Who comes out on top in the eternal debate?

Peter every fucking time. His talent and skill for vocals and lyric writing and song writing blow Phil's away. Phil Genesis is still really good from Trick of a Tale to Duke, but Peter Genesis is generally better. Phil has a good voice and sung those Phil Genesis songs really well, but Peter was always more creative and expressive and did so much more with his vocal performances while Phil was always more straight-forward.

Phil Collins ruined Genesis by turning it into a pop band

What a hack!

Peter Gabriel is the Avant Teen choice. Phil is the true seasoned patrician choice.

>>69650228
Phil doesn't have a Games Without Frontiers or a Milgram's 37, you fucking hackpleb.

Phil is the better singer but Peter is the better songwriter imo

And the closest he gets to Mercy Street is In the Air Tonight lol. What a joke. His Sledgehammer is I Can't Dance.

>>69650288
In the Air Tonight is closer to Intruder than Mercy Street, and Sussudio is his obvious Sledgehammer.

Phil's Mercy Street would be Take Me Home or Another Day in Paradise.

>>69650348
Nah.

The best is the one who sang the best version of Supper's Ready, and that would be Phil Collins

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fONg3sIACkQ

>>69650766
>Phil
>Best Version of Supper's Ready
YOU FUCKING WHAT?

Reminder that it goes
Peter > Steve >Anthony Phillips = Phil > Mike >>>>>>>> Tony

>>69650996
No. Not him and he is absotively correct. Phil is a better singer than Pete.

Pete is a better songwriter and all around musical visionary.

>>69651034
It seems lacking without Peter and his insane theatrics.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_FBcz3tBH74

>>69650258
Brand X > Peter Gabriel's entire career

File: 9f29fde588750e2f0fd350b3bb01810e.jpg (77KB, 736x996px) Image search: [Google]

77KB, 736x996px

>>69651135
We are talking solo career here, or else Brand X would even beat out Genesis.
Phil's drumming in his prime was insane. Only Bill Bruford could out drum him.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AOnrkuS_w6w

>>69650766
tbqh the best version is on Foxtrot, but I agree the Seconds Out version is the best out of the live versions

File: Peter Gabriel Muscleman.jpg (13KB, 236x314px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 236x314px

>Heard there are people chatting shit about me in this thread
>You fuckers wanna take that back?

File: 1425158891821.jpg (6KB, 145x145px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 145x145px

>>69651424
I-I'm sorry, Peter-sama!

File: Peter the Tank Engine.jpg (15KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 480x360px

Peter Gabriel because he made the most AESTHETIC proto-vaporwave music video of all time
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qt87bLX7m_o

>>69651482
I fucking love that video, the actual song is nowhere nearly as good without it.