a chart of 40 Herbie albums to get no replies cmon guys what are your thoughts?

>>70309102
>Why do nirvanafags always resort to the "you're le underage" argument?
>Nirvana is for 13 year old redditors

how do
what
I
what

>>70309327
oh /mu/ doesnt actually listen to jazz, sorry you wasted your time

>>70309398
hey man I've listened to kind of blue at least twice

File: IMG_2499.png (1MB, 1334x750px)

1MB, 1334x750px

>>70309398
>>70309448

>>70309074
Low is not contrarian at all, dude.
Bowie Contrarian would probably be 1. Outside

>Plebeian
Please Please Me
With the Beatles
Sgt. Peppers
Abbey Road

>Contrarian
A Hard Day's Night
Let It Be
Yellow Submarine
Beatles for Sale

>Patrician
Rubber Soul
Revolver
White Album
Magical Mystery Tour
Help!

>>70309327

it's spot on there's not much to say

excellent work

>>70309525
Thank you :)

>Plebian:
Rock
>Contrarian:
Jazz
>Patrician:
Techno

>>70309770
>Plebeian
Rock, Folk, Electronic
>Contrarian
Jazz, Classical
>Patrician
Avant-Garde

>>70309770
>Plebian
Techno
>Contrarian
Muh special snowflake bloops
>Patrician
Math rock, classical, Jazz.

>>70310717
Drive Like Jehu is legit patrician.

>>70309910
Fedora, The Post

>>70310717
Wow this is so inaccurate in every imaginable way...

>plebian
the bends

>contrarian
the king of limbs

>patrician
amnesiac

>>70309868
>Avant-Garde is a genre

>>70309026
No one cares, also gay

File: IMG_2969.gif (992KB, 250x250px) Image search: [Google]

992KB, 250x250px

>>70312126

>>70309026
god bless you herbieanon your dedication to herbie is admirable

>>70309868
>>70309910
disgusting

>>70312126
bad post

>>70309026
Truly one of the last great posters on /mu/

>>70312207
Gay post. Also no one cares.

>>70311837
elaborate

>>70308971
Oh, this explains why I was having so much trouble getting into Panopticon...

>>70310826
fuck off Mike

File: 1484294705399.jpg (221KB, 1362x757px) Image search: [Google]

221KB, 1362x757px

>>70310717
fixed it

>>70308710
>pleb
those bands
>patrician
beatles

ITT:
>Popular
>Popular contrarian
>Unpopular contrarian

>>70314031
>Wavves
>Patrician
>Red House Painters
>Mission of Burma
>Contrarian

>>70308698
Insecticide vol 1 and b-sides are truly punk tier they are the patrician choice
everything else is labeled correctly though

>>70308698
We get it you like Needle drop

>>70314031
All pleb accept mission and jesu

>>70308418

Spot on.

File: 1386639996902.jpg (157KB, 600x653px)

157KB, 600x653px

>>70309910
>math rock
>patrician

>>70308810
>those contrarian options
S/t is the one of their best, morrissey and marr both say strangeways is the best. I'd put louder than bombs there

>Plebeian
Violator
>Contrarian
Ultra
>Patrician
Music for the masses

>>70308896
You shut your whore mouth

>>70308418
Paul is also True Patrician as well as Plebian though. He's one of those rare cases where he's both.

>>70308600
Herbie nigga!

>Harrison
>not contrarian

>Plebeian
Most Popular
>Contrarian
Least Popular
>Patrician
Second Most Popular

>>70311976
> i was born in the wrong generation
kek

>>70314893
>Plebeian
Your Opinion
>Contrarian
Least Popular
>Patrician
My Opinion

fix'd

>>70314629
this.

in the same light, george is simultaneously contrarian as well as patrician

>>70308793
Correct
>>70308600
You my nigga herbieanon but ill always love his fusion albums above all else
>>70308810
Fucking yes, hatful is the only time a comp is better and more coherent than any album an artists made
>>70308896
Tarkus is patrish
>>70308942
feels and sung tongs are patrish, sj, stgstv and hcti are arguable and the rest is plen
>>70308971
All patrish desu
>>70309074
This but add young americans to patrishas well

>>70309364
You're a fucking idiot

>>70316742
>You my nigga herbieanon but ill always love his fusion albums above all else

I do too.
I just went with what the REST of 4chan would say about his fusion albums.

I made a full chart version. It was fun.

>>70309012
what do people hear in hcti it seems like their worst album excluding the two new ones

>plebian
The Most Lamentable Tragedy
>contrarian
The Airing of Grievances
>patrician
Local Business

>>70308418
Correct

>>70308710
>Cheap Trick
>plebeian in any respect

End your life.

>>70308600
>can't stand sextant
>call himself a patrician

>plebeian
Coloring Book
>contrarian
Acid Rap
>patrician
10 Day

File: autechre.jpg (294KB, 1000x801px) Image search: [Google]

294KB, 1000x801px

>Plebeian
Incanabula
Amber
Tri Repetae
LP5

>Contrarian
Chiastic Slide
Quaristice
Oversteps
Exai

>Patrician
Confield
Draft 7.30
Untilted
elseq

>>70320758
yessss
i love 10 day, definitely his best

>>70308418
I disagree with you on Ringo.
I believe both Ringo and George are Patrician.

>>70320306
I never at any point said I was patrician.

You didn't even read the updated chart. Sheesh.

>Plebeian:
Demon Days
>Contrarian:
Plastic Beach
>Patrician:
S/T

>>70309074
how the hell is Low contrarian?

Plebeian
>Old
Contrarian
>XXX
Patrician
Atrocity Exhibition

>>70308698
yes, it's correct

>>70308793
You're right
Not like any of those albums would be bad

>>70314893
But actually though.

>>70309074
Hunky Dory should be in Plebian, Low and Heroes in Patrician, Scary Monsters in contrarian

>>70320832
approved

>>70309501
>Rubber Soul
>Patrician
I mean I own it on LP from 1965 but it's just a bunch of semi-comfy pop songs, with some better tracks like Norwegian Wood. I rarely listen to it.

>plebeian
You'll Cowards Don't Even Smoke Crack
>Contrarian
You Went to County Jail Not the Penitentiary Pussy Nigga
>Patrician
Kill Urself My man