Expectations vs reality thread

>>69062523
can't say I understand what disco has to do with close to the edge at all

>>69062544
it's not disco in particular, but unlike other prog bands, "Close to the edge" aged like a carton of milk from the same time.
It feels way too 70's, and when you can tell the decade a music was made when you hear it, it is shit.

>>69062607
>when you can tell the decade a music was made when you hear it, it is shit.

it's hard to imagine a wronger statement

>>69062630
a specific decade.

>>69062607
not sure about that one friendo

File: Brain Salad Surgery.jpg (892KB, 1902x802px) Image search: [Google]

892KB, 1902x802px

>>69062607
Well, I can tell ItCotCK is from the late 60s/early 70s, so I guess that album is shit too.

>>69062607
so you don't think that music can be a way of experiencing the time period that it was made in? music has to sound modern or it gets tossed in the garbage? how about books and films?

learn to appreciate art

>>69062861
(You)

>>69062788
Same, I expected this like spooky atonal math rock album and instead got Big Black trying to edgy.

>>69062837
>the only correct post in the thread

>>69063177
fuck forgot to remove the >

>>69063273
My boi

IIIIIIIIIIII LIKE TOO MUCH THE
RAAAAAAAIN THE POWER OF MY
BRAAAAAAAIN THE SUNSHINE AND THE OOOOOOOOOOPEN ROOOOOOOOOAD AHEEEEEAAAAD OOOOOF MEEEEEEEEEEEEE

>>69063273
needs more references to pedophilia in the what i got

>>69062817
>Liking things that have not stood the test of time

>>69063517
ooh boy aren't you looking forward to knowing which Romantic composers you're allowed to listen to, in about 50 years?

>>69062681
So you would rather amend this to the (only slightly) less wrong:
>when you can tell the music was made in the 70s when you hear it, it is shit.

>>69063618
I imagine it's probably none of them by this person's standards.

>>69062523
kys fucko

>>69062788
Sure is pleb out today...

>>69062837
It's more of a grower than any of their other albums, but it is pretty epic.

>>69062800
accurate

File: surfs up.png (2MB, 1650x656px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1650x656px

>>69062523

>>69063872
THERE'S A RIOT GOIN ON

File: 1478905547219.jpg (5KB, 202x202px) Image search: [Google]

5KB, 202x202px

>>69062544
>>69062788
>>69062800
>>69063177
>>69063188
>>69063700