>better than the beatles and bowie really makes you think

praise piero

If you were to remove the aspects of them being way more culturally relevant than btbam then I guess I could see it as possible that you'd rate it better

>>70155413
fuck that wasn't there earlier today

is he like doing this right now?

>>70155713
*earlier today as in like a few hours ago

File: genius.png (5KB, 631x49px) Image search: [Google]

5KB, 631x49px

Reminder that Cardiacs are no longer spork-core but are now genius-core, as they should be

>>70155713
yeah he just added it very recently. It shows up in New Albums

Another 8 to add to the 00s list

>>70155754
always rated them

How proggy/jazzy is this record? X/3
How noisy/unmelodic is this record? Y/3
How quirky/silly/weird is this record? Z/3
Does this album feature multiple guitars? G/1

X+Y+Z+G = Scaruffi's score

>>70155754
I love scaruffi for this.

>>70158232
What about The Doors - S/T?
It would score poorly using that system and he gave it a 9

>>70158232
have one on me has an 8.5 and it's none of those

even people who hate 'metalcore' like that album

plus it's prog so he sucks its proverbial dong by default

scaruffi is a faggot for liking this album

>a genuinely good band is considered better than overrated corporate boy band
praise scruffy

>>70158547
I love BTBAM, but they're on Metal Blade ffs. And Victory isn't any better if you look at their releases.

As corporate as anyone else.

>>70158586

He gave Jagged Little Pill an 8. He doesn't care if an album sells really well, either.

>>70155448


>He includes the bugaboo of "cultural relevance" in his judgment of musical quality.

Stupid!

File: cd414f1b60b59aa2df6e50867634d767.png (26KB, 309x242px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 309x242px

lol

>>70155413
>>70158232
Colors
>3/3
>2/3
>2/3
>1/1
3+2+2+1=8
score checks out

maybe swap a point in noisy/unmelodic for a point in quirky/silly/weird

>>70159574
so he's confusing Can't Give Everything Away with Girl Loves Me right?? But even then, there are no electronic drones in Girl Loves Me, just some bloops. Is Scruffobox going senile?

he's reviewed agalloch now

File: scaruffi_modern.png (1MB, 1000x690px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1000x690px

just updated the millennial chart

as a big fan of colors and sing to god i must say i'm incredibly irritated that this twat has reviewed them

really don't need the coming weeks of memeing, I was doing just fine liking things on my own thanks

>>70155413
>BTBAM - colors 8

what the fuck, it's one of the best records of the 00s according to him
porco dio piero