Discuss.

>>69918336
i follow you on twitter

>>69918336
This is correct

Honestly, it's an impossible discussion to have. New Order obviously has a ton of classic albums, more than JD, but Ian died right when they were getting started. They put out two amazing albums with him, who knows what would have happened if they lived.

New Order is amazingly consistent though, not sure even JD would have been able to keep up that same pace.

I agree

File: 2kQogTB.jpg (77KB, 640x960px) Image search: [Google]

77KB, 640x960px

Childhood is idolizing Joy Division
Adulthood is realizing New Order makes more sense.

Childhood is JD.
Teenagehood is NO.
Adulthood is Monaco.

>shitty opinions thread

File: wave_chick_pepe.jpg (18KB, 412x351px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 412x351px

Childhood is Warsaw
Teenagehood is Joy Division
Adulthood is you never fucking made it there because you hung yourself when you were 23.

this is a fact

>>69918336
fuck this twitter account. lol dude depression lol mental illness lol fuck you

>>69918336
Agreed completely.

i have mixed feelings about this

overall, i'd say no, but certainly in many case-by-case basses i'd agree

>>69918468
The comparison is between New Order and Joy Division, not New Order and what Joy Division could potentially have been if Ian had not died. It's very possible to compare the discographies of the two bands and pick a favourite, anyone with sound critical judgement can do it.

>>69918336
Absolutely correct.

New Order built an impressive discography with a lot of great stuff over an extended period. The highs Joy Division's short life soar above even New Order's best.

JD=quality; NO=quantity.