This is not music

>>69325107 agreed, this is architecture

You are reddit.

its an experience

no, it is devo

>>69325107
Ooooooo but it is!!

except that it literally is.

>>69325221
How?
explain how Sleep Dealer is music?

>>69325326
Any arranged sound is music.

>>69325326
It has rhythm and different notes in it that play? Not sure what you mean??? Please explain better?

>>69325407
>Samples of a gum commercials

>music

You idiot

>>69325392
>dot at the end
wew lad

File: homepage_large.8f4faae3.jpg (52KB, 319x319px) Image search: [Google]

52KB, 319x319px

More like this??

>>69325422
>the source dictates whether its music or not
ok D R O P P E D

>>69325392
This is something that everyone needs to understand

No, however, I don't listen to noise music

File: ....jpg (191KB, 583x1508px) Image search: [Google]

191KB, 583x1508px

>>69325427
>dot at the end
you cant be serious

>>69325422
Hey faggot. Classical is that way >>>

Also, you saying OPN's Replica not being music is an untrue statement and you're most likely trolling. Sampling contains and arrangement of sounds.

Fucking christ, I swear you music theory faggots are the cancer destroying this already shit shithole.

>>69325422
What relevance does it have where the samples came from? Can you seriously not hear melody in that track? It's repetitive, sure, but it's full of melody

>>69325452
if he actually thinks that replica isnt music you can bet that he doesnt listen to music. im sure he just got off the boat from /r/music and listened to the first album he saw posted here

>>69325470
not op but damn, calm down dude. you must have some chili pepper fitted in your anus

>>69325422
imagine being this close minded, opn isnt even hard to get

>>69325452
>Sampling contains and arrangement of sounds.
>What's R+Seven
Wow.
Just stop and play a instrument for once.

File: cestne.jpg (34KB, 378x264px) Image search: [Google]

34KB, 378x264px

>>69325107
This anon be bringing some next level critique René Magritte style.

>>69325107
And who the hell are you to say it isn't?

>>69325429
Try Oneohtrix Point Never

>>69325107
Yeah it's a fucking picture

>>69325427
well thats how you are typically supposed to end a sentence.

>>69325596
Why is /mu/ being so fucking shit today? Jesus

>>69325392
All sound is inherently arranged by time.

Therefore, all sound is music.

>>69325623
not in the rapid ways of communication of the internet

>>69325650
kill yourself asshole

>>69325658
please rapidly communicate a follow-up to this post less than a minute after posting it

quickly now

File: Reaction84.gif (302KB, 307x281px) Image search: [Google]

302KB, 307x281px

>>69325635
Oh buck up, I was only joking. And sorry about your shitty day here, not everyone's an asshole, but most people here are.
As for more albums like that one, I'm sorry but I've never listened to it. Useless reply, my bad

>>69325674
how about you first

File: giphy (6).gif (1019KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

1019KB, 500x500px

>>69325690

>>69325650
damn...

>>69325429
james ferraro - human story 3

>"Mooooom! Anon is dictating what is and isn't music again!!"

>>69325724.
>more than 4 minutes later.
>rapid.
"no.".

>>69325757
your timer is wrong

>>69325422
Name 3 favorite albums

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hiwi7d0f91Y

>this isn't music

>>69325763.
here:.
>>69325724.
>>69325658.
you count.

>>69325422
but the gum commercials have music in them.

File: giphy (4).gif (175KB, 250x300px) Image search: [Google]

175KB, 250x300px

>>69325819

>>69325889.
>took 4+ minutes to count.
anon, that is so rapid.

>>69325452
Sampling was pioneered by classical artists dumbass.

>>69325889
>>69325909
what the fuck are you guys doing

>>69325930
when you are done with that sentence, please make sure to put a dot (denoted: .) on the end of it.

lmao

opn sucks fyi

>>69327321
explain this

Serious love/hate based question on this album:

So like yeah I get that tracks like Sleep Dealer and the title track are legit amazing with heavy sample manipulation to create something organic that moves around a lot. But most of the tracks on this album are pretty static or have awkward attempts at being songs like the McDonalds one. Is there something I am missing when most of the tracks just drone on the same few chords the whole time without change in texture maybe till like the end where they'll have a cool bit or something?

>>69325615
underrated

>>69328883
Do u listen to or understand any other drone music?

>>69329041
Yeah, I appreciate like Boris or Tim Hecker for example. Glenn Branca, too if he counts. But with a few of those guys, even if it appears like they are playing the same exact note, it's often microtonal differences in each time those instances of the note(s) are played that makes it work for me so it never gets boring. My thing with Replica is that the lesser tracks on it feel too repetitive with not even slight variation unless I am missing something.

>>69329257
Well the reason I asked is usually I enjoy this album in the same way I enjoy drone music, not by waiting for something to happen but really just sinking into and enjoying the sounds. There usually are small variations in what is going on so it doesn't get too repetitious.

>>69325141
word
>>69325650
Now you're getting it!

You're right, it's electroautistic musique.

>>69325635
Kiddies are off from school for Thanksgiving break.

>>69329257
This is someone else

I want to say that you haven't given it (Replica) enough attention, but that's probably presumptuous of me. I can't actually find many instances on the album where songs are static. Most tracks have A LOT going on, and flow pretty freely between ideas. Maybe parts of Nassau and Submersible are samey, but that's pretty much all I could find.

I kind of don't know what to say other than, you're mistaken about the sameyness of the record. This thing has a lot going on.

>>69329320
>>69330209
Nvm you guys are right. Shit, I remembered giving it a fully attentive listen the first time, then loving it, then repeat listens I didn't like it as much except a few tracks. The smaller changes in layering with how sounds often get introduced in the album doesn't work well in the loud public places I often go through everyday when I do have music on. Makes sense, considering I wouldn't listen to say....Gas in a similar situation either for similar reasons, but appreciate the artist in a quieter time/place.

Perhaps something to think about for those that aren't feeling this record and maybe find the most quiet moment they can to fully pick up on everything.

>>69325107
The fuck is it called? I'll listen to it and exclaim my opinion. Once done, you will delete this thread and forever stfu.