Is the emotional and/or physical abuse of a human (or humans) justified if it results in highly regarded and influential art?
...um, no.
>>70117635
/thread
no but who cares?
>>70117635
But without the abuse endured during the creation of Trout Mask Replica, we wouldn't have it as an artistic work, and as such, several albums and artists influenced by it simply would not exist.
>>70117635
this
Crapstain Queeffart was a talentless hack
>>70117680
this album didn't influence shit, it's just some pretentious fuckhead making "experimental tunes!!!" at the expense of other people's health.
>>70118365
It's fine if you dislike the album (most millennials do), but if you honestly believe it wasn't influential then you are extremely ignorant of 20th century music history.
Are you an Oasis fan, by chance?
>>70118898
>Matt Groening
>David Lynch
>John Lyndon
>John Frusciante
wew lad
>>70117607
Yes. In fact that and self-defense may be the only justification there is.
>>70117607
Absolutely
>>70118365
>didn't influence shit
It influenced loads of shitty noise rock Beefheart imitations, of course it was influential
>>70117607
no, but i don't think it's necessarily wrong to enjoy work that's resulted from said abuse
>>70118365
ugh. people like you go on this board.
come on, Beefheart didn't torture people or something
>>70121015
>Didn't pay bandmates
>Drugged them
>Fed them a miniscule amount of food
???
>>70121042
he's was just havin a laff
>>70121078
this. everyone here is a bunch of pussies
>>70121042
It was by utilitarian means that we were afforded the greatest piece of music of all times
>>70121042
>Didn't pay bandmates
he had no money
>Drugged them
false, they drugged themselves
>Fed them a miniscule amount of food
he had no money
This kind of complaint really saddens me desu
Like people in 2017 would condemn Kubrick for pushing Shelley Duvall to emotional heights and call it torture
>>70121163
Captain Beefheart once threw his guitar player into a dumpster. He also pushed his drummer down the stairs. He would also have band members put inside barrels and berated until they broke down crying.
>>70121196
why'd they get in the barrels if they were just going to cry like babies
baka
>>70121196
who cares? TMR is literally the best album ever made. it was well worth it