post your recent rated on rym and comment on others lmao

>Graceland 3/10
kys

>>69395938
(You)

>>69395938
>lmao
>low ratings for classics are cool and edgy
no thanks

File: sdf.png (117KB, 1330x417px) Image search: [Google]

117KB, 1330x417px

>>69395938

be nice to Syd you goon

File: Screenshot_1.png (65KB, 831x311px) Image search: [Google]

65KB, 831x311px

>>69395938
what are your 5's?

>>69395979
I like the artists he influenced
not much his music itself
>>69395982
https://rateyourmusic.com/collection/DeBatata/r5.0
>>69395959
how else am I supposed to receive delicious (You)s

>>69396024
I gave Construção a 3.5, I'm more of a Jorge Ben kinda guy hahah, nice 5's tho

>>69396108
I really, really want to like Jorge
But I can't roll with his voice

>>69396179
His voice is actually my favorite thing about him. The falsettos are too good man.

>>69395975
I can get behind this

>>69395938
(You)

File: recents.png (114KB, 943x400px) Image search: [Google]

114KB, 943x400px

>>69396692
oops i forgot this

>>69395938
Why do you even misten to so much music you consider bad?

>>69396809
but how would I know if I like it if I don't listen

>>69396834
Just try a track off the album and see if it might be your thing

>>69396834
you turn it off part way through and dont rate it

File: IMG_0011.png (263KB, 640x1136px) Image search: [Google]

263KB, 640x1136px

As usual my recent is clogged with wishlist stuff so this format's better
>>69395982
Check out Kiasmos- s/t
>>69395975
What do you think of Bloom? Also I rec this to pretty much anyone I see with Beach House, but if you haven't go listen to Cocteau Twins- Four Calendar Cafe. Incredible album

>>69396870
>>69396877
but then I will never know if I like the rest
besides, I don't worry about that, I don't listen to music only to like it
it's fun to discover new sounds

>>69396916
Fair, each to his own I guess

>>69396916
Ya don't listen to them, listening to full albums is imperative for developing a full coherent opinion and introduction to an artist, and even then it's still a good idea to check out their other stuff depending on the artist and if they change sounds a lot. I hate when I ask people why they didn't like an album and they go "I didn't like the first couple tracks so I turned it off" that shit bugs the hell out of me

>>69396712
>David Fenech

At least listen to GOOD free improv

File: ss+(2016-12-01+at+11.49.03).jpg (49KB, 684x334px) Image search: [Google]

49KB, 684x334px

>>69395979
what's your favorite beatles solo album?

>>69395982
>32 Zel / Planet Shrooms
>better than Nostalgic 64

>>69397585
I think it is too honestly. I like both a ood bit though. Zel is just more consistent. Also Zel >>>>> Shrooms

File: don't hate.png (64KB, 648x323px) Image search: [Google]

64KB, 648x323px

>>69395938
>LOL I hate all the old, dadrock music. Am I cool yet sempais?
(You)

>>69395979
That's some good tastes right there.

>>69397550

Haven't listened to them all, but I like All Things Must Pass and Living in the Material World
way more than anything other Beatles related I listened to.

Do you like Low too? If you rated Idaho that high you must love them.

>>69397695
I think Low is the 2nd most overrated slowcore band. They're ok. I find that there are tons of other slowcore bands that do their whole shtick way better.

>>69397677
>>LOL I hate all the old, dadrock music. Am I cool yet sempais?
do you feel better now
did you relief you anger

>>69397717
>>69397738
You deleted your post just to become even more sarcastic. Amazing.

>relief your anger
ebin

File: Screenshot_2016-12-01-10-08-07.png (308KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

308KB, 1920x1080px

>>69397604
gots to listen me some more Billy Joel
looks like you had a real nice couple of days

>>69397550
are these all spacey rock kidna guys like transona five

>>69397764
that was someone else
why are you so aggressive
I could start ranting about your taste too but I don't feel like a dick rn

File: rym.png (192KB, 670x829px) Image search: [Google]

192KB, 670x829px

patrish taste coming through

File: le.jpg (12KB, 239x366px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 239x366px

>>69397764
wasn't me, blame the mods

but yeah, your lack of understanding isn't very christian of you, so-called "reformed christian"

>>69397800
transona five wasn't that spacey though. it's all slowcore.

File: 1459761976970.jpg (46KB, 472x357px) Image search: [Google]

46KB, 472x357px

>>69397773
>Young Thug
>3/5

File: 1474393038006.jpg (220KB, 1200x900px) Image search: [Google]

220KB, 1200x900px

>>69397704

>I think Low is the 2nd most overrated slowcore
band.

o-okay

>>69397604
Have you listened to any of Bill Withers albums?

File: recent.png (68KB, 1217x319px) Image search: [Google]

68KB, 1217x319px

and we're back

>>69397800
yea man billy joel's pretty damn groovy
>>69397831
i have not
where should i start if i think lean on me is an incredible song

>>69397823
Deserves 1/5

File: rb.jpg (75KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

75KB, 500x500px

>>69397823
baka Thugger is lit

>>69397773
>>69397773
>JEFFREY
>anywhere close to the quality of B6

You may have heard it but check out Loma Prieta- IV

>>69397842
Start with Just as I Am, then listen to the album with "Lean on Me", Still Bill. If you like those, finish with +Justments.

Archive has the albums for dl.

>>69397874
I haven't I only recently decided to try and take him seriously lol, I'll listen to it soon. and I think jeffery is better desu

>>69396914
thx for the rec anon.
>>69397585
Nostalgic 64 is so bland and generic, the only thing going for it is the lyrics. in 32 Zel he already has more personality and interesting production, also, it has the cool meme song.

>>69397677

Thanks. Try some Harry Nilsson if you haven't already.

Also gotta suggest Talk Talk - The Colour of Spring ofc.

>>69397820
I didnr listen to that one I don't think but I remember them sounding mad spacey dreamy contemplative whatever the heck
im not really big into indie rock stuff I guess I probably don't even know what space rock actually is

but yeah hey do you like tacoma radar

>>69397842
my mom hates his guts I used to play keepin the faith really loud and it made her so mad good times good times

>>69398006
tacoma radar is great. if you like that check out braving the seabed.

>>69397864
Thugger is shit*

>>69398135
this

>>69398067
cool, will do thanks

File: ss+(2016-12-01+at+07.50.54).jpg (110KB, 1193x492px) Image search: [Google]

110KB, 1193x492px

>>69397800
do you like dominos

>>69397677
Moving Gelatine Plates is great
isn't Oh Yeah supposed to be a real oddball in Mingus discog?

>>69396712
Carp's Head has it all, good music, Ghédalia vox and a qt sad kitten on the cover

>>69395979
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nW5U1eUd9fk

>>69395938
wow you ended up hating Graceland then huh

>>69398422
what went wrong with HYIMW for you? I thought that album was gorgeous

>>69398526
I have one of 'em faggy-ass pretentious rating systems where 2.5 means I liked it. As for why I didn't enjoy it more, I'd say it's because while I loved the arrangements and I secretly feel she could be the next Scott Walker if she puts in the work, but her vocal style makes all the songs seem kind of samey even though the music wasn't. I also have a hard time vibing with the "ethereal" aesthetic that seems to be all the rage for the past years.

>>69398422

Alain is a cool guy.

I have to give many, many albums I actually like three stars, since I only use full stars.

So I have only five ratings and save the highest for my absolute favorites. Leaves only two tiers to differentiate between shades of "good": 3 stars and 4 stars.

I gave the likes of Bowies Blackstar or most The Cure albums three stars, so I can give their better albums four stars to accentuate that they are better.

RYM is pain.

>>69398617
he sure was :(

File: LMAO.jpg (42KB, 1128x360px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 1128x360px

HEY GUYS I'M, L I K E, A PROFESSIONAL MUSIC CRITIC

>>69398688
calm down

>>69398726
aight

>>69398655

People die. That's just how things go.

>>69398846
I haven't died yet, deceasedfags get on my level

how do you do these screenshots?

i am too lazy to google, help please

File: Boku no Hedgehog.png (937KB, 2880x1216px) Image search: [Google]

937KB, 2880x1216px

>>69398865

emphasis on yet

>>69398645
or you know.. you COULD use the half stars too...
>>69398588
oh, interesting. I don't usually see the point of those but to each their own. Yeah her voice comes off as very distant, almost omniscient. Imo it works but ya I can see where you're coming from.

>>69398913
sonic is fucking hot
>>69398883
your pc might have this program called snipping tool

>>69398913
longer socks are more aerodynamic and allow for maximum fast I'm p sure

>>69398917
rating systems should serve the user most so it's best to go with what seems most useful to yourself.
and yeah I'm not going to let that stop me from listening to more of her stuff though.

File: ZRYM2.png (66KB, 900x368px) Image search: [Google]

66KB, 900x368px

>>69398947

thanks a lot

i feel like i was a bit too harsh to AX7, but man were some songs cringey

>>69398913
just what the fuck man
>>69399004
ya I feel you
>>69399082
what else have you heard of A7X's stuff? That's one of their worst albums

>>69399130
>what else have you heard of A7X's stuff?

nothing tbqh
i liked afterlife (for its kitschy, yet still good lyrics), so i thought i give the album a try

>>69399165
are you normally into metal into more like rock stuff? I could rec you some songs to get into them. They're one of my favorite bands

>>69399208

really? one of your favorites? they sold out big.

i dont listen to songs, only albums.
i like pop and rock more than i do metal.

>>69399314
I think if you knew more about the band as people you wouldn't think they "sold out". They just like to change their sound with each album and they shifted to more accessible music. That isn't inherently selling out. If you prefer rock you should listen to their album this year The Stage, honestly. It's a really catchy project with great riffs and an ear for composition. You might like Hail To The King too even tho I think that one's hot garbage. Their first 3 are all in the top 100 of my favorite albums

>>69398422
Oh Yeah! is something. While I like the album, it's clear Mingus was not going in a particular direction, cause the mood was all over the place.

>>69399590

thx senpai, i will give them another chance

>>69399929
sure thing, let me know what you think. If you can get over the fact that it's really high-octane and fast-paced, I'd most highly rec you listen to City Of Evil. I respect that you listen to full albums, I myself do the same

>>69399999
Checkd

>>69399999
You Slut!

>>69395938
What don't you like about Point by Cornelius?

>>69399999
Holy fuck, checked

>>69398422
>giving Lulu 5 stars

>>69399999
Checked, you slut!

>5's list has less than 50 albums

Do you even like music?

>>69400059
gonna be honest with you, I don't remember anything about it
I do remember disliking it a lot... I may be confusing it with another record but I remember getting a bit dizzy after listening to it... which I get it, it's an emotional response that probably had little to do with the music, but still, I really didn't like it
uh
I know I sound stupid but really, the only thing I remember about it is that I hated it

>>69400259
i find myself saying the same thing all the time and always have to catch myself and remember some people just reserve it for their favorites. It should really be given to whatever deserves it though to preserve the integrity of overall system, but oh well
>>69400340
fuck Jefre. I hate his music. I hate Myself was solid tho, Idk about 4.5 but I liked it a decent bit

>>69400379

>to preserve the integrity of overall system

people don't even respect basic bell curve

5's are the least of your problem

>>69400313
Fair enough. I was just curious as he's one of my favourite Japanese artists, but you're entitled to your opinion.

Nice to see Global Communication - 76:14 got a 5. Excellent album.

>>69400610
I have a problem with all of it but 5's especially. Probably because I just get this feeling like you're cheating them out of a great score because you can't just make a top 50 albums list and instead want to make your 5 star some kind of really important, sacred score

>>69400912

I think there are plenty of people who rate everything they like 5 though. So it should even out.

>>69400912
I like to rate each track and then get an average score to rate the album... I have a shit-ton of 4.5's verging on a 5 but only one 5 so far.

>>69400340

I should really listen to Jefre

File: SonofSvengoolie.jpg (4KB, 132x164px) Image search: [Google]

4KB, 132x164px

>>69399999
> jar of flies a 3
What a waste of a get

File: rym.png (55KB, 644x323px) Image search: [Google]

55KB, 644x323px

no bully please

File: ss+(2016-12-01+at+03.54.57).jpg (55KB, 543x321px) Image search: [Google]

55KB, 543x321px

>>69400963
Dog Man Star is good though

>>69398688
Christgau?

>>69397812
>Kishi Bashi among the lowest rated on that list
>"Patrish"
w e w

>>69397677
I don't like Walker's original songs that much, but his Jacques Brel covers on 2 are great.

>>69402013
>bottomless pit 2.5
>microphones 4
pls go

>>69402741
>8/10
>bad

>>69402741
>Liking DG

File: 6743ee34b8c56bbd3c1d19d607ccdc6a.png (73KB, 934x319px) Image search: [Google]

73KB, 934x319px

>>69395938
take a chill pill
>>69395975
sure
>>69398422
be nice to julia
>>69400963
nice
>>69402013
give me your lunch money

>>69402741
pleb detected

File: 2016-12-01_15-32-10.png (97KB, 896x435px) Image search: [Google]

97KB, 896x435px

>>69403485
>not overrating opeth
I personally think it's lower than 3, but you're still cool.
>>69402013
you're just blindly giving /mu/core 10s, that's good enough.
>>69398778
>neofolk
based, wish I listened to more of it
>>69398688
pretty accurate ratings desu
>>69397842
you legitimately think you're better than everyone else

>>69404025
>Bright Size Life 2 stars
w e w

>>69404147
it's really noodley and low energy. I like some of his other stuff better.

>>69398778
>Flowers From Exile 2 stars
fuck off

>>69404713
anon...that is 1 star

>>69401174
ya... I've seen those profiles. And everything they slightly dislike is a .5. It makes no sense to me
>>69401346
I did that for a little bit when I first went on the site, but I found a lot of albums to be greater than the sum of their parts and so I ditched it
>>69401363
no you shouldn't

File: Snip20161201_7.png (255KB, 1774x690px) Image search: [Google]

255KB, 1774x690px

>>69397812
>Solange album a 4
>Atrocity Exhibition a 3
"no"
>>69398688
>Greed anything above a 1.5
>>69398778
You have good taste.
>>69399082
You were not. They're awful.

>>69399208
shut the fuck up about avenged sevenfold

>>69405885
why should I or anyone else shut the fuck up about one of our favorite artists? I'm not gonna shut the fuck up about Klaus Schulze either but I guarantee you wouldn't have made that post if I was talking about him

File: 5.jpg (253KB, 1540x1540px) Image search: [Google]

253KB, 1540x1540px

>>69404025
>you legitimately think you're better than everyone else

any reason you think that? because i don't believe that at all :/

>>69406331
you think you're better than me

>>69406283
Because they're shit is why

>>69406410
get your head out of your ass. Your opinion isn't better than mine and mine isn't yours

>>69407184
I added you please add me back we seem to be interested in the same stuff

>rating music
>thinking anyone cares about your half-baked adolescent opinions

kill yourself

>>69406331
You have bach, and a lot of popular singles, that normally means on rym you're a higher than thou mixture of an avant-teen and poptimist, literally the worst kind of user. You'll have some super obscure releases as 5s along with ABBA and other shit, and you think your taste is absolutely the best. Someone who will unironically call someone an embryo.

If you just enjoy those records, then good job, though I really hate people who overrate Bach, but those ratings and records are massively indicative of someone who thinks they're part of the rym elite.

File: r8.png (62KB, 519x316px) Image search: [Google]

62KB, 519x316px

>>69405500
you should go listen to the pixie's debut EP it's my fav material from them

>>69402013
I might give Low another listen now

>>69400963
>liking britpop in any form
kek

>>69399082
>alvvays and biffy clyro are equal
go away

>>69408024
>faust .5

phew. What made it deserve that?
>>69407957
what's wrong with alvvays? I thought that album was a lot of fun

>>69408044
no I mean I loved that album they are much much better than iffy bile

>>69408024
Allman Brothers are shit, I didn't even have to see the Faust to know you were baiting

>>69408119
oh good, ya I agree. Not sure why I assumed you were going after Alvvays. People give them shit here sometimes

>>69396914
I admit it's hard to resist my urge to just hate you but I just wanted to ask if you've listened to any other Killdozer? Twelve Point Buck is really their best but even something like Snakeboy has some of their best songs. Going to the Beach is a fucking classic.

>>69398778
On the one hand, I think Flowers from Exile is a very fun album but on the other hand, I appreciate that you recognize Nature Unveiled as Current 93's best album. Art Bears are alright but not my favorite band from that scene.

>>69408317
Nah that's all I've heard. Is 12 point less cringe? I think my review should be on the front page still if you wanted to see my thoughts on that one

>>69408044
>random noise trying to be passed off as experimental art
>le circus ebin music

faust is fucking trash for pretentious idiots who think listening to ebin music makes them have better taste than everyone else

>>69408177
t. /mu/core drone

>faust is better than allman brothers

literally kill yourself

>>69408628
you seem to have a pretty bad inferiority complex
do you need someone to talk to

>>69408653
kek

exactly the point

>you're mentally ill because you can't enjoy faust

when will you pretentious idiots learn

>>69408697
no, I think you're ill because you are making up things to be upset about
no one is saying they're better because they enjoy faust
no one is saying they are better than you
no one is saying you have to enjoy faust
you might need to lay off 4chan a bit

>>69408628
Anyone who calls any music that isn't indeterminacy "random" is either intellectually dishonest or an idiot. Your post is also full of unintentional irony, and I hope for your sake that you're just trolling.

>>69408776
see
>>69408781

>>69408781
I've seen that guy posting before
he has some sort of persecution complex, always expecting people to call him a pleb
>>69408830
maybe if you weren't a jackass to begin with people wouldn't treat you like that

>>69408830
I don't care what you like or dislike. It's your way of thinking that I'm judging.

>>69408898
the way of thinking you singlemindedly made up? k bruh

>>69408857
i'm not. only because 90+% of the people you interact with who like faust and similar """""music""""" are like that

>>69408898
>you called my favourite meme album shit so I'm going to use """"fancy"""" words to try and make you sound dumb and so I sound superior

>>69408415
All their early stuff is like a joke, but some of the jokes are funny but Twelve-Point is where they upped their production and got more legitimate so it stands up a lot better. I'm a big noise rock fan though and I wouldn't put Killdozer in my all-time favorites, I just thought that was a very low rating and thought it weird you would listen to not-their-most-popular album if you don't like them

>>69408920
So you didn't use thinking when you wrote that post? When you decided people only like a semi-famous album to spite you?

File: 20.jpg (129KB, 720x960px) Image search: [Google]

129KB, 720x960px

>>69407761
you sound very insecure and not the kind of person i'd want to be around, much less discuss music with.

>>69408947
You need to stop setting up false dichotomies. Anyone can like Faust and anyone can think your posts are stupid.

File: 10735327_791216520934653_715933023_n.png (598KB, 640x640px) Image search: [Google]

598KB, 640x640px

what a shitshow th ese threads always turn into

>>69409007
>trying to discredit someone else's experiences with le """"fancy"""" words

do you know anything other than pretentiousness?

File: rym1.png (131KB, 872x535px) Image search: [Google]

131KB, 872x535px

I've been more positive than I usually am. I'm ruining my reputation!

>>69408950
I was just introducing myself to them by listening to that. I had no idea if I liked them or not and just couldn't get into it at all. I'm also a big noise rock fan, up there in my favorite genres lists. I'll give Twelve Point a shot, because I definitely saw some good riffs and performances, I just thought the songwriting was wack overall

>>69408947
>i'm not. only because 90+% of the people you interact with who like faust and similar """""music""""" are like that
well idk
I stopped going to chart threads because of pretentious people too
but I think you shouldn't let your opinion on the fans make up your opinion on the music... like, no one is keeping an eye on what you like
truth is that no one really cares what you like unless you're girl
I think you should take a break from 4chan... because it can make people paranoid af

File: 10.jpg (90KB, 1200x922px) Image search: [Google]

90KB, 1200x922px

>>69409046
you're getting way too ahead of yourself here, little timmy.

>>69409046
Are there synonyms you think I should've used instead? Is the word "synonym" fancy as well? Also, you've been making authoritative claims, not describing experiences.

>>69408961
wait what, that's the accusation I was making. the chain of posts doesn't make sense if you're not >>69408628

>>69409073
I noticed you have King of the Jews in your wishlist, you should add The Narcotic Story, it's not so much noise rock but it's a fantastic album

>>69409119
I thought you were saying "see" and then showing how my post proves what the angry guy is claiming.

fuck you OP graceland is 4.5/5 minimum

>>69409127
Will do, thanks. I actually listened to fuckfest and couldn't fucking stand it, thought it was trash. But I've actually heard KOTJ a long time back and thought it was decent, but realized I couldn't remember anything from it so I deleted the rating to give it a new shot. You should send me an add, I could share some stuff with you

File: rym.jpg (107KB, 646x329px) Image search: [Google]

107KB, 646x329px

It's funny because I just realized I gave almost all these bands' previous albums a 2:

>Ten (2/5)
>Down Colorful Hill (3.5/5)
>Copper Blue (2/5)
>Cunning Stunts (2/5)
>Pod (2/5)

>>69408628
>people who like ____ just think theyre better than everyone else!!!
>also kill yourself for not liking _______

>>69409284
>cunning stunts a 2
Really? I thought that album was fantastic

>>69409333
It's my least favorite Cows album, almost turned me off them...I like the heavier ones before and after it much better (not that a 2's a terrible rating, I have about 1000 albums that are 2 or lower)

File: meme.jpg (349KB, 1100x660px) Image search: [Google]

349KB, 1100x660px

>>69409086
It doesn't affect me. I've been on /mu/ for over a year and I still mostly listen to music that a lot of /mu/ hates (dadrock meme etc).

I just find it insulting to actual music that such things like faust can be considered good music or even music when it's lacking any semblance of song structure, rhythm and sometimes even melody. You may as well just go into the street and record cars driving past and call it music because there isn't much difference.

It makes it easy for any talentless idiot to record some random noise that is not representative of any of the artist's "emotions and call it music and be worshipped by circlejerking idiots.

Same deal with the "noise" genre, mostly just awful Sunn 0))) rip offs (who I do think have artistic merit - at least live) that can't play their instruments properly so they play easy random stuff and call it music because they can't produce actual music.

It's the musical equivalent of pic related

>>69409429
holy shit this lack of self-awareness

File: barely o's.png (236KB, 430x413px) Image search: [Google]

236KB, 430x413px

>>69409429

>>69409352
Try Faust IV. They all have the ability play their instruments well and claiming otherwise is just dishonest. And just because something doesn't follow a traditional structure doesn't mean it has no structure at all. You know, while you might hear random metallic scraping noises on the intro of Meadow Meal, someone else might recognize that it's actually a prepared piano that transitions into "real" playing, which is a theme of the album.

>>69409429
well dude I really want to help you to be less angry
but I don't have the energy for that, sorry

>>69409469
>determining the state of another person's consciousness from a 4 line post.

Well done anon, you are special.

>>69409520
And a sequence of random numbers has some sort of structure too, right?

>>69409528
>having an opinion I don't agree with is anger

embarrassing tbqh

>>69409590
I'm not special, it's all thanks to you making it so glaringly obvious

you don't even seem to be able to realize that your experience isn't universal

>>69409620
>you don't even seem to be able to realize that your experience isn't universal

exactly my point. you actually think this? kek

>>69409590
Faust literally isn't random. What are you trying to achieve by being pointlessly stubborn?

>>69408983
No, I just spent too much time on /rym/ and it has destroyed my perception of taste.

File: 2dope.jpg (731KB, 2048x1536px) Image search: [Google]

731KB, 2048x1536px

>>69409659
/rym/ is a magical place, it's where the magic happens.

>>69409638
so you do believe that it is impossible to have opinions differing from your own
well done, see >>69409469

>>69409590
it has nothing to do with liking this or that, you imbecile, that's what you don't understand
it's about being so aggressive to people
you have such an altered vision of reality that you think that if someone disagrees with you it's because they are pretentious, they like bad music, they are evil
stop being defensive of your taste, nobody really cares about it
jesus how can a person be so little self aware

>>69409648
there is little to no difference

>>69409683
jesus christ you are insufferable. how thick can you be?

do you even realise the incredible irony in it? you've literally done the EXACT same thing

>>69409705
how fucking wrong can you be? the reason I'm like this is exactly because of people like you, who think they can diagnose some other person's mental state when they are instead just trying to discuss something.

>>69409800
>you've literally done the EXACT same thing


feel free to point me to where I have done this. The only thing I have been arguing in this thread is that your way of aggressively considering your own opinions to be factual is silly. Nothing more.

>>69409861
>so you do believe that it is impossible to have opinions differing from your own

you're engaging in the mentality you're accusing me of in this post. you're claiming that I have no self awareness and that I can't believe I'm wrong, but you won't accept that your """"diagnosis"""" is wrong.

you're literally trying to prove that a thought I have in my head doesn't exist because you say so, and you won't believe it's possible that you're wrong

hence:
so you do believe that it is impossible to have opinions differing from your own

>>69409800
>who think they can diagnose some other person's mental state
you know why I can
because you're not as unique as you think you are
because everyone goes through the avanteen hate phase
you claim "mu didn't change your taste" and that's only because you are afraid of trying new things
you're afraid of people calling you a pleb, you're intimidated by art you don't understand and instead of acting like an adult and face your issues you act like a baby on 4chan
you think you're the only one who dislikes "random sounds" or "random colors"? the whole majority of the world population are like you, why do you proud yourself at that?
again, because you're a fucking baby, who prefer calling names and pointing at others when you see something you don't like
grow a fucking chin, you did't choose not to like pollock, you chose not to face it like a man and go read about it
you're a thick skulled faggot who is proud of being ignorant

>>69410013
>says I need to get off 4chan
>thinks he can put a person into a box based on 5-10 plain text anonymous posts

>>69410045
that's how beige you are

>>69410064
see
>>69410045

>>69409989
>>69410045
how about you quit the "stop trying to diagnose me" shtick and start actually arguing your point?

File: image.png (326KB, 680x720px) Image search: [Google]

326KB, 680x720px

>>69409800
No, it literally was not random. A lot of planned techniques and concepts went into making the album.

>>69410080
see
>>69409429

>>69410084
it essentially gives the illusion of randomness though, because there are very few repetitive themes throughout the album

>>69410072
your point being?
you're still proud of being ignorant, you still misunderstand art, you still refuse to open any of your points for debate, and you still claims that you want to discuss...
discuss what? art? what do you know about art? you're stupid, ignorant, dumb, an imbecile who knows nothing other than the classics
you're a joke, you have no taste, you don't know anything about music... is that what the voices in your head keep telling you? because they are right

>>69410126
>it essentially gives the illusion of randomness
yeah, to someone as musically uneducated as you are.

>>69409989
except I was not. "it is impossible to have opinions differing from your own" is an accurate paraphrasing of your rejection of subjectivity in >>69409638

furthermore, it is plain from >>69409429 that you impose your own definition of what music is upon other with seemingly no awareness that others views can be just as legitimate.
>I just find it insulting to actual music that such things like faust can be considered good music or even music when it's lacking any semblance of song structure, rhythm and sometimes even melody.
in this statement right there you just say what you consider requirements for something to be music, as if it were factual. This is, again, a show of the behaviour we were discussing.

>>69410126
The album transitions back and forth between "traditional" forms of music (classical, jazz, rock) and "avant-garde" forms of music (tape music, early electronic inspired by Stockhausen, noise, field recordings, spoken word) pretty consistently. It also has recurring musical themes like the guitar accompaniment under the chanting in Meadow Meal being an inversion of the motif that plays during the Miss Fortune coda. They also use the same synthesizer techniques during juxtapositions. Faust is so planned out that it's basically a concept album. You're really attacking the wrong target.

>>69410183
It's obvious you are very troubled, I hope you find the help you need anon.

>>69410193
>been playing musical instruments for over ~15 years since I was 5-6 years old
>studied music theory
>played in classical ensembles
>listened to vary diverse types of music since the age of 4

>musically uneducated

>>69410245
>requirements for something to be music, as if it were factual

these are part the objective requirements for music. it's not my opinion, it is objectively fact.

definition of music:
>vocal, instrumental, or mechanical sounds having rhythm, melody, or harmony

>>69410266
as I said, it sounds more like noise. the whole effect of it is to give off an unmusical vibe, rather than musical. you could say it's some perverse aural experiment but it mostly does not resemble objective music.

>>69410839
>the whole effect of it is to give off an unmusical vibe
No.
>objective music
Here's where you went wrong.

>>69410962
>we want our album to musical
>let's make it sound vaguely like music!!!
yeah, no

>Here's where you went wrong.
here's where you went wrong:
>Here's where you went wrong.

>>69410993
what

>>69411005
stop giving the poor sod them (you)s m8, he doesn't deserve em

>>69411005
like clockwork

>>69411022
(You)

>>69411039
oh, ok
thanks for clarifying

>>69410839
Melody is simply a succession of ordered notes. Whether or not you find a particular succession of notes "satisfying" is a subjective experience, often based on the culture you grew up in. Not only that, but the first definition of music on dictionary.com includes tone color as an element of music, and you only need one element to be considered music. So you're wrong.

>>69411051
anytime friendo

>>69411057
kek. you're objectively wrong. by that definition any sequence of sound anywhere can be a melody, because everything is 'ordered' by something.

By your definition literally anything and everything is music.

>>69411171
and WHY is he objectively wrong? stop skirting the issue all the time

>>69411171
It's not my definition. It's the dictionary definition. You just tried to use official dictionary definitions as evidece that your perception of music is objective, so I looked up and cited a specific one. As it turns out, you end up wrong.

>>69411179
because not everything is music. it's just common sense.

using his argument you can stretch those definitions so far that anything that produces some sort of sound, whether audible by humans or not is music.

>>69411171
I have to interject here. You are making such an ass out of yourself this whole thread and it's almost commendable that you're still at it.

No, not everything is music because not everything makes sound, let alone sounds of various pitches. But yes, the sound of your washing machine running is considered music(check out Matmos II), because it creates an order of varied pitches and that case even sometimes has a set rhythm which is more than enough. A train horn is music. Your cat's meows are music. Open your mind and realize music is something that exists in real life. It doesn't have to be a fucking verse-chorus pop track by a fourpiece to be music

>>69411212
why can't everything be music
what exactly is wrong about it, besides that you disagree
come on, you can do this

>>69411222
But that might lead him to think the world is beautiful.

>>69411212
so wait a second here, your argument is the platitude "it's just common sense" and a slippery slope fallacy? is that all you've got?

I was really expecting more from someone claiming to have studied music theory

>>69411222
Quality numbers and quality content. Bravo tripfag

>>69411212
If you want to argue with dictionary.com, try sending them an email. I don't think they'll see your post here.

>>69411222
>>69411227
>>69411247
>>69411253
>>69411268
>>69411271
holy shit this circlejerking

yeah enjoy your dripping tap music you avant garde tards

>>69411320
And you enjoy your four chords, identical song structures, and lyrics about women.

>>69411320
Kek we will

You enjoy living in a fucking cage you witheld ignorant buffoon

>>69411320
we will, because unlike you, we actually enjoy a lot of things

>>69411348
>>69411349
>>69411351
>post 5 albums
>suddenly it's all I listen to

kek why are you so all dumb

by the way, actual music is objectively better than any avant garde toilet flush chalk board scratching "music" you listen to. you just sit in these containment threads because you're too autistic to enjoy real music.

>>69411393
more statements, still not arguments. boring!
at least make the b8 worthwhile you silly goose

>>69411419
>damage control
kek

>>69411393
>http://rateyourmusic.com/~TelegraphRoad

also stop with the false dichotomies: people don't have to choose between two categories of music you arbitrarily defined

>>69411439
>rock
>blues
>electronic
>jazz
>hip hop

>four chords, identical song structures, and lyrics about women

diagnosis tards once again wrong

>>69411470
You missed the point of my post. You made a strawman about "dripping tap" so I responded with one about what you listen to.

>>69411487
>le strawman meme
>damage control: full power enabled

he's not even trying anymore, how dull

>>69411552
Why do you feel so strongly against people using accurate vocabulary?

Here's the post with triggering terms removed.

>You missed the point of my post. You intentionally mischaracterized what I'm defending in order to make it easier to dismiss, so I responded by doing the same to you.

>>69411594
>thinly veiled strawman post
(You)

>>69411649
That doesn't make sense.

>>69411669
>>>/comprehension.com/

File: Capture1.png (79KB, 605x323px) Image search: [Google]

79KB, 605x323px

>>69409429
It's one thing if the album you are referring to is completely aleatoric in nature, but it's not. Faust's s/t has song structure throughout. Unconventional? Yes, but it's still there. The way you are describing that album just proves to everybody that you've just failed to understand it.

>>69411707
>he doesn't like it therefore he doesn't understand it

really makes you think

>>69411740
see
>>69411694

>>69411772
see
>>69411649

>>69411789
yeah, that describes >>69411740 pretty well too

>>69411819
yeah, that describes >>69411740 pretty well too

>>69411740
He wasn't just saying that Faust was a bad album. He was also saying that Faust was not music because it lacked song structure.

Opinions on music is subjective, but once you say that a piece doesn't have song structure when there is one, then you fail to understand it.

>>69411849
>faust
>structure
wewlad

>>69411924
>>69410266
>>69410084

>>69412009
you can find structure in anything if you look hard enough. if I went out and did a field recording by the side of the road you could point out structure where there actually isn't.

the only reason you think faust has structure is because you are able to repetitively listen to it and memorize it.

>>69412058
but that's all structure is, something human minds create on their own. it's not something that inherently exists boy

>>69412070
>