Why does this album get panned ?

>>69216475
I don't know, p4k seems pretty unphair in that regard.

>>69216485
Cake

Exile In Guyville, 8/10
Whip-Smart, 6.5/10
Whitechocolatespaceegg, 7.5/10
Liz Phair (2003), 5/10
Somebody's Miracle (2005), 4/10
Funstyle (2010), 4/10

>>69216475
Because it's not very good. If you mean why's it panned so much, that's because she was an Indie darling, and this was seen as a betrayal by the likes of Pitchfork.

>>69216508
Whip-Smart is a 9/10

>>69216475
Because she want from Indie Darling to Generic Pop Star.
Basically a sold out

>>69216526
>>69218817
this. Its not actually a 0/10 but p4k is trying to make a point essentially

>Liz Phair [Capitol, 2003] A

https://www.robertchristgau.com/xg/music/phair-03.php

based christgau shows what's up again

>>69219235
Fuck off with this forced meme

>>69219267
why does Matt LeMay have more credibility than christgau again?

>>69219289
>paying attention to music critics
when will this meme die

>>69219325
>in a thread about music critics
>complains that it's about music critics

>>69219342
is there a better place to complain about music critics than a thread about music critics?

>>69219184
what a terrible website lol

>>69219389
probably not

File: 1434424762368.jpg (15KB, 364x378px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 364x378px

>>69219499
well alright then