What went so horribly wrong?

Nothing. It's as underwhelming as their other stuff.
you're just viewing it without the rose tinted glasses

you're mum

>>69813496
it's emo

>>69813496
I don't think it went wrong but I didn't dig it much.
It sounded like an old emo band trying to make an emo revival album for expectations.

>>69813520
First record is overwhelming
>overwhelmingly good, actually
This one is just what it is... pleasant follow up that's no longer in the place they were.

thought the lyrics were worse, production style was a lot "shinier". guitar arranging wasn't nearly as well done. people who are saying that this is on the same level as S/T 1 are just being contrarians. there are very clear reasons why this is the worse album

>>69813556
IRONICALLY, given the cover.

It sounds a lot like an Owen record with a bit more noodling going on really

it's really good

I liked it but I've never heard their other album despite seeing it posted a million times

Why do they think photographs of houses make good album covers?

they fell for the dad emo meme

they're too comfy now to be emotional

>>69813556
Yeah they went inside>>69813597

>>69814095
Dont know why it quoted two people

>>69814095
good point

>>69814161
GOOD point

>>69814194
thanks Lori